I’m still waiting for my refund … and waiting … and waiting

Question: I’m having some refund trouble with an airline, and need your help. Last year I had to cancel a Lufthansa flight I had booked through Expedia because of a death in my family. The ticket cost $303. When I told my travel agency the reason for canceling the trip, it gave me a list of documentation necessary for a refund.

I called Lufthansa, and a representative told me they wouldn’t process a refund by phone. So I sent the necessary paperwork to both Lufthansa and Expedia.

Since then, I’ve followed up several times online and have re-faxed the documents to Lufthansa. To date, I have never received any response from Lufthansa — not even to acknowledge receipt of the documentation. Any advice? — Megan Gallardo, Podgorica, Montenegro

Answer: I think you’ve been more than patient with Lufthansa. The airline should either send you a refund or refuse to return your money. Not responding is not acceptable.

Most airline tickets are nonrefundable, but airlines sometimes make exceptions when there’s a death in the family. Your online agent would have recommended that you send a death certificate and a letter to the airline, explaining your circumstances.

Refunds can take a while. Airlines normally tell you to wait two to three credit card billing cycles, but a year isn’t unheard of. I’ve seen that a time or two.

Why the foot-dragging? Of all the explanations I’ve been offered — slow accountants, obsolete technology, or just corporate policy — the one that rings truest is this: airlines don’t want to part with the money.

I’m not sure that’s what happened in your case. Maybe Lufthansa didn’t have all of your paperwork. Maybe your letter went to the wrong department. Either way, the airline kept you waiting for a year. It shouldn’t have.

Was this preventable? Absolutely. You bought your ticket through an online travel agency, which should have done more than just give you an address for refunds. You might have applied a little pressure to Expedia to nudge Lufthansa about the status of your refund. That’s what good travel agents do for their clients.

You might have also considered sending a polite follow-up email to Expedia and Lufthansa to check on the status of your update after a few months. An online inquiry is fine, but if you aren’t getting through to anyone, I recommend escalating your case to a manager or an executive. Their e-mail addresses are not difficult to find.

If neither the agency nor the airline responded, you might have contacted your credit card company to initiate a dispute. (If your ticket was fully refundable, and your credit card company believes your airline is simply holding on to your money, it might have been and open-and-shut case.)

At my suggestion, you emailed Expedia one last time. It responded saying, “your request for refund is still in progress as of this time” and that there were no further updates on whether the request had been approved.

So I contacted the airline. Initially, the airline deferred to Expedia. But eventually it came through for you. Nearly a year and a half after you applied for it, Lufthansa issued a $303 refund.

  • http://pragueapartmentsonline.com Martin Smith

    I have written to you several times about the ridiculous involuntary forfeiture of more than $3,000 for a ticket PRG-CDG-EZE and return. Because of missing the first leg PRG-CDG the entire ticket was cancelled and we couldn’t even use the return. AirFrance/KLM and Expedia all say there is no recourse. Surely this is theft. Just because the flight from PRG-CDG was missed because of a horrendous auto accident very near the airport surely should not mean that the entire sum is forfeit and then we had to buy other tickets. We have written Air France/KLM four times now and not even received a response. Help!

  • http://cestbeth.com/ Beth

    This is why I rarely buy anything from an online, third-party booking company for either myself or my travel clients. I’d rather pay a little more and deal directly with the air carrier, the hotel, etc. To call Expedia a “travel agent” is sort of insulting to the true travel professionals who provide excellent, personalized services and go to bat for their customers in difficult situations such as this.

  • Carver

    I agree with Beth insofar as I don’t deal with 3rd party booking agents as a rule. I believe in dealing directly with the travel provider.

  • Robert Knox

    Elliott,
    You recommend emailing directly to an Expedia or Lufthansa manager, and say their addresses are not hard to find. How and where can we find these addresses? My experience is that these businesses will not give out management names and email addresses. A clerk will take your request and promise to send it forward, but they never do.
    RK

  • Michael Lemire

    Robert,

    You can do a search for stories on the offending party at the consumerist.com. They have lots of info on how to get in touch with executives.

  • David Z

    How and where can we find these addresses?

    Chris actually posted those of Expedia on this very blog:

    http://www.elliott.org/help/expedia/

    If you get a bounceback after trying to email any of those listed there, tell Chris so he can update.

  • http://cnn Eva

    I have worked for a travel company with offices around the globe for 9 years. My job is to process the refunds our retail agents sell to the public. Let me tell you, Lufthansa is one of the WORST when it comes to paying out-most of the refunds I forward to them for processing take a year to come back. Its ridiculous! Airlines HATE to part with their money. I regularly have to chase cases where 4 or 5 different airline employees have assured me a refund has been processed when, in fact, it hasn’t. My advice: Keep all correspondence, receipts, boarding passes, luggage check tickets-everything! Don’t give up and don’t give in!

  • Lynn Ryan

    Several years ago I bought a fully refundable paper ticket on Continental Airlines using my American Express card. I missed my flight when I got stuck in a hotel elevator (true!) and later sent my ticket to Continental for a refund.
    I did everything right, kept copies, sent all the required documentation by Airborne Express signiture required, and reported the dispute to American Express. Over the next year and a half, American Express asked me to resend the documentation three times, but I never received any acknowledgement, communication or refund from Continental or the card company. At that point American Express told me they had nothing more to do with the problem and it was now between me and Continental.
    I then called directly to the refund department of Continental Airlines. They said as long as the ticket hadn’t been used (it hadn’t) I was indeed entitled to a refund. It came through the next morning. I told American Express what I had done and cancelled my card. I am sure they didn’t care, but I never missed the $75 a year I was paying for zero customer support. As for Continental, even having one of their management as a friend didn’t help; they just were not going to refund my $600 until I went to the guy who actually does it, someone the travelling public usually does not have access to. This experience just confirms that buying a ticket through a travel agency, even for a small fee, can be well worth it for the back up they can provide in a dispute. They have all the right phone numbers!

  • Carver

    @Lynn

    Sorry to hear about what Continental put you through. However, I cannot agree about using a travel agency. The one my firm used cost $25 per ticket. I make about 20 trips per flights. That’s about 500 annually as insurance against something bad happening. At least for me that way too much money.

  • David Z