A canceled flight, a missing refund

orlandoQuestion: I’m trying to get a long-overdue refund from American Airlines, and I need your help. Last year, my husband and I had tickets for our honeymoon on American Airlines. On the morning of the flight from San Diego to Orlando, we got a phone call that said our itinerary had been changed. However, the new flight was almost two days later.

This was unacceptable to us since it was our honeymoon, so we called the airline’s customer service department. They were unable to find us a closer flight so the agent said they would just refund our money. We ended up buying new tickets on another airline.

As you can probably guess, we never received the $1,374 refund we were promised. The tickets were paid for with a debit card so the refund should have been issued back onto the card.

We tried calling American Airlines about this and they said the refund had been issued. But when we called our bank to ask them about it, they said there was never any refund. I have also e-mailed American Airlines customer service about this and they just replied that the refund had already been issued. Then, when I emailed them again and asked for some sort of proof that the refund had been issued, there was no response.

We’re stuck. Is there anything you can do? — Sarah Paynter, San Diego

Answer: American Airlines should have refunded the money you spent on your tickets by now. On second thought, it shouldn’t have ever come to this. When your flight was canceled, the airline should have found a way of getting you to your destination in a timely manner — not two days later.

Your rights as a passenger are outlined in American Airlines’ conditions of carriage — that’s the legal agreement between you and the airline. See paragraph 18, which deals with delays, cancellations and diversions. It specifies that when cancellations and major delays are experienced, passengers will be rerouted on its next flight with available seats.

“If the delay or cancellation was caused by events within our control and we do not get you to your final destination on the expected arrival day, we will provide reasonable overnight accommodations, subject to availability,” it adds.

Not so long ago, airlines would buy a ticket on another airline if the delay were their fault, like a mechanical problem or a crew shortage. Ticket agents at some carriers still have the authority to endorse a ticket to another airline.

I don’t think you should have taken “no” for an answer. Telling an American Airlines representative that you’re on your honeymoon might have gotten you a flight to your destination without spending any extra money.

In a situation like this, having a skilled travel agent would have also been useful. A trusted travel adviser — especially someone who specializes in honeymoon vacations — would have known whom to call at American. If nothing else, that would have saved you and your husband from a lot of unnecessary stress.

As to your refund, airlines often talk a good game when it comes to returning your money. In fact, they take weeks, and sometimes months, to process your credit. Why? I haven’t heard a good explanation yet.

When you’re trying to track down a refund, you’re better off sticking to e-mail. If the airline sends you something in writing that promises a refund, finding the money will be much easier for your bank. Even if the money never shows up, your financial institution may return the funds if it interprets the correspondence as a letter of credit, or an intent to pay you. That can’t happen if you call the airline.

I contacted American on your behalf and it promptly issued a $1,374 refund to your card.

(Photo: Joe Penniston/Flickr Creative Commons)

  • Joe Farrell

    Wow – $1374 for 2 tickets from San Diego to Orlando? orlando is pretty cheap to fly to!

    Knowing the airlines like I do, they would allow you to refund the front half of the ticket but not the return.

  • Raven

    Completely unacceptable that it took so long for American to refund the money to this couple. What was the cause of the cancelled flight? If it was something AA could have controlled, these people should be getting more than just a refund–extra miles, upgrade coupons, something.

    Airlines are the new mob. They take your money, beat you up, and treat you like crap all while the government looks the other way.

  • Justin

    Shouldn’t this be 1374 + interest Chris? After all, any institution that “holds on to your money” is subject to pay interest as if it’s a loan. I think they are due a few hundred dollars more.that 1374 has not only devalued due to inflation over the period of time, but they lost use of that money for other things. Maybe they should take them to court too on this one. They might walk away with some more on top of it all.

    Justin

  • Josh

    This is another reason to always use a real credit card (vs a debit card) for travel purchases (and to fight hard against proposed changes that would allow companies to charge you a surcharge for doing so; they only want to reduce your consumer protections). A cancelled flight (for any reason, including weather) or significant schedule change always allows the customer to choose a refund even on a “nonrefundable” ticket (this is in most conditions of carriage, and part of any basic merchantability type laws).

    When I return something, even a multi-hundred-dollar something at any retailer, it is almost always credited immediately and posts online by the next day. There’s absolutely no reason an airline can’t do the same in a clear-cut refund case such as this. The best practice is probably to call the credit card company immediately and dispute the charge — they’ll take it off your account (temporarily) right away, and if the airline refunds the charge on their own it’ll automatically reconcile; if not you’re protected. This doesn’t always work the same way with a debit card.

  • Roberto

    I’ve always been amazed how merchants that can take your money instantly can’t seem to give a refund in under 6 months.

  • Karen

    There’s something fishy about this story…two days to get a new flight? American has 9 non-stop flights a day from SAN to DFW with 10 non-stop flights a day from DFW to MCO. They also have flights from LAX to MCO. With that many options to choose from, I have a hard time believing the story that the next flight offered to them was two days later.

  • Kevin M

    For those commenting on the price of the tickets and how strange it was that AA couldn’t get them to their destination until 2 days after the original plans: Given that this was a honeymoon, I wouldn’t be surprised if these were first-class tickets, hence the higher price, and with only a handful of first-class seats on each flight, it could be that the airline was booked up for that class otherwise.

  • Mohannad Al-Suwaidan

    I’m having the same problem with AA except I’ve been waiting a YEAR for a refund of $3,000 for a canceled family trip to Europe due to a snow storm in London. They replied to my online request with “Although we try to find a solution to all issues sent to us, it’s not always the best way to resolve matters efficiently.” I guess more than a year is still considered “efficient.”