The Customer Service Hall of Shame through the years: And the winner is …

Uh, make that the loser — AOL. That’s according to an aggregation of four years of the Customer Service Hall of Shame, a yearly study of customer service done by MSN Money and Zogby International.

Who would have thought?

The worst companies were determined by the percentage of respondents who described their customer experience with a company as “poor.” The worst 10 make up the Hall of Shame. I should note that MSN also has a Hall of Fame for the best companies, but that’s a story for another day.

Let’s have a look at the worst companies through the years, starting in 2007, the first year the survey was conducted. AOL didn’t even make the cut in the first year. Instead, it was dominated by cable companies and wireless providers. But that was about to change …

By 2008, AOL had vaulted into first place. Another newcomer to the list was Abercrombie & Fitch.

Huh? How can a clothing retailer generate that many complaints?

Here’s the next year. Again, AOL in first, with the cables, wireless and banks trailing. And Abercrombie & Fitch, still hanging on by a thread.


By this year, we’re back to normal. Abercrombie appears to have gotten its act together, AOL is still on top, and the usual suspects remain on the list.

What’s wrong with AOL? The question should be: What’s not wrong with it? A cursory review of the complaints filed against the Internet service provider suggests its prone to double-billing customers, making it difficult to cancel, and otherwise delivering inferior service.

The banks and credit cards? That, too, is a topic for another time.

So now that you know who delivers the worst service, what can you do about it?

Evaluate your own situation. Are you getting bad service from one of these companies? If so, you might want to reconsider your loyalty. If not, stay put — but consider yourself warned.

Let the company know you’re disappointed. You need to give the company a chance to make things right, even if it’s at the bottom of the barrel. If it can’t, then move on.

Don’t threaten; just walk away. Your actions will speak louder than words. Shouting about your situation from the rooftops, while effective in the short term, doesn’t speak as forcefully as a customer who takes his or her business elsewhere.

How about you? Which companies deserve to make this list? Do you see any that shouldn’t be here?

  • http://www.sanibel-rentals.net Sylvia

    No great surprises here. Phone/internet and bank services dominant the group. The problem with the phone services is once you have “left” Sprint, Verizon and AT&T, there are not many choices.

    If ever you do a piece on the BEST customer service, I nominate Netflix. Their superb responses have kept us out of the movie theatres for years!

  • Eric Zawid

    I agree about Netflix. They are on the top of my list for best customer service.

  • Steve Dennison

    I certainly agree with Sylvia about the fact that there are no great surprises concerning who is on the list. Talking (communicating) and money … just what you would expect from the world’s biggest economy. And these are also companies with huge clienteles, and the proportion of complaints is bound to be larger. But if you own stock in AOL, it is past time to ditch it.
    I’ll also back up the Netflix vote as one of the best in terms of customer service, too!

  • MORT HERMAN

    I AGREE WITH YOU HALL OF SHAME LIST. THERE ARE MANY MORE BUT THE SADDEST PART OF IT ALL IS THAT THESE COMPANIES DO NOT GIVE A D___N. ALL WE CONSUMERS CAN DO IS GO ELSEWHERE BUT IN THE FINAL ANALYSIS, IT WON’T HELP. WE HAVE LOST OUR SENSE OF ETHICS.

  • cyn

    I don’t get all the upset over AOL, I have used them since they came into being and while there were times I pulled my hair out in frustration, I have not had a problem in years…….now I still use them for my email since they have the best, hands down, email program around. BUT, I don’t pay for it, it’s free, so why doesn’t everyone use the free AOL? I don’t get it??

  • Catherine Ffrench

    Can anyone give me email addresses or an email address of an executive at Abercrombie & Fitch? I’ve called customer service several times and they aren’t any help. I’ve been searching the internet for days and am coming to the conclusion that any executive’s email address at A&F is top secret. If anyone can email me a valid email for one of the executives at this company, I’d really appreciate it. Thanks.

  • Sand

    I changed the name on my Verizon account after my husband died.  They said it was a new account and upped my rates.  They get my vote as the worst.