Is Target’s price-match guarantee an empty promise?


1-TargetQuestion: I recently tried to price-match merchandise at a Target store in Framingham, Mass. I had read the price match policy online, and I was sure I was eligible. But I was denied.

I followed up with the corporate 1-800 number, and was twice given the same
(startling) answer: Target will not price match any printed ad that is not valid for an entire week. They exclude these ads because they are “timed” events, like door-busters and early-bird sales.

I think this is really not very honest of them. Target appears to be trying to wiggle out of granting a price match. Can you help me get them to do the right thing? — Ben Blout, Boston

Answer: Price-matching sure sounds like a great idea. You find an item that costs less at a competitor and the store matches that price. But in practice, it can be difficult to make a successful claim.

You reviewed the fine print in Target’s offer before trying to make a claim. That’s good. But unfortunately, you don’t get to interpret the contract — they do. And Target told you repeatedly that the item you were trying to make a claim on was marked down as part of a “timed” event.

The irony is that Target’s price-matching was a timed event itself. Its offer on “select” items ran from Nov. 1 to Dec. 16.

You sent several emails to Target, making some valid points. The wording on its price-match offer could have been clearer (it was obviously written by attorneys) and its answers to you seemed canned.

I’ve dealt with guarantees like this in the hotel and airline industry for many years, and once you peel back all the layers of fine print, you’re not left with much. These price promises really serve as nothing more than marketing gimmicks, in my experience. But as a Target customer, I felt you would stand a good chance of getting something beyond a boilerplate response.

After you’ve emailed Target at this form, you might try an appeal to one of the executives. The naming convention for emails is firstname.lastname@target.com — it’s fairly easy to determine the rest.

I contacted Target on your behalf. In response, it sent you yet another form email saying it was “sorry” for your disappointment and thanking you for your feedback. How disappointing.

Is Target's price-match guarantee an empty promise?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Christopher Elliott

Christopher Elliott is an author, journalist and consumer advocate. You can read more about him on his personal website or contact him at . Got a question or comment? You can post it on the new forum.

More Posts - Website - Twitter - Google Plus