TSA Watch: They never warned us about the octogenarian jihadists

The 91-year-old woman was blind and in a wheelchair, but that didn’t stop the TSA agents in Seattle from giving her a thorough screening. A very thorough screening.

“They made her get out of the wheelchair,” her daughter told me. “They made her walk to the body scanner, stand and then walk through. They absolutely would not let her have just a pat-down. Then they proceeded to take everything from her carry-on and wipe it down for explosives. I was furious, but feared saying anything because all I wanted to do was get her home.”

The mother and daughter, who were flying to St. Louis last week, asked me not to use their names because they feared the agency might give them even more of a once-over on their return flight. And I would normally call the TSA for a comment (and it would deny that it forced a 91-year-old into its poorly-tested scanners, of course) but the TSA has bigger problems.

Her name is Lenore Zimmerman, and she is the 4-foot-11, 110-pound, grandmother who alleges she was strip-searched at JFK. When she asked if she could forgo the advanced image technology screening equipment, fearing it might interfere with her defibrillator, two female agents reportedly escorted her to a private room and began to remove her clothes.

“I was outraged,” Zimmerman, a retired receptionist, told the New York Daily News.

TSA vehemently denies the incident ever occurred. Zimmerman is threatening to sue the agency. In the meantime, another elderly woman has come forward to say she, too, was strip-searched at JFK.

This is hardly a new accusation against the blueshirts. Who can forget the 95-year-old cancer patient in a wheelchair who was allegedly asked by TSA agents to remove her adult diaper this summer?

“It’s something I couldn’t imagine happening on American soil,” said her daughter, Jean Weber. “Here is my mother, 95 years old, 105 pounds, barely able to stand, and then this.”

Just before Thanksgiving last year, a Florida ABC News affiliate reported on another grandmother who consistently received an aggressive pat-down whenever she flew, presumably because of a knee implant.

“I feel molested,” Antonia Riggs Miernikshe told the TV station. “I’d like to go take a shower with Lysol (afterwards).”

Is it any wonder that the grandparents of the world feel as if they have a target on their backs whenever they fly? Or that they have opted for another means of transportation, as Beverly Dale has.

“This year I took Amtrak to Texas and Chicago from Philadelphia instead of flying,” she told me. “Sure, I would have preferred having more time with my grandsons instead of using it for train rides but I refuse to go along with the absurdity of allowing strangers to look at my body, rummage through my luggage and then treat me with disrespect.”

The real question is: What is it about our grandparents that sets the TSA off?

I mean, how difficult can it be to see that the Lenore Zimmermans of the world pose absolutely no threat to an aircraft? That the odds of cancer patients in wheelchairs and grannies with artificial knees trying to blow a plane to smithereens are less than zero?

TSA screening is moving away from the one-size-fits-all approach — kids under 12 can now keep their shoes on, for example — but apparently elderly passengers are exempt from those common-sense policies. Grandma and grandpa are treated as if they are probable jihadists, even though their wheelchairs, implants and adult diapers tell us otherwise.

Lawmakers are busy carving out exceptions to TSA’s screening procedures. Just last week, they decided military personnel and their dependents should be exempt from some airport screening, despite strong evidence that they should be searched like everyone else. Already, crewmembers, airport employees, lawmakers and dignitaries are allowed to skip some or all of TSA’s screening.

Why not give the octogenarians in wheelchairs, who are just trying to get to Palm Beach for the winter, a little break?

Come on. What’s one more exception?

(Photo: Marcel Oost erwijk/Flickr)

  • Kiwigram

    I believe that the TSA should be done away with all together.  Why should we have to put up with all of the garbage they put us through.  Other countries don’t do this.  Why the most “advanced” country in the world degrade their people like this, is beyond my understanding.  Just to keep the record straight, I have been flying around this world for 40 years.

  • frostysnowman

    Osama Bin Ladin said many times that part of his strategy was to weaken/ruin the US economy. 

  • frostysnowman

    Except once you are in the security area, you are not allowed to leave without possibly being arrested and fined a significant amount of money.  Passengers can’t just change their minds about travel on a whim without also being suspected of being a terrorist who is changing their plans because of the security procedures.

  • Blip66

    “You don’t even know me yet you blanket me with a generalization such as that.”

    This is hilarious! Coming from someone who freely admits not two posts up

    “Yeah, let’s make it about skin color…”

    Do YOU know everyone with the skin color you are so afraid while making blanket accusatory statements?

  • belmal33

    The other part of the strategy was to humiliate the American public by making us walk barefoot  on dirty floors, give-up out toothpaste and mouthwash,  and become haters.

  • Nparmelee2001

    I’m 79 and have a knee replacement.  I get felt up every time.  They no longer use the wands.  What am I supposed to have that’s not metallic on my body that those who aren’t stopped don’t have?

  • Anonymous

    Probably not Political Correctness, but they damn sure hate bad press.

    Also, get a real username.

  • Daisymae

    AARP is well funded. Why aren’t they defending the elderly from TSA?

    Their magazine has a section called What an Outrage. Why haven’t any of these atrocities committed against the elderly appeared in their magazine?

  • Superlarz

    just wondering what type of TSA screening would have prevented that

  • Eric

    I’m planning on voting against every single incumbent in the next election

  • Eric

    What’s your address.  I’ll send you your sheep costume.

  • Nigel

    I voted no, but only becauyse I think the procedures should be the same for everybody. Crewmembers, airport employees, lawmakers and dignitaries should NOT allowed to skip some or all of TSA’s screening, then maybe when the lawmakers etc know what it is really like to submit to the TSA, just maybe some reasonable limits and controls be placed on TSA. I can only hope

  • Nigel

    Airline and airport employees can be bribed or blackmailed or even threatened into doing something to help a terrorist in spite of previous background checks.

  • http://DontScan.us Wimpie

    “Should TSA revise its screening procedures for elderly passengers?”

    NO -They should revise it for EVERYONE!

    The TSA should be folded up and moved to North Korea!

  • Eric

    While they MIGHT have the authority to search vehicles entering an airport, they do not have the authority to set-up a road block on I-95 and start randomly searching cars.  If the state police can’t do it without your consent or a warrant, then neither can the TSA.

    Actually, I’d love to see them try it, because people would get so PO’d that Congress would finally pull the plug on the TSA.

  • Susan N

    Well, the guy getting on the plane landing in Detroit was coming from Amsterdam – they would (should) be the ones responsible for letting him on, without anything to do with the TSA or US anything.

  • nunya

    Type your comment here.The TSA is diametrically opposed to the very reason this country was founded.  Freedom from unreasonable search and seizure is a fundamental right that we have mistakenly given up under the false pretense that the TSA is going to be able to do squat about a terrorist who truly wants to harm an airplane.  The TSA is a joke and makes me concerned about what other rights we will blindly give up just because our “government” says we have to.

  • Chris

    I’m amazed at the 528 persons who answered yes to your question, and am only hoping that because it was sunday, they had switched their brains off !!!
    What you need is not individual procedures per categories of flying public, but rather one procedure that would enhance safety while allowing everyone to travel safely and without hassles !…

  • Chris

    I’m amazed at the 528 persons who answered yes to your question, and am only hoping that because it was sunday, they had switched their brains off !!!
    What you need is not individual procedures per categories of flying public, but rather one procedure that would enhance safety while allowing everyone to travel safely and without hassles !…

  • Anonymous

    A second victim has come forward. She was also strip searched the day after Mrs Zimmerman.

    TSA strip-searches 88-year-old Ruth Sherman

    http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2011/12/04/another-elderly-woman-says-she-was-exposed-at-kennedy-airport/

  • Anonymous

    A second victim has come forward. She was also strip searched the day after Mrs Zimmerman.

    TSA strip-searches 88-year-old Ruth Sherman

    http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2011/12/04/another-elderly-woman-says-she-was-exposed-at-kennedy-airport/

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    Eric, they’re called VIPR teams, and yes they have already been used at train stations, bus stations, subways, ferries, and highways.  They have searched people “at random.”  It’s a further — and entirely predictable — abuse that has spread from the airports.  Predictable because so many people have shown they’re willing to put up with it.  As long as that’s the case, nothing will change, except to get worse.

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    “Why? Because I do what I’m supposed to do.”

    You think that’s the magic trick, eh, Kovsky?  Keep drinking that Kool-Aid.

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    Thank you, Blip66.  You are correct, but good luck trying to convince Americans who think they’re so “special.”  Racism is alive and well in this country, always has been.  And since 9/11, it’s gone off the charts, as you can see by some of the comments here.

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    No, they don’t hate bad press. They ignore it.  They get it all the time and just repeat their Orwellian doublespeak. “Proper procedures were followed.”  ”We didn’t do ___________.”  ”That didn’t happen.”

    They lie.  Again and again.  It’s what they do.  And they get away with it because so many Americans are willing to put up with it.  Therefore, the abuse will continue.

    “The limits of tyrants are prescribed by the endurance of those whom they oppress.” -Frederick Douglass

  • Jholland

    I am 59, and I have to use a wheelchair to descend and ascend ramps. I fly about 6 times a month, as I travel for my job. Every time I go through security I am put through the xray scanner, where I have to hold my arms over my head, patted down and made to remove my shoes, and jacket. Then I am ALWAYS pulled aside for a double body pat down. I am 90 pounds 5 feet tall.  I think they have something against wheelchair people.

  • cjr

    Pilots have shown up drunk. They’ve shown up sick, tired, fed up with their jobs.

    And those possibilities are also a much greater threat to an airplane than terrorism.

  • Sommer Gentry

    The TSA wants you to think that, frostysnowman.  While they will give you a lengthy hassle, the TSA has absolutely no right to forcibly search you.  They have never even dared to fine a passenger (civil fine by the way, not a criminal one) for defending his/her body and rights from their filthy molesting hands.  Yes, you can and should plan to change your travel plans if the TSA decides to start dishing out sexual abuse that you won’t tolerate.  I did it last week.  No fine, no charges, nothing but protecting my safety and walking back upstairs to reschedule my flight from another nearby airport.

  • Bill949

    Yup they will be crawling out of the woodwork now

  • Cliffordpwoodrick

    As a 75 year old retired naval officer senior, I have cut back my flights from six flights per year to one round trip per year as I am tired of being groped. I have metal knees and a metal hip so I set off the alarms whenever I get near the scanner. Even after I go through the X-Ray machine I get felt up. So now I will drive and protest by not flying. If enough people do this perhaps the government will notice and get real. In Israel, I did not get groped so why here in the USA?

    Have a wonderful day – Cliff 

  • Lindabator

    Timothy McVey wasn’t muslim.

  • Anonymous

    Who do you go after.  The “Underwear Bomber” was Nigerian.  The population of Nigeria is about 50/50 Muslim/Christian.  It’s not always possible to discern one’s religion via name either.  The largest Muslim population in a non-Islamic country is India and again, a person’s name may not be a good indicator of religion.

    So perhaps anyone who is South Asian or African needs to get specific scrutiny in case they’re Muslim?  The problem is that generalizations about race or name simply are silly in this day and age.

    The serious issue is that Islamic terrorist networks are now deliberately trying to recruit converts who don’t “fit the profile”.  These are people like Jose Padilla and Richard Reed, or people of distinctly European ancestry such as “Jihad Jane”.  The suggestion has been for people to actually monitor individual behavior rather than looking for inherent traits that might have little to do with one’s likelihood to be part of a terrorist network.

  • http://twitter.com/xrae Rae A

    We took Amtrak to a funeral last week. Last minute round-trip tickets, $210 for two people. Parked, for free, next to the tracks. No security searches, no baggage limits. Free to get up and move around the train as often as we wanted. Lots of legroom and lots of overhead storage. It’s a great way to travel. 

  • Traveling man

    Profiling….that would be the worse thing to have happen. Srs can be terrorist also. Be careful what you wish for.

  • Wiseword

    What people need to realize is that what is happening is analogous to Germany in  the 1920′s and 1930′s. First came the Brown Shirts, crude, ignorant bullies. TSA, anyone? They were wiped out by the Black Shirts, sleek, smooth, sophisticated, viciously evil.Nominations, please.

  • Daisymae

    When will advocacy groups start to complain about the profiling and abuse of elderly and disabled travelers? I’ve been anxiously waiting for AARP and groups representing the disabled to say or do something. The silence is deafening.

  • Bill

    AARP and many advocacy groups (not individuals) generally have their own personal interests before those of the group they are trying to represent.

  • Guest

    Its crazy what they are doing.  My 90 year old father, a WWII vet (purple heart bronze star) who can barely walk with a walker is forced to walk through the machines and then patted down because his artificial hip sets them off.  An elderly friend with an artificial leg is required to take his pants down and remove the leg when he goes through security.  He finally got so fed up he stopped traveling.

  • Daisymae

    It’s so ironic that your father fought to end the barbaric rule of the Nazis and now is treated to the same oppressive Nazi-like abuse by his own government.

    Those depraved Bozos in Blue that treated your father with such disrespect should be bowing down to him in gratitude. Without your father and men like him they would be on the business end of the same treatment coming from a person wearing a swastika.

  • SusanL

    I’m not elderly, but am a disabled traveler.  Because of my treatments I’m a very bald lady.  I’ve worn various hats and scarves through domestic and international airports with no problem until last week.  I was traveling from O’Hare to Knoxville and was made to remove my hat before going through the detector.  It didn’t bother me so much to go through bald, since they only reason I wear hats in public is to keep the stares and comments (you wouldn’t believe what people say or ask) down.  Still, I’m sure many in my situation would be mortified.  I wonder if they ask those wearing wigs to remove them?  On the return trip, I asked in Knoxville if I needed to remove my hat and they said “goodness no”.  I mentioned what happened at O’Hare and was told “Shame on them in Chicago.” 

    Just another anecdote about inconsistency, but really, it’s difficult enough traveling with disabilities so I hope they find a way to make it easier on the elderly.

  • fellow flyer

    I am a 59 yr. old woman,average white person appearance and have been subject to additional screending the last 4 of 6 flights I have taken. Various airlines, various locations. Do I look so average that I am suspicious? Of course, I would trade some of my dignity for safety but I am also getting tired of being singled out. At least Orlando had a sense of humor about it and let me do “Mickey ears” during the body scanner part.