Sorry, you don’t have an airline ticket

Question: I need your help with a vacation to St. Kitts that was missing a key component: our airline tickets. I had paid Expedia $2,521 for the package, which was supposed to include airfare from Cleveland.

But when I arrived at the airport, I discovered that our tickets hadn’t been issued. I had received an email from Expedia the day before, confirming our reservations.

I called Expedia’s customer service department, which asked me to buy new tickets. Expedia agreed to reimburse me the difference between the package price and the tickets, which came to $871.

Three months later, I still had no credit. I called again, only to find out that because they had no documentation that we had purchased new tickets, they could not issue a credit. I faxed them a copy of the receipt for the tickets.

Shortly after that, I received an email from Expedia denying my request for a refund. They did offer a voucher for $100 to be used when booking another Expedia trip. I don’t understand why my refund request was denied. I did everything they asked. I even bought Expedia’s trip insurance. Can you help? — Linda Foy, Cleveland

Answer: Expedia should have booked your flights, of course. When it didn’t, it should have bought your replacement tickets — not asked you to buy them.

And the three-month delay, followed by a “no” on your refund request? Let’s just say it wasn’t in line with its vaunted Expedia “Promise” that guarantees, among other things, that, “the travel you booked with Expedia will meet the descriptions on our site and in your itinerary.” Here’s the full text of its warranty.

But how about you? Even though you received a flight confirmation the day before your trip, why didn’t you confirm it with the airline directly? Make sure the confirmation is in writing and contains a six-character alphanumeric confirmation number. That’s a sign that you have a real reservation.

Once you were at the airport, you shouldn’t have allowed Expedia to persuade you to buy new tickets. If Expedia screwed up the reservation then it shouldn’t be your job to fix it. Your online travel agent should have secured the new tickets. Instead, you basically gave Expedia a free, three-month loan, which it then defaulted on.

Talk about corporate welfare.

When Expedia began giving you the runaround, I wouldn’t have let them string you along for three months. Why not appeal to someone higher up at the travel agency? I post a few high-level contacts on my site, On Your Side.

You could have also applied some pressure to your airline. It might have been able to figure out the mystery of your missing reservation and fixed your flight without forcing you to pay more.

In the end, the mystery of your nonexistent flight remained exactly that. Although I contacted Expedia on your behalf, it didn’t offer an explanation for what went wrong. Instead, it contacted you and refunded the price of the new tickets you had to buy at the airport.

  • Michelle

    wow…if anyone had a travel nightmare it is this couple. If anyone should be offered a refund AND compensation it is these people. So far, I always go directly to the airline for tickets but always use third parties for hotel. I don’t use Expedia or Hotwire because I have heard too many negative stories. Two thumbs down to Expedia.

  • Bruce InCharlotte

    Expedia also needs to be paying the finance charges and interest on the balance plus compensation (and not a credit towards a future purchase!). They committed to the tickets and then dropped the ball. How come they get off so light here?

  • Kelly

    Something sounds awful fishy to me! I have a really hard believing there wasn’t more to the story. But if there wasn’t I can’t believe that Expedia tried to get away with this! I would have taken them to small claims court regardless if they got the refund.

  • Blackadar

    Chris,

    I entirely disagree with your suggestion that it’s the responsibility of the customer to check in with the airlines after booking with a travel agent – online or otherwise. They are compensated for that service and it’s their responsibility. That doesn’t mean that it’s not a good idea for a consumer to check it, but it’s not their responsibility. This is Expedia’s screw-up, so don’t try to blame the customer on this one. Frankly, at this point, the consumer should be compensated for more than just the extra ticket – their screw-up cost the consumer time, which is the most precious commodity we all have.

  • Roberto

    I’m with Blackadar on this one. Expedia, as the travel agent, should be the ones verifying the booking with the airline. If they want to collect their commission, they need to do the work that is required to earn it!

  • Geoff

    From article: “Make sure the confirmation is in writing and contains a six-character alphanumeric confirmation number. That’s a sign that you have a real reservation.”

    The six-character confirmation number means you have a reservation, but not necessarily a confirmed ticket. Unless you have a ticket number (usually 13 or 14 digits) then your ticket is not actually issued and your reservation just as worthless as not having one at all.

  • http://golodgings.com Martin Smith

    Dear Chris:

    I see you giving the advice you gave this lady often. I am always amazed when you do give it. When you are in an airport and people are standing around you waiting for service it is pretty hard to be adamant with a gate agent and it is even harder trying to get someone at Expedia to do anything other than tell you no. It does make sense to contact them by email and that may work for some. For me thought Expedia is a complete disaster and they routinely deny any responsibility for anything and blame everything on the airlines.
    Kind Regards
    Martin

  • Joe Farrell

    What you got from Expedia was a ‘reminder’ not a reconfirmation – people need to read the language very carefully.

    The problem is that you were dealing with script readers in the overseas customer service department who don;t know anything. Next0 when ever you actually buy something from a travel consolidator like Expedia, Travelocity or Orbitz, you need to VERIFY that an actual ticket was purchased by them for you for EVERY element of your travel. This means there will be airline ticket numbers in a little field. You need to call the hotel to make certain they have a reservation for you – and make sure you get EVERYONE’s confirmation numbers- airlines have 6 digit alphanumeric PNR’s and hotels have confirmation numbers. Otherwise, trust at your peril.

    TO EVERYONE OUT THERE: If this happens – you send a very nicely worded demand to the CEO of the company. You say this:

    “On[date] I purchased an air-inclusive package from Expedia. Upon arriving at the airport on [date] Expedia has not purchased tickets as part of the package. I was forced to purchase day of travel tickets. That cost was $871 more than the cost of the package. My Expedia package itinerary was [insert itinerary number] and attached is a photocopy of my ticket receipt for the purchased package.

    Demand is made for the immediate payment of $871 which is the excess of actual travel cost versus the travel cost Expedia promised me. Failure to receive a check for the aforementioned amount within 30 days will result in litigation.”

    Period – end of letter – end of demands. Don’t bother following their procedures and sending demands second and third copies of documents which they lost to every escalating departments. One letter. One demand. Then, small claims court. You sue them for breach of contract. In a case like this, you will EASILY win.

    Once Expedia gets the lawsuit, someone will a) contact you immediately and you will have a check within days, or b) they will not show up and you can start looking for assets to attach.

  • Byron Cooper

    I do not think Expedia, Orbitz, Travelocity, and other online agencies add any value for the extra charge. I have seen numerous complaints on elliott.org and elsewhere to ever use them for any reason. My daughter booked a round trip flight with Expedia when she was in college and realized that she made a mistake in the departure and destination within one to two minutes. The flight had not been ticketed yet so she successfully disputed the charge with her American Express Credit card when Expedia refused to help. There are instances when you need a live travel agency. My daughter just got married and she is on her honeymoon. She took the Elliott.org advice and used a real travel agent, American Express. I have not heard anything so everything must be going extremely well!

  • Arizona Road Warrior

    Another negative story about an online travel agency. I am sure that there will be some comments posted stating “I have dealt with this online travel agency for years and never had any problems”…that is great. I judge a company when you have a problem…that shows their true colors.

  • http://www.cutcat.com ChelseaGirl

    I’m very surprised that some people think it is not the customer’s responsibility to check his/her reservations. It is a shared responsibility: The travel agent or booking site needs to do its job, but that doesn’t mean you as the consumer can just sit back and do nothing. You do need to make sure everything is in order, because screw-ups obviously do happen (and it seems like they happen a lot with Expedia). If you feel that because you have used third-party booking that you don’t need to follow up, that is leaving yourself open to problems. Again, it doesn’t excuse the agency for lousy service, but the consumer always has to be proactive; it doesn’t matter what you are buying. When I book with Priceline or Hotwire, I call the hotel to make sure they have my reservation.

  • Jason

    It is not just six characters confirmation number, you need also thirteen digits ticket number. Each airline has assigned first three digits, and even if you travel on multiple airlines, there is only one will be issuing a ticket. You may have a confirmation number, but if tickets are not issued before departure, you may be asked to pay again at the airport. Confirmation number is just holding your seat on the plane, ticket is evidence you paid for your seat.

    My job used American Express Corporate Travel to book my trip from CLE to TUS. They booked me on Continental. It was rainy day in March, but temperature was dropping. After we got on the plane the rain became ice and Continental cancelled all flights out of CLE. It was rush hours around 6 pm. Tens of thousands of people were directed to a handful of agents for reaccomodation. Southwest and United were still flying but they were cutting some people off to have only half full planes to be able to take off from an icy runway. I hanged at the airport for a while and when I learn there is no chance for me to fly that day; I phoned American Express travel and asked them to rebook me on the first available flight next morning. A representative confirmed me on 7 am US Air. But the confirmation number he said is the same as I had for Continental. It alerted me. After I got to airport hotel, I decided to call Continental and confirm if I had a confirmed flight for next morning. The hold time for an agent was 70 minutes. The agent said you do have a confirmed flight on US air but ask if I could be on hold for a moment because he needed to check something. After another about an hour “moment” of hold the agent explained: He spoke with his help desk and after my flight was cancelled due to weather, Continental automatically rebooked me on the first available Continental flight 3 days later. Amex travel confirmed me on US Air flight but they didn’t re-issue ticket I only had a confirmation. So, Continental help desk cancelled my US Air reservation without even asking me because they didn’t want to transfer the ticket to another airline and found a spot on 5 am Continental flight. By the time I got off the phone it was already 1 am. I had to start making my way back to the airport, because taxis or hotel shuttle did not operate due to three feet of snow. I made it on 5 am flight, we pulled from the gate and the engines would not start. We stock in the midfield because of ice the ground equipment to bring plane back to the gate did not operate. Finally we were back at the gate at 7 am. I got of the plane and first phoned to Amex Travel and asked to get me out of here now, I mentioned I can make it to 7:12 am US air flight. A person I spoke was really helpful and she issued a new ticket within a minute. I ran fast from one end of the airport to another and made it. Problem was I had a full fare Continental ticket and Amex booked me a new full fare US air ticket. It took me about three months to get refund from Continental, because according to the record I took the flight. My boarding pass registered when I got on the plane, but they did not noted I got off the plane.

  • Joe Farrell

    As much as I hate to say this in public – I use Expedia almost exclusively – I have never seen Orbita or Travelocity have any different fares or availability. That said- I do NOT use Expedia to actually book tickets- I use them to do a fare survey. Then – noting the times of the fare and the flights and the airline, I go to that airlines website to actually book the ticket. Why? Because there is a) ZERO risk of a screw-up and b) I have proof that a ticket was immediately purchased for me, seats selected and evidence on airline ‘letterhead’ that they sold me something. Kinda hard to deny that American/United etc sold you a ticket when you have proof that they sold you something. Its just too easy for them to ‘blame someone else’ when something goes wrong, if someone else is involved.

    I have yet to have ANY travel agent add anything to my travel experience other than fees and an opportunity for error. I have been forced to use corporate agents on occasion and everything single time I have used them some part of the trip has had something go wrong – perhaps its as simple as booking a wrong category of room or simply paying too much for one. Rarely will a corporate travel agent book the lowest rate – they will book the lowest commissionable rate. A travel is entitled to be paid for their work, assuming that they add some value to the transaction. I have yet to find that value.

  • Carver

    If I have to do all the work of calling, verifying, etc. what exactly did I spend my money purchasing with the travel agent? That’s why unless its a particular complicated trip, I just go directly to the travel provider. AA.com, Marriott, com, SPG.com, etc.

  • Bill

    I agree with Joe’s comments completely. I have used Expedia a couple of times to buy tickets, but largely I do what he does – direct from the airline.

    I also seem to run into troubles every time there is a travel agent involved. Amex Platinum years ago was the absolute worst, but other ones aren’t much better.
    I don’t know who certifies or evaluates the competence of travel agents, but I am glad that doctors, dentists, pilots, etc are not done in the same way or we’d be in real trouble.

  • Jason

    Sometimes even if you purchase your ticket directly with an airline the ticket is not issued due to some technical issues. It doesn’t make difference where or how ticket was purchased, you can always go to airline website, retrive your itinerary and see if there is a ticket number on your receipt. If you can’t find ticket number – call. Just seat selection will not give you right to fly. You can select and reserve seats without even buying ticket and you will have six character confirmation number. When you purchase ticket you usually will get two e-mails: first, a confirmation, and second, a receipt with a ticket number. Or if for some reasons you transfered to a different airline make sure to ask the agent if your ticket was endorsed to that airline. My United flight was cancelled due to mechanical issue, United reservation booked me on Delta. An agent provided me with Delta confirmation number. When I arrived at Delta gate, I was told that even I had a reservation, United did not pushed ticket to Delta and I was sent back to United to fix it.

  • BucksterSF

    I used to use Expedia exclusively for the simple reason they had better rates. Now I usually book online with airline and property (after using Expedia to see who goes my routes directly) because in some cases they’re cheaper to go direct. They are never any more these days. In fact, most are exactly the same, with the only difference being Expedia’s booking fee.

  • MeanMeosh

    @ Carver – well said. I find it somewhat ludicrous that those who utilize the services of a travel agent should then have to do a bunch of work themselves to make sure that the travel agent is doing what they’re being paid to do. It would be like if my clients paid me money to prepare and electronically file their tax returns, then are advised that they need to call the IRS to confirm that I actually did it. Mistakes happen on occasion, but if the argument is you can’t rely on a PAID travel agent to do what they’re supposed to on a regular basis, that’s a pretty jarring indictment of the industry.

  • Arizona Road Warrior

    @ MeanMeosh – “Mistakes happen on occasion, but if the argument is you can’t rely on a PAID travel agent to do what they’re supposed to on a regular basis, that’s a pretty jarring indictment of the industry.”
    - – - – - – - – - – - – -
    My question is “Are Expedia, Travelocity, etc. travel agents?” IMHO, they are not. These sites are booking sites. If you call their call centers do you speak with a person that is a licensed travel agent? My guess that the answer is no.

  • Carver

    @Arizona

    If you call their call centers do you speak with a person that is a licensed travel agent?
    ==============================================
    Except of course that no state licenses travel agents in the same sense that plumbers, real estate agents, contractors, etc. are licensed. Accordingly, each travel agency determines for itself the level of skill, experience, and competency required of its travel agent employees.

    So while we may individually choose to define that a “true travel agent” is, there is no general consensus. One person considers AAA and Amex to be travel agents, another does not.

  • http://www.talestoldfromtheroad.com Dick Jordan

    I think I have used Expedia or Travelocity once to book a hotel room. I have read so many complaints about Expedia and Travelocity that I am sure I would never book through them again.

    Like other readers, I use third-party sites (I preferKayak) to help me determine which airlines fly between which cities, and to obtain flight schedules and fares. Then I book directly with the airline.

    If I don’t have a guidebook, I also use third-party booking sites to locate hotels and get a quick read on room rates.

    Occasionally, I use these sites to check out rental car availability, although I always reserve a car directly through the rental car company Website.

  • Charles

    I’ve used Expedia and Orbitz for years. When booking only plane tickets, it’s nearly always cheaper to go to the airline, but travel packages can be significantly discounted on these sites. Our trip to Jamaica this summer was about $400 (20%) cheaper than anywhere else due to the package price. I could not book the parts separately and get as good a deal. I always go to the airline web site after the booking and look up the reservation, but I’ve not had any problems with either company.

  • Mike Z

    @Arizona Road Warrior “My question is “Are Expedia, Travelocity, etc. travel agents?” IMHO, they are not. These sites are booking sites.”

    All of those companies act as an intermediary between you, the traveler and the actual companies providing the service. They all sell airline, hotel and package deals. They all claim to offer services like a travel agent, insurance for example, or even a pledge to help out in case of a problem. My guess is that they are also licensed in the state they have a physical presence in to sell these products, which would make them a travel agent.

    Are you telling me that a travel agency would not be allowed to have anyone working for it that wasn’t licensed? It was my understanding that you had to be licensed to SELL, not to shuffle papers or help a customer after the sale.

  • Chicky

    I have booked a couple of rooms with hotels.com because their rates were cheaper even than those on the hotels’ web sites. However, I called the hotel directly to make sure the reservations were confirmed.
    Like Joe and Carver, I generally use Expedia and Co. to survey the available fares and so forth. I use those sites as an overview. Occasionally, I’ll rent a car through Hotwire or Priceline, since I don’t care, really, which company I rent from, as long as they have a car for me on the day I need it.
    Usually, though, I reserve rooms, flights and cars through the company web sites. So far (fingers crossed), I’ve never had a problem. And almost always, with a little poking around, especially for cars and hotels, I can often find a little extra discount I can use. For example, I rented a car through Alamo recently and since it was a weekend rental, I got a $15 discount, which paid the taxes and fees. Not bad.
    If I were booking a complicated international itinerary, however, I’d go to a human travel agent at a brick and mortar company in my town. One office is just up the street from where I work, so if something goes wrong, I know where to find them. LOL.

  • Linda Snow

    I agree with the posters saying they use the booking sites to find itineraries, then book directly with the airline. That’s certainly the best way – except when it doesn’t work. I once found the Delta itinerary I wanted on travelocity, then went to Delta website and they didn’t list it. Ended up having to take my chances with travelocity after all.

    I also agree with the posters who said Chris was expecting too much from the OP, especially in the matter of “insisting” that Expedia buy her tickets while she was standing at the airport – they obviously weren’t going to do that, and her acceptance that they were promising a refund in good faith is about all she could have done at that point.

  • Kevin M

    Whether or not Travelorbpedia is a “real” travel agent or not isn’t the question.

    When you book a ticket on these sites, it’s my understanding a fee for the service is included. If that’s the case, then they are being paid to perform a service, and it is not unreasonable, in my view, to expect them to perform that service.

    Now, speaking from a practical standpoint: no matter who you pay to perform any service, it behooves you to stay on top of things and not just assume it will be done according to the agreement you believe you have. I had a roof installed recently; although I’d gone over the details of the requirement carefully with the roofer, I was still out there checking on the work constantly – not because it’s my job to do so, but because it was the only way I could know for sure it was done. There are a handful of vendors I trust implicitly enough to allow them largely unsupervised work; the rest, I watch, because even if only 1% aren’t fully competent and trustworthy, that 1% can ruin your day.

  • http://ckbtvl@ma.rr.com Geoff

    Airlines make as many errors as anybody. Expedia was just wron! There are still a great number of real people “TRAVEL AGENTS”. Our tour wholesaler pricematches every legitimate online agency. Human travel agents, wow a real person with a real name in your real niegborhood….who could ask for more. People planning expensive vacations need a person that they can trust! By the way, for Michele, I have lower airfares for many vacation destinations, than you will ever find on the internet, just another way that great travel agents help their customers.

  • Joel Wechsler

    @Joe Farrell What is your source for the statement that “rarely will a corporate agent book the lowest rate-they will book the lowest commissionable rate.”? This is, in my opinion, a gross canard, unsupportred by any facts. It is like my saying that rarely does a lawyer stay at the most economical hotels when the client is paying. As to the value added by a travel agent, I would say that I can buy a kit that will enable me to write a legallly binding will and don’t need an attorney. On the other hand, if I have a complicated estate I would consult one. The same is true of travel-if your trip is simple you can do it yourself but if it’s complex you might need a specialist who knows more than you do about destinations, hotels, complicated airline itineraries etc. That is where the value is added by a good travel agent./

  • http://www.roamingtales.com Caitlin @ Roaming Tales

    Chris, you said: “Even though you received a flight confirmation the day before your trip, why didn’t you confirm it with the airline directly?”

    Really? I thought flight confirmations were a thing of the past. Every time I’ve tried to do it in the last decade, airlines have consistently told me that you don’t have to do this any more.

    But yes, Expedia should have paid for the new tickets in the first place.

  • Roger

    I had a very similar experience about 5 years ago, but with Travelocity. I ended up on the phone for 2 hours with their India-based customer support, who were unable to handle anything outside of their scripts.

  • ronda

    I’d say if they had paid up right off the bat, the travel agency should only be responsible for the difference, I think for waiting, they should’ve given they’re costumer (who they obviously got alot of money from, last time I checked 5000 is no chunk change) some goodwill vouchers or maybe a discount on they’re next vacation. Sure its not necissary, but in this economy, can they really afford to lose costomers. particularily costomers that are smart enouph to come to consumer advocates like Christopher Elliott?

  • Outrigger77

    Expedia sold me a ticket with an airline they don’t even have a contract with.