Denied a lost luggage claim on a technicality — can you help?

By | December 27th, 2016

When Kelly Paulson’s luggage is lost, she follows the airline’s instructions but is left with no luggage and unexpected expenses. Why? She doesn’t have an “official” claim number. Now what?

Question: I recently flew on KLM Royal Dutch Airlines from Seattle to Oslo, Norway, via Amsterdam. When I arrived in Oslo, I found out that my luggage and that of 70 other passengers was missing. There was only one KLM representative at the airport. Because of the number of passengers waiting in line, we were instructed to file the missing property report online, and that we would be compensated for the replacement cost of necessary items.

After filing the report, I received a confirmation message that, because of technical problems, a temporary file reference number had been issued. It stated that a final Property Irregularity Report would be sent to me via email when the system was back up and running. I did not receive one, and it has become the source of my complaint.

I spent $202 on toiletries and a change of clothing. When I inquired about my luggage with KLM, I was again told that I would receive compensation, and that the airline would deliver my bag to the hotel when it was found. That did not happen. After waiting three days with no word from KLM, I had to pay for transportation back to the airport to check on the status of my luggage. A representative located it in a storage room. I also lost money on a prepaid tour of the Oslo Opera House, because of the time it took at the airport. I would like to be reimbursed for that, as well as my transportation costs.

Related story:   Delta's Ausband: When it comes to customer service, "we want to be even better"

When I returned home, I filed another claim and was informed that Delta was now handling the KLM cases for those who reside in the U.S. I emailed copies of my receipts, airline tickets, and KLM’s confirmation message and temporary file claim number to a representative of Delta. I have been unable to get this issue resolved for several months. The representative said that she was unable to get the reimbursement approved without an official missing property number.

I contacted KLM a couple of weeks ago and have not received a response. I need your help! I just want to get reimbursed for the money I spent due to the airline losing my luggage. — Kelly Paulson, Seattle

Answer: This case is a reminder of how important a paper trail is in resolving a problem. Companies want proof, and the “customer’s word” does not go very far. You have done a great job of communicating with KLM and Delta and have been very patient with a problem that has continued for almost four months.

You were denied a lost luggage claim on a technicality, even though you followed standard procedure by initiating a missing property report the day your luggage was lost. The error resulted from a computer glitch with KLM.


You were left to deal with the problem, because KLM never issued you a final Property Irregularity Report number. If KLM was able to provide a temporary file reference number, there should be a record of that in its system. Otherwise, it should have given you an error message that your claim was not processed.

You are justified in asking for a reimbursement of expenses. According to KLM’s delayed or lost baggage policy,

If your bag was lost, damaged or something was missing from it, please contact KLM Customer Care to request reimbursement of expenses and/or compensation.

It is disappointing that KLM did not notify you when your luggage was found. It should have offered to deliver it to your hotel. Instead, after three days had passed with no word on your luggage, you had to pay for transportation back to the airport to find out if it had been located. It also cut into your touring time.

Related story:   Afflicted by B&B burnout

What is most disconcerting is how Delta handled your request for reimbursement. There were 20 emails between you and the same Delta representative. Instead of sending you one message with a list of what Delta required (like a copy of your receipts, airline tickets, reference number, number of bags, what airline you flew on, and more), the representative sent only one request at a time and then asked again for information you had already sent.

Even though you forwarded a screenshot of KLM’s confirmation of a report being filed, along with the temporary file number assigned, the representative said that KLM does not issue temporary claim numbers. This went on for several months. Your responses were always pleasant and concise.

It looks like Delta’s representative was not willing to take the initiative to get this problem resolved. Having Delta handle correspondence addressed to KLM probably did not help either.

Sometimes a successful resolution depends on the person you are dealing with and how much effort they are willing to put forth on your behalf. If you are unable to come to a reasonable solution with a company representative, escalate your request to a higher level. We provide a list of company executives and their contact information on our company contacts section.

When consumers reach an impasse with a company and don’t know what to do, they turn to our advocates. What many may not know is that these fine advocates working behind the scenes are offering their time at no cost to the consumer. They review the matter objectively and attempt to negotiate a reasonable solution.

Related story:   Is this the beginning of the end of airline fees?

We are glad that you chose to reach out to our advocates on our advocacy site. They jumped in and started working on your behalf and did a great job of helping you resolve this problem. Delta agreed to issue you a refund for $202 and gave you a travel voucher for $100.



  • Harvey-6-3.5

    Good job in helping. Other than waiting for the person at the airport to help, or escalating to an executive contact, does anyone have any specific tips for dealing with this sort of computer glitch.

  • fshaff

    Little confused why Delta was handling this. Was this a code share flight?

  • MF

    I wonder if it would be fair to say that this site, “Works for the airlines?” After all, the airlines get their thornier customer service issues fixed without having to spend money on another layer of CSR oversight. Perhaps they never will, but the airlines ought to at least send Chris a Christmas card thanking him for doing their work for them, at no cost to the shareholders. And let us not forget this site’s contribution to reputation management – rules-driven heartless airlines do the right thing occasionally, when asked to do so politely, but not too often or consistently to impact their bottom line.

  • Ben

    “On a technicality”? Hardly. A technicality is if the consumer misspelled something on the form.

    This is a combination of mis-handling of luggage, poor customer service at the Oslo airport, technical failure of the KLM systems, and very poor customer service by Delta. A $100 travel voucher doesn’t seem to be sufficient compensation for the hassle.

  • Bill___A

    Good job by elliott.org but shameful how this was handled by the airlines.

  • BubbaJoe123

    I believe that KLM outsources a large portion of their customer service operations for US customers to Delta.

  • mk

    I had my luggage lost for 3 days in Europe too! shortest version of the story: no $, no compensation– U got your luggage back after 3 days! be happy! that was my compensation per the airlines!

  • gpx21dlr

    I wish we didn’t have to jump through all these hoops for reimbursement. PITA.

  • Pegtoo

    20 emails to the same rep who gave one instruction each time. How do they find such sadistic employees? Compensation was not nearly enough.

  • DepartureLevel

    Couldn’t think of a worse scenario. Why would they have any “concern” for a customer that flew one of their codeshare or alliance partners ?

  • PsyGuy

    She should have gotten more under EU261.

  • PsyGuy

    TSA reject applicants.

  • PsyGuy

    I think they owe him something closer to a case of scotch, and good scotch.

  • Mark

    EU 261 doesn’t give you any special coverage for lost luggage. It just states that airlines have liability for damages up to 1000 SDRs (~$1300), based on actual costs incurred.

  • PsyGuy

    $1,300 sounds a lot better than what the LW got.

  • jsn55

    This story is nothing but amazing. I would have lost my mind. Great work for this KLM traveller!

  • “What is most disconcerting is how Delta handled your request for reimbursement. There were 20 emails between you and the same Delta representative. Instead of sending you one message with a list of what Delta required (like a copy of your receipts, airline tickets, reference number, number of bags, what airline you flew on, and more), the representative sent only one request at a time and then asked again for information you had already sent.”

    Doesn’t this just make your blood boil?

    Kudos to the original poster for staying calm and doing due diligence throughout.

  • The Original Joe S

    Sending that info to the Company’s HMFIC might get the toad hammered, but I doubt it. They don’t care.

  • The Original Joe S

    KLM looks like another “avoid” airline.

We want your feedback.Your opinion is important to us. Here's how you can share your thoughts:
  • Send us a letter to the editor. We'll publish your most thoughtful missives in our daily newsletter or in an upcoming post.
  • Leave a message on one of our social networks. We have an active Facebook page, a LinkedIn presence and a Twitter account. Every story on this site is posted on those channels. The conversation ranges from completely unmoderated (Twitter) to moderated (Facebook and LinkedIn).
  • Post a question to our help forums or ask our advocates for a hand through our assistance intake form. Please note that our help forum is not a place for debate. It's there primarily to assist readers with a consumer problem.
  • If you have a news tip or want to report an error or omission, you can email the site publisher directly. You may also contact the post's author directly. Contact information is in the author tagline.