Airline considers $10 surcharge for baby-free seating, priority disembarking

What will the airlines start charging us for next? After you read this, you’ll be sorry you asked.

Nigel Appleby’s daughter recently got a survey from WestJet which offers some clues about the Canadian carrier’s next move. It’s troubling, to say the least.

WestJet has denied that it sent the survey to its customers.

According to Appleby, the airline wanted to know if passengers would consider a $10 service fee for one of the following:

Priority boarding (getting on the plane first)

Priority disembarking (getting off the plane first)

Expedited baggage delivery

Priority rebooking in case of flight cancellation

Complimentary meals/hotel accommodations when a flight is either cancelled or substantially delayed

In-flight Internet access

Guaranteed space in the overhead bin

In-seat power

Premium snack/meal offering

A freshly laundered pillow/blanket set that you may keep after the flight

An amenity kit with earplugs, eyeshades and toiletries to keep you refreshed on the plane

A wait of 10 minutes or less to clear security checkpoints

Sitting away from parents traveling with babies/small children

If you could pay $10 less to not use particular services for a flight of two to four hours, how likely would you be to do so for each of the following services?

Savings for not checking bags

Savings for not earning frequent flier miles

Savings for only bringing aboard one small piece of carry-on baggage (e.g., only a purse or computer bag)

Savings for being the last to board

Savings for using online check-in instead of a kiosk

Savings for using either a kiosk or online check-in instead of a human agent

Savings for having my checked luggage to be among the last to be delivered

Savings for sitting in a middle seat

Savings for making no changes to your ticket prior to departure

Savings for not getting free water, coffee/tea, juices or soft drinks in flight

Savings for having a seat that does not recline

Savings to sit close to parents traveling with babies/small children

This is disappointing, but not surprising. Airlines are leaving no stone unturned when it comes to generating “ancillary” revenues from their customers.

The funny thing is that there’s no “discount” for services you don’t use. When airlines went “a la carte” they didn’t discount their fares – instead, they were busy trying to raise them.

So let’s call this what it really is – a hidden fare increase.

  • Mark P

    Absolutely! I would pay extra to sit far away from kids kicking the back of my seat..babies crying while parents either ignore, or try their best to quiet the child down. It would be better to have a “baby/child” zone in the plane, but that will never happen. $10 is a small price to pay for peace.

    Yes to $10 to clear security check points. Would be nice to pass by the line especially when you are running late to catch a flight.

    Yes to $10 Internet and Power connectivity. Would make the flight go by much quicker and not have to worry about carrying extra batteries for the notebook.

    All in all the majority of these upgrades look like the perks in first/business class without the huge difference in price. Granted you don’t get the big comfy chair, but for the price, it does add value.

  • Carver Farrow

    Of course, marketing notwithstanding, there is no econominc difference between a fee for a service you use or a discount for not using a service. That being said, it would depend on the purpose of a given trip.

    On an overnight business trip,I would be happy to save money by not checking bags. On a one week trip to Europe, I’d rather check the bags.

    The real problem is to make sure that the airlines do not devalue their frequent flyer programs by duplicating the benefits for a $10 fee.

  • http://adaysouting.com Cathy Jolly

    I can’t imagine the airlines being able to manage who paid for what services. That said, I would be happy to trade inflight internet access for checking in at a kiosk.

  • http://www.globetrottingbride.com Globetrotting Bride

    I would definitely pay $10 for a baby free flight. Worse than the crying is the kid who sits behind me and kicks my seat the whole time while the parents pretend to not notice!

  • http://www.pobox.com/~meta/ mathew

    I, too, would pay $10 extra to be guaranteed a seat away from screaming children. It’s something I’ve suggested to airlines in the past when taking surveys.

  • Cindy

    I’d be willing to pay $10 for several of these things ~ the crying children, of course…but especially the (hopefully) 10 minute security line or priority disembarking if you had a tight connection.

    My issue would be that by charging $5 for this and $15 for that and $10 for something else….pretty soon we’ll just have to automatically calculate an additional $50 in our head when searching for good (cheap) prices…

  • http://www.wandermom.com wandermom

    The vitriol expressed about “screaming children” always surprises and saddens me.

    I wish the airlines would come to some industry agreement and all raise prices by 5% – and stop this nickle-and-dime-ing everyone.
    But then again, I’ve flown Ryanair enough times to know where this is going and it isn’t pretty.

  • D. Kyle

    This is an internet hoax. From any other airline I would believe them but this is WestJet, one of the best run airlines in the world.

  • Andrew Brown

    I’d pay $200 extra for an annoyance-free flight. That means: no babies, no kids, no people that stink, and no drunkards wanting to tell me their life story. :P

  • Mark from the real world

    Sorry to all whom don’t know what’s going on, all the time. I have two active children, which most of the time are well behaved but do get bored easlily. We bring everything we can from books, to toys to our own movie players. But what do you do when one of your kids is mild audtistic? Do we ban him from Disney or can people realize that there are things out there that no one can control. Maybe the people who have issues should rent a car and to their destination, because I wouldn’t survive that long with my two. They don’t intentionally upset people, but if they happen to bump a chair or a table, so what. I recently flew back from Mexico and we were reading to keep them calm and our 3 year old slid off his chair and bumped the chair ahead. One instance and the guy turned and suggested we control our children. If that is the level of patience from an adult, how can you expect more from a child. Just a thought.

  • http://www.cockam.com ajaynejr

    I think there should be special dispensation available every once in awhile for various things including for guaranteed space in the cabin for certain baggage. This should not involve having to step up to a much more expensive fare like first class. The idea of ten dollars for this, fifteen dollars for that makes sense. I would be in favor of making it less expensive for very infrequent instances such as one guitar or picture frame in ten years of occasional flying, and more expensive for those who want more privileges regularly, but that would be too complicated to administer.