Is this enough compensation? I got a refund and they blacklisted the property, but …

It wasn’t Margaret Peary’s first hotel booking on Priceline. But it may have been her last.

She’d been quoted a rate of $77 a night, which didn’t include hotel taxes for a condo in Kihei, Maui. Great rate, right?

But when she got her credit card bill, the fun started.

Wow! I was charged a whopping $207. I called the condo rental agency and said “There must be some mistake.”

I was told “Oh no, the charges are correct. In addition to the $77 room price, we charge a $35 “booking fee” (even though I booked through Priceline) and an $85 cleaning fee plus the tax.”

Seriously?

I did a little digging, and found that yes, some properties on Priceline do in fact charge booking fees — and more.

Here’s a resort in Kirkwood, Calif., that charges a $20 “booking fee” and a $7 per night “recreation fee.” Here’s another resort with a 5 percent booking fee.

But you’d expect all this to be disclosed up front, and preferably included in the room rate, especially if the fees are required.

Peary fought the charge.

I contacted Bank of America Visa and after speaking to a young man who gave very glib answers I asked to speak to a supervisor. She did a three-way call with Priceline, who claimed I chose a “pay as you go” reservation and who supposedly had the itinerary which detailed all of those hidden charges of which I supposedly received an email copy after making the reservation.

All of it was bogus! When I asked him to please email me what he was looking at, he agreed to do so. No email was ever received.

B of A agreed to eat the $120 in excessive fees and credited my Visa for that amount … kudos to them!

The Visa supervisor made a very astute statement when she asked Priceline, “When did Mrs. Peary authorize Priceline to allow a third party vendor to have access to her credit card?”

When indeed? Priceline did not bill me … the vendor billed my Visa.

This is a scam of epic proportions, Chris, and no one wants to assume responsibility for the consumer fraud that is being foisted upon the public.

The condo folks said “We get lots of calls from people who booked through Expedia, Travelocity, Priceline, etc. who are unaware of our additional fees.”

Of course they’re unaware because the fees are not posted anywhere!

That didn’t sound right, so I contacted Priceline.

“Not the customer experience we’re looking for,” a representative admitted.

Priceline apologized to Peary and said it would stop making reservations with the property “until this gets squared away.”

I asked Priceline if it had disclosed the fees. Yes, the representative said, but she apparently didn’t see them. It’s working on improving its disclosure.

I think it’s great that Priceline blacklisted the property for taking money from one its customers without permission. Nice of it to mention its fees more prominently, too. But is that enough?

  • Andre K.

    Under any circumstance “Personal Data” does not and should not ever constitute the transference of secured credit card information. Legally it should only include data required for the actual processing of the reservation, such as name, address, contact info, and other such data which constitutes personally identifiable information. Credit card information does not fall under the category of personally identifiable information

    As for the question “Did Priceline offer Margaret Peary enough compensation?” the answer is clearly no. They did nothing to reimburse their guest for this experience and it is clear that they perpetrated a breach of contract by passing on credit card information without authorization for use of fraudulent means.

  • DavidS

    Excerpts from Priceline’s website:

    Information We Collect
    We collect personally identifiable information (“Personal Data”) about you that you provide to us while using the Site. Personal Data includes information that can identify you as a specific individual, such as your name, address, phone number, credit card number or e-mail address.

    Certain Services: In order to provide you with certain services, we may share your Personal Data with our subsidiaries or third party partners, or require that you transact directly with a third party partner.

  • Rosered

    That’s some important info to be put in the fine print.  Remind me not to use Priceline because of this (and I’ll be looking at other sites’ fine print more carefully too).

  • YesIdoKnow

    Priceline = Drop your pants and roll the dice.

    Why are people shocked when they’re screwed by Priceline???  Really, are they that stupid?

  • BruceW

    We have an idiot “Consumer Advocate” that reveals scams in our are in weekly local news segment but they always obscure the scammers names!  They say they are afraid of getting sued.  How the hell is the segment helpful if we don’t know who to avoid!  They are totally useless.

  • Guest

    Anyone you transact with gets your paypal email.  So what.  You don’t have a good password??

  • http://elliott.org Christopher Elliott

    Sorry. The company name is Hawaii Condo Rentals, according to Peary.

  • MikeZ

    Exactly! Show maximum amounts so the customer knows what they may be responsible for. Also, $85 for cleaning? For one night? Cleaning people make like $10 an hour. So they take an entire day to clean each room that someone has been in for a night!?!?

    And $35 for a booking fee? Thats crazy. You don’t book through the resort, Priceline does. The resort made the blocks of rooms available through Priceline and any booking fees should be up front, and included in the price.

  • DavidS

    Actually, any travel agency you use..online or in person will do this. The question I am beginning to have with this is that why the need to send credit card info if the reservation was paid in advance via a transaction direct with Priceline?

    If I call my travel agent and ask to hold a room in Minnepaolis tonight, they will pass the credit card info to the hotel. If I no show, the hotel will charge my card a no show fee.

  • Gubby

    What was the point of that useless rant?

  • xpatinasia

    The consumer was wronged, and was made whole.  Unfortunately, as many consumers do, she felt as if she should have won the lottery.  “I want MORE!”

  • xpatinasia

    The consumer was wronged, and was made whole.  Unfortunately, as many consumers do, she felt as if she should have won the lottery.  “I want MORE!”

  • Petes

    Why anyone books with sites like Priceline is beyond me.  If anything goes wrong, you are screwed.
    Is that worth the few dollars supposedly saved?

  • DavidS

    Where would you book a room? The same can be said for ANY booking method.

  • Traveling man

    A good online agency shoud eat the fees and offer at least 1 night’s compensation for the aggrivation put on the client.

  • DavidS

    Step #1: Find a good online agency.

    But even then, in this case the hotel made the extra charges, not the agency.

  • Dfjkh

    Priceline plays games with taxes and fees.  Once naming your own price, we have to allow for an extra 20% taxes/fees. These are disclosed at the final “yellow” page, as the total of your reservation. Ex: $100/night + $15 taxes + $5 booking fee * 2 nights = $240 total to be charged. If any fees are not disclosed at this page, a hotel can’t charge anything extra. Priceline indeed collects all taxes and I hope all fees.  I’d dispute any resort or cleaning charges if not disclosed to me up-front.

  • DavidS

    This is not a “name your own price booking”, but rather a conventional pre-paid booking.

    Regarding priceline’s name your own price bookings, they do have a blanket statement that a hotel “may” charge a resort fee, but I agree with you, if a fee is not optional it should be part of the room rate.

  • DavidS

    This is not a “name your own price booking”, but rather a conventional pre-paid booking.

    Regarding priceline’s name your own price bookings, they do have a blanket statement that a hotel “may” charge a resort fee, but I agree with you, if a fee is not optional it should be part of the room rate.