Road trip update: What would you drive across the country?

I am not allowed to show you any pictures of our 2007 Honda Accord.

But imagine, if you will, what a high-mileage vehicle that regularly shuttles three high-energy kids between school, music lessons and play dates looks like, and you’ll have a good idea.

If Mater from the Pixar film Cars comes to mind … well, you’re not that far off.

Our car has been loved to death. There are candy wrappers and empty water bottles strewn across the back seat, and I can’t remember the last time it was washed. Right now, it looks like it survived a riot in London. It’s embarrassing. Which is why Kari won’t let me show you the car.

But that’s not what really concerns me.

We’ll be lucky if it makes it up to Canada next week. Our October itinerary in Florida — sure. Texas and New Mexico? I don’t know. I wouldn’t want to scale a mountain road in a blizzard with this set of wheels.

Question is, what are we going to do about it? We’ve had some very informal discussions with car manufacturers who are watching this project with interest. It would be nice to have a car company sponsor our trip, of course. But they’d give us what they want us to drive. And that doesn’t really answer the question of what we should drive.

What would you take on a cross-country trip?

Here are the candidates, as I see it.

The RV.
Ahh, think of all the room! In one of these road-yachts, we wouldn’t have to worry about finding accommodations every night. We’d just pull out our beds and — voila! — we’re good to go. But wait! The gas bills would kill us. And it wouldn’t eliminate the need for a smaller car to get us around once we’re at our destination. Still, I wouldn’t mind it.

The minivan
You can’t sleep in one of these, but the fuel bills are more manageable. On the downside, it’s a minivan, which every parent I know drives. A minvan symbolizes conformity, which is the last thing we want to be. But still, if we found the right minivan, we might feel differently.

The SUV.
We’re not really SUV types, either. But you never know.

The hatchback.
After our third child was born, we seriously considered buying a hatchback. But alas, on a writer’s salary, even that kind of upgrade wasn’t possible. I’ve traveled across America in a station wagon with my family (I have four siblings) and although it was crowded, it worked. It would be more fuel-efficient than a minivan or RV, but still give us enough horses to get over the mountain.

The sedan.
This is our default choice: Keeping the Accord and hoping for the best. And also, making sure our AAA dues are paid, which, I can assure you, they will be. I have to say, I love driving a sedan. You feel the road. You make frequent stops and get a chance to see the country. You’re not wasting precious fossil fuel. Downside? (Other than our trusty Honda breaking down?) Not enough room, insufficient power, and mild claustrophobia.

So these are the decisions we’re faced with. What would you drive across the country? Are there any particular car manufacturers we should talk to about a sponsorship, or should we just stick with what we have?

Full disclosure: I’ve driven a Honda since 1992, and before that, a Ford. Loved them both. My switch to Honda was made largely for price reasons, and not because I disliked my Ford. I’ve had the privilege of renting a lot of other cars in the meantime, and the two standouts are a Jaguar I rented from Hertz a few years ago (oh, that was fun!) and a Ford Explorer, which was a pleasure to drive but guzzled gas like there was no tomorrow.

Most of all, we don’t want to get lost in the crowd on this trip. We’re looking for something unique, not generic. On a road trip, a car is the sixth member of the family, so this decision is almost like adopting a new baby.

(Photo: Nick K/Flickr)

  • http://www.bytehead.org/blog/ Bryan “bytehead” Price

    I remember when I was 12 or 13, and we went on a four (six?) week trip from Ohio to Washington state (where my sister was living), and then back through Denver (more family) and finally back home.  We took the family sedan, which was fine with the V8 and good air-conditioner, and me being the only kid, only to have to sit out a day in Illinois because my dad had to rebuild the carburetor. No other car conditions occurred, though, no flats, nothing like that.

    I wouldn’t hesitate to take my 2006 Hyundai.  Then again, MY kids were just about out of high school when we bought it new, and the only major thing we’ve had go wrong with it was the fuel pump (for which it is in the garage for right now. Grrrr…  My own fault for letting the gas drop too low).

  • http://www.bytehead.org/blog/ Bryan “bytehead” Price

    I remember when I was 12 or 13, and we went on a four (six?) week trip from Ohio to Washington state (where my sister was living), and then back through Denver (more family) and finally back home.  We took the family sedan, which was fine with the V8 and good air-conditioner, and me being the only kid, only to have to sit out a day in Illinois because my dad had to rebuild the carburetor. No other car conditions occurred, though, no flats, nothing like that.

    I wouldn’t hesitate to take my 2006 Hyundai.  Then again, MY kids were just about out of high school when we bought it new, and the only major thing we’ve had go wrong with it was the fuel pump (for which it is in the garage for right now. Grrrr…  My own fault for letting the gas drop too low).

  • Jan Ross

    If someone is going to sponsor your trip, go for the RV. I have always thought a road trip in an RV would be a blast. Once, I traveled across country with three women in a 1979 Pinto. THAT was fun.

  • ghost

    You might want to look at the 2012 Ford Focus 5-door hatchback.  Gets about 36 highway and 26 city.  Seats 5 with good storage.

  • Linda

    Here goes!! I LOVE our 2010 GMC Terrain.  It is extremely safe with 6 airbags; great on mileage; handles like a sedan and has all wheel drive.  Safety is a big feature for me as I raised and traveled with 4 children and now have 2 granchildren .  The Onstar is so great and you have immediate help if needed and can call anywhere with the satellite .  Should you have an accident; they call for help and it is immediate.  SOoooooo- that is what I would recommend you to consider as your next car.  No, I do not sell cars nor do I get a kick back for this information!! HA!
    Linda

  • Christophe

    I might spoil your dreams, but what if you started with a good car wash and see what the car look like ??? 2007 is not that old !…
    I’ve got a Toyota Rav4 from 2002 and I would still consider driving it long distance !…

  • P.J.

    The best choice for driving cross country is a bit different than a vehicle for every day local use.

    Your best bet for a cross country trek is a European s
    edan, as large as you can afford or fathom. It will be the MOST comfortable for a LONG trip.

  • Tom

    Heh CE, none of those would be my choice but then again I have grandkids almost as old as your car lol.

    If I was staying on good roads & not going into the dirt, & I didn’t need to carry much luggage for my wife & I, there is no doubt I’d take my Vette.

    It’s comfortable & gets 25mpg on the freeway & is of course, fast.

    If off road is in the offing, I’d take my Alaska cadillac, one of my 4×4 pickups with 4 doors.  Still gets 19 on the freeway & 15 in town but will go anywhere I need to go.

    Those rice burners are to small & hard on my bad back.

    Have fun.
    Tom

  • http://oussamastake.blogspot.com/ Oussama

    An Explorer is a joy to drive, big enough but handles like a Sedan. The new models are fuel efficient (turbocharged 4 cylinder engines). 

  • Sammy

     Like guest said. You’re not just buying a car for one single road trip. You’re going to have it for a while. So yes, it’s worth it to me. Take proper care of your car and you can drive one for 10+ years. I know people personally who have gotten more than 300,000 miles on their cars with proper maintenance. I owned a KIA Sephia, that was supposed to be a “throw away” car for 10 years. Not everyone trades in their cars every three years.

    And how long is gas going to stay as a “measly” $3.50 a gallon? It just keeps going up and up and up and up. Here in Vegas we have at points gotten dang close to $5.00 a gallon. The only way we lose our dependence on OPEC is to lose out dependence on carbon based fuels so much. That make MUCH more sense to me for the long run view for the world.

  • Sammy

    If you want to talk atrocious gas mileage. As a kid, we had a decked out full sized Dodge van, circa 1979/1980 model bought new. The inside was set up for camping, back bench seat pulled out into a bed, storage in the back for gear, pump sink, icebox, small closet. There was padding under the carpet where I slept. Two adults, one child, a dog, a cat, and about five cross country trips over the years.

    I still treasure the memories of the places we went and what I saw. Family road trips like that aren’t taken very much any more. One year we left CO, traveled east through KS, MO (stopped in Hannibal), IN, WV, PA (saw Gettysburg and Hershey), NY (Finger Lakes region, Niagara Falls), into Canada, came back down through MI, the headed back to CO. I know I missed a lot of states in there, but can’t name them all LOL. But I think those trips instilled my love of traveling, learning, and of history.

  • Chrisntim

    For the ENJOYMENT of all in the vehicle, go with a minivan! This is not about your image, it is about the journey and those on the trip with you. So, go for the most room, the best views for ALL passengers and the milage so that you can do more things (museums etc)

  • Steve R

    I put about 500 miles on a rented Ford Edge several months ago on a business trip, and I loved it. Roomy, powerful, and comfortable. Of course, seeing that I averaged 21 mpg in mostly highway driving just about stopped my heart since my car and my wife’s car get almost double that. But if that size vehicle appeals to you, then I’d echo AutoSlash and Melissa and recommend the Edge. (I’m not generally a fan of American cars, either, though I think they’ve gotten a lot better in the past few years).

  • Steve R

    2007? I don’t care how many miles you’ve put on it, that Accord is just a baby and can run reliably for many more years. :) I’m sure it’s a tight fit traveling in it as a family of five, though.

    Personally, fuel economy is the primary consideration for my wife and me. Her car is a 2007 Toyota Yaris which cost $15,000 new and averages 39-40 mpg on road trips with primarily highway driving (and not at 55 mph, either). Of course, we have the luxury of not worrying much about space…pretty much any car is big enough for the two of us and our luggage. (It’s a comfortable road trip car, too, with the exception of the lack of cruise control – but that was our choice not to pay extra for an option package that included it).

    From a reliability standpoint, I still heavily favor Toyotas and Hondas, but I think Ford and GM have caught up quite a bit in the last few years, so if I was looking for a brand-new car, I wouldn’t rule them out.

  • Cliffordpwoodrick

    Hi – My Academy classmate has a hybrid SUV and he stated that he gets better gas milage with local driving then he gets on the highway. He drives locally about 85% of the milage but I travel highway about 85% of my travels. I purchased a new Toyota Highlander as we drive to Florida from New York. It is big enough to hold four months luggage etc and I am happy with the 23.2 miles per gallon. It all depends on how and where you drive.

    Have a wonderful day - Cliff

  • Rinacres

    I have driven my Ford Escape with 3 kids all over the US, from WI to Salem, MA to Seattle, WA to Ft Myers Beach FL , to Las Vegas a few times, and multiple trips to Savannah GA and back.  I never had any issues with it and it was a wonderful car for the trip.  I first fell in love with that style when I rented one for our trip to Yellowstone, and within a year had bought my first one.  Now, that first one is my daughter’s car now as she traverses back and forth from college and many other road trips, and I have upgraded my self to the new FlexFuel version.  It is perfect!

  • Tom

    I would suggest you look at the Dodge Durango. I have a 2006 with the 5.7L Hemi. Actually gets about 20MPG on trips to Florida. Plenty of room for luggage and passengers. And you can’t beat the Hemi to get you up the mountains and for passing.
    Plus it just sounds cool to say “It’s got a Hemi.”

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LOCND3JAJL4PGYWJBHUT3HWAZM web/gadget guru

    Wow! a 2007 Honda! That’s newer than anything I own…My latest acquisition is a 97 Chrysler Sebring convertible. I love convertibles! It’s a change up from my Jeep collection (I’ve had 3 Jeeps at one time…now down to 2)
    I don’t believe in buying new cars. Older cars run just as good and cost you less in the long run! This is especially true if you have a good mechanic you can trust. My family has been using a local mechanic for the last 30 years and I trust them with every car I’ve ever owned!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LOCND3JAJL4PGYWJBHUT3HWAZM web/gadget guru

    Yeah, but at $35K+ for this thing you’re paying $5k-$8k premium for the hybrid part alone. Amortize that difference across how long you will be owning the vehicle against the savings in fuel and this premium cost for a hybrid just doesn’t make sense! This is especially true if you drive mainly highway miles.
    No, If you’re looking at an SUV, You’ld be better served in a GMC Terrain. Better Highway miles than the hybrid and more room too! Plus, this thing just looks cool!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_B4HAGDVH36FGX62QIJLOFNGA4M Erin

    Jetta sports wagon… old style with new gas mileage with the tdi

  • Jennj99738

    A VW camper van like this one!  http://www.flickr.com/photos/davydutchy/540441910/

    Oh, maybe that was my dream…

  • DavidS

    YES! And Grateful Dead in the 8-track! :)

  • MeanMeosh

    Wow – wish I’d read this yesterday – myself being a self-proclaimed roadtrip expert as a veteran of at least two dozen cross-country jaunts over my life so far :)

    My parents have an Odyssey, and I’ve driven them from Texas to both Florida and Memphis and back a few times.  It’s a nice ride, but fully loaded with people and cargo, isn’t great with the gas.  About 23 is the best we could do, and that’s with the cruise set between 70 and 75 on the interstate.  If you like Honda but just can’t do the minivan, try the CR-V.  Slightly smaller, but better gas mileage (about 26-27 on the highway).  And you can get it with 4WD.  Or if you’d rather stick with a sedan, maybe try the Ford Fusion.  It’s big, and the V-6 can bring it, but you can still get close to 30 on the highway.

    But, I have to admit, I’m a little curious why you’re worried about an ’07 Accord making the trip.  Hondas are built like tanks.  My wife had a ’97 CR-V that just recently kicked the bucket.  You should be able to get another 5-6 years easy in that thing.

  • Sue

    I love my Suburban, three comfortable seats, good view of your surroundings, easy to drive and plenty of luggage space. Also really like the fact that it weighs a ton and is solid so I’am more apt to “walk away”. I knew it’s loved gas when I bought it, but was willing to accept it for all the pros involved.

  • MrAirport

    Rental.  There is nothing better than putting tons and tons of miles on a rental.  If the pony gets sick along the way, call them and they will deliver a fresh one.  Excellent opportunity to “road test” a car you might want to buy in the future.
    There are deals to be had on a rental.  Whether it is a corporate discount code, and Entertainment book discount, a Frequent Flyer discount code, Association code, there are deals to be had.  A little research can find you something real reasonable.
    You think a rental for 3 weeks is expensive, try having the wheel bearings repacked in “Wide Spot in the Road, Rural, America”.  Now, that can be expensive!
    Old story coming up: My buddy Steve wanted to drive from Illinois to the wild west with his two teenage children.  His Merc wasn’t going to make the trip.  I suggested a rental.  He got a Lincoln Towncar back when Budget was loaded to the gills with them.  Real Cheap.  And had a coupon good for a better deal. 
    Illinois to Denver, Salt Lake City, Reno, San Fran, San Diego, Las Vegas.  OH – the low oil light came on.  He bought 2 quarts – one went in and the other on hand in the trunk.  Onward to Phoenix and then through Saint Louis back to Springfield.  5244 miles. 
    That was the way to go!

  • LarryB

    Unless you have over 200k miles, have been in multiple accidents or just have a lemon (not likely) the ’07 Accord should do just fine, mountains and all. After all the thing is 5 years old, tops. And it’s a Honda.

    I’ve driven my 150k+ 2000 Nissan Xterra on long road trips with absolutely no worries.

    Now, if you had a ’97 Accord or an ’07 Chevy, I’d understand your worry.

  • Jessica

    We just got our new MB Sprinter 12 passenger van with a low top and rear a/c package.  Perfect for traveling with our six kids.  We’ve put 3200 miles on in the last month and a half.  Highly recommend for comfort while traveling.  Oh, and we did add in after market gps and 24 inch dvd screen.

  • Jen G.

    Minivan or RV.  We don’t have kids yet – just dogs, but when my husband’s father retired he bought out his work vehicle, a Dodge Grand Caravan, and gave it to us, and wow, we’re hooked!  The room in them is unbelievable.  (I don’t know how we ever fit everything in to my Honda Civic before we got the minivan.)  There are three rows of seats but when we are home we just have the front row in and use the entire back for storage and dog crates.  When we road trip with family we can add a row or two of seats as needed and everyone has plenty of space plus still a ton of room for storage.  The gas isn’t too bad – about 20mpg.  My Civic gets about 35mpg, but there’s just not enough room for road trips with the two of us and three dogs, plus stuff.

    The other option is an RV.  You lose MPG, but, you gain on the fact that you don’t have to find/pay for hotels.  You don’t have to spend as much eating out because you’ll have a kitchen and fridge.  You don’t have to pack and unpack as you move from hotel room to hotel room.  You don’t have to worry about hotel rooms being booked, or dirty, etc.  You can either dry camp (rest stops in some states allow you to do that, many Walmarts allow you to stay in their parking lots, etc) or pay to stay in an RV park, but it’s still way cheaper then hotels.  And the people you get to meet while RV’ing are amazing too!

    Another option is a tow-behind trailer, although that would still require a new vehicle as your sedan isn’t going to be able to tow much of anything.  But that would give you the flexibility to drop the trailer at the RV park and drive just the tow vehicle around wherever you need to go at the time.

    We just bought a pop-up to use with our mini-van a few weeks ago and it’s great!

  • willybfreed

    Sprinter van is the bomb.I Have some friends (a couple and two dogs last time I heard)and they call their crew “Sprinter life. If you log on to http://www.sprinterlife.com and you will hear so many good things about the sprinter van. They have been to 13 countries as of last post. Very cool trip and very good vehicle. They have a solar coversion for power and all kinds of x-tras