Are travelers overloaded by social media?

Mary Gallagher recently received an e-mail from the Metropolitan Tucson Convention & Visitors Bureau offering “hot deals.” But there was a catch: In order to receive them, she had to follow Tucson’s tourist authority on Twitter and friend it on Facebook.

That didn’t sit well with Gallagher, a travel writer, who said she receives enough deals each day.

“How much Facebook and Twitter drivel could you spend each day reading?” she said. “This really, really annoys me.”

Are travelers overloaded by social media? It’s a timely question, given the release of “The Social Network,” which topped the box office for several weeks in October, is about the origin of Facebook, the most successful social network on the planet.

Travel is a huge component of social networking, propelling applications like Where I’ve Been — a website that allows users to mark their travel history on a color-coded map — to stardom.

“It can get to the point where it’s too much,” said Brian Ek, who oversees some of Priceline’s social media efforts. Which is to say, somewhere along the line, the travel experience isn’t meaningfully enhanced by having more friends or followers.
“I’m not sure if, as a traveler, you have to participate in a social network in order to have a good trip,” he said.

But where’s the line? Gallagher saw it when Tucson e-mailed her. She replied to the sender, complaining that social networking deals exclude travelers who don’t participate in these newer networks. She also asked that her name be deleted from Tucson’s distribution list.
Related: See the world through your smart phone

A 2010 YPartnership survey suggests most travelers are probably still looking for the line. Results show that 91 percent of respondents use Facebook, about a quarter use MySpace, and 17 percent are on Twitter. But the research also notes that only 1 in 20 leisure travelers has ever made a travel decision based primarily on research or feedback received from a social networking site.

A recent University of Maryland study found that American college students are addicted to social media. In fact, being away from social media was like a withdrawal, similar to the kind experienced by an alcoholic. One of the researchers, Susan Moeller, described some of the subjects as “incredibly addicted.”

A recent survey of frequent travelers by Egnyte, an information technology company, found that 53 percent of people admit to using their smart phone when in a hotel bathroom.

When the line between reality and virtual reality start to blur, you could be in trouble. “You lose track with whether or not you’ve spoken with someone or whether you’ve seen something on Twitter or Facebook,” said Chris McGinnins, a travel blogger with an active social network. McGinnis said older travelers, who can remember a time before social networking, might find something wrong with this behavior when it’s pointed out to them. But younger travelers think nothing of it. And that worries him.
And who said you can never have too many friends? Many travel companies, including media-savvy JetBlue, have initiatives aimed at boosting networks simply for the sake of having the highest profile. JetBlue (1.5 million Twitter followers) recently gave away 25,000 frequent flier miles to random followers.

On the flip side, there are individual travelers who are in the business of collecting friends and followers, too. Experts would diagnose this kind of compulsive behavior as an addiction if it involved anything else.

If you’re obsessively collecting new followers, can’t bear to be apart from your cell phone and often confuse what’s happening on your social network with reality, you, like Gallagher, have found the line.

(Photo: B. Hernández/Flickr Creative Commons)

  • http://nmdfreelance.com Nancy Dickinson

    As a travel writer myself, I think Mary Gallagher is being a little too sensitive in this instance.

    First, travel writers are inundated with e-mails, phone calls and mail asking we come visit a place. It’s easy to become upset at the large number of requests we get.

    However, I am also on the Tucson CVB mailing lists. I DO follow them on Twitter and I am friends with them on Facebook. I do the same for probably more than 100 places like the Tucson CVB. The Tucson CVB sends out a great deal less postings than do other places on my “friends” or “follow” list.

    I don’t think it’s out of line to ask people to follow them to get the good deals. It encourages people to come back again and again.

    My thoughts to Mary? Get past it and let the travel industry grow with the times. The deals aren’t JUST for people who get the e-mail, Facebook posting or Tweet; that’s just who got the notice first. I can easily pass on deals to friends and no one’s feelings are hurt if the person is the second, third or fourth generation from the original offering.

  • Shelly

    Thank you, Mary! I’m in complete and total agreement with you. As a travel agent, I’m told constantly that I have to have a website where my clients can book, and that I have to be active on all the latest social media in order to thrive.

    I do have a website with my address and phone listed, but it’s not bookable. A website cannot dialogue with my clients and discern their wants and needs by listening to them speak about their prior travel experiences.

    I do not participate in any social media other than word of mouth. I find the current preoccupation with texting and blogging very tedious. I’ll take a good conversation with a human being over an form of electronic communication any day.

    Everyone has travel “deals”. I want to know that my “deals” will fit my clients’ “needs”. Sometimes it’s the price, but more often it’s the value and the experience that they’re after.

    My clients do not remember the “deal” they got on their last vacation. They talk about the experience they’ll remember for the rest of their lives.

    Yes, I’m middle aged with two late teens children but I guess I’m just not as gullible as I used to be.

  • http://www.travel-rants.com Darren Cronian

    I am always suspicious when a company leaves a ‘fantastic, never to be beaten deal’ on social networks like Twitter and Facebook, and on the few occasions I have checked the link, I have attempted to book this ‘fantastic, never to be beaten deal’ to find out what it is now ‘sold out’.

    I suspect A LOT of the deals you see on social media networks are simply hooks to get you into through the door. The question is, does the trade description act apply on social networks – I suspect that ads and deals aren’t monitored by the likes of the Office of Fair Trading here in the UK.

  • jen

    I have a different point of view. As a traveller in my mid-30s I am very interested in the “insider” deals available on social media. I love researching travel and see interesting deals all the time. I will occasionally “Like” or “follow” someone on Facebook or Twitter for a deal or promotion, but it is very easy to unlike or unfollow them if there’s no value in the connection.

    For my recent trip to Las Vegas I monitored most Vegas resorts and many airlines, restaurants and entertainment venues for deals and events. There were several Tweet-ups where followers are invited for free drinks and prizes and also deals for Twitter/Facebook followers at restaurants and hotels.

    If you don’t like it, don’t do it. No one is forcing you. But if you’re a budget traveler or travel professional and you choose to stubbornly reject these technological advances on principle, it’s your loss.

  • http://tdhurst.com Tyler Hurst

    You can’t be bothered to follow someone on Twitter for the chance to get a killer deal?

    Really? THEN DON’T FOLLOW THE ACCOUNT.

    Jesus, how hard is this?