Is mandatory car rental insurance a “bait and switch” scheme?

Studioartz/Shutterstock
Studioartz/Shutterstock
When Michael Kestan rented a car in Israel through Expedia, he went through all the steps necessary to ensure he was insured. That included buying travel insurance through Expedia, which, he was assured, would cover him.

It didn’t.

“When I arrived in Israel I was advised that Hertz had a mandatory insurance,” he says. “The insurance was $29 per day — twice as much as the car rental. At no time did Expedia advise me of these charges and at no time was I given an opportunity to shop around.”

This isn’t the first complaint I’ve had about Expedia or its lax disclosure of mandatory car rental insurance. Here’s a case I mediated back in 2011.

Just for kicks, I went shopping for a rental car in Tel Aviv for next month. At the bottom of the rate sheet, in fine print, it says, “May not include mandatory insurance charges that are required for certain international rentals.”

Is that enough disclosure? Maybe.

But the fact that Expedia would sell a travel insurance policy that purports to cover Kestan — I find that problematic.

Of course, he had no choice but to pay the $29-a-day insurance, which significantly increased the cost of his rental. When he asked Expedia to cover the cost, it refused.

He adds,

They have only refunded the $72 for the insurance I bought through Expedia. At least that’s what they said on the phone — I have not seen evidence of this yet.

Expedia, as I understand, has known about this “bait and switch” and is simply refusing to live up to its responsibility to ensure that they deliver what they promise.

I do not understand how they can offer this insurance when they know it is not accepted. They need to live up to their commitment. I firmly believe that Expedia should reimburse me the mandatory insurance charge.”

I see his point. Why sell a product that won’t cover you? Why quote a rate when you know everyone renting a car from the United States will be forced to pay for the insurance?

Expedia is the largest, most successful, and arguably the most technologically sophisticated of the online travel agencies. If there’s a way to squeeze a profit out of something using technology, you can bet it’ll find it.

A few years ago, I might have given Expedia the benefit of the doubt. There were just so many products it offered on its site, and asking it to do something like Kestan wants seemed unrealistic. But I believe it has the technology to pull something like this off. I also think it has an obligation to make sure these “misunderstandings” — which only benefit Expedia — don’t happen.

“What is most upsetting is that Expedia is allowing customers to believe they are renting a car at a price of $14 per day and when they arrive in Israel the charge is more than three times the price,” he says.

I agree.

I contacted Expedia on his behalf. Here’s how it responded:

The customer service team has taken a closer look at Mr. Kestan’s case and has confirmed that a refund was processed for the insurance not honored by Hertz in the amount of $72. In addition, Expedia is offering the customer a $50 travel voucher for future travel.

A $50 travel voucher is nice, but I’m not sure it’s enough.

Is mandatory car rental insurance a "bait and switch" scheme?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Note: We are experiencing some latency with new comments posting today. We’re working on a fix. Thanks for your patience.

  • http://flyicarusfly.com/ Fly, Icarus, Fly

    I checked a few other international car rentals and Tel Aviv compact cars average $50-60 per day. So if the OP got it for $14, that would’ve been a red flag. I’m hoping he checked more than Expedia before booking because that would’ve turned up: Why is Expedia 1/3 the price of everyone else? If it’s a nationwide surcharge (ie. not specific to any one rental company), then Expedia should prominently inform. Otherwise, a disclaimer that additional fees may apply is sufficient. Then it’s up to the renter to look up the specific info for that particular rental company / location, I think…

  • TonyA_says

    That’s exactly where the problem is Travel is not equal to Auto Liability insurance

  • TonyA_says

    That’s exactly where the problem is. Travel is not equal to Auto Liability insurance

  • bodega3

    Car rental insurance Show Details Hide Details

    $242.00 each car

    By selecting this product I acknowledge I have read and agree to the terms of
    the Description of
    Coverage

    This robust plan provides coverage for collision,
    theft, vandalism, and much more, regardless of destination and includes a $250
    deductible. This insurance is underwritten by Stonebridge Casualty insurance
    company, and is administered by BerkelyCare, a division of Affinity Insurance
    Services, Inc.
    View more information:Car Rental Insurance Plan

    Please note that in some
    rental destinations, such as Mexico, car rental companies may have
    additional insurance requirements such as a mandatory purchase of liability
    coverage.

  • bodega3

    I found that Expedia does provide information that additional insurance may be required depending on the country of rental.

  • bodega3

    I found that Expedia does provide information that additional insurance may be required depending on the country of rental.

  • http://www.facebook.com/geoffrey.millstone Geoffrey Millstone

    It appears to me that he purchased Expedia normal cancellation insurance. Then he had to purchase Hertz mandatory insurance. What a lack of research on his part. Europa, Kemwell, and a dozen others offer the rentals with “all’ INSURANCES AND TAXES.

  • http://www.facebook.com/geoffrey.millstone Geoffrey Millstone

    It appears to me that he purchased Expedia normal cancellation insurance. Then he had to purchase Hertz mandatory insurance. What a lack of research on his part. Europa, Kemwell, and a dozen others offer the rentals with “all’ INSURANCES AND TAXES.

  • TonyA_says

    I went to Expedia and tried to rent a car from Hertz in TLV airport.

    The price had a disclosure.
    * Includes estimated taxes and fees. May not include mandatory insurance charges that are required for certain international rentals. Car charges are billed at time of rental.

    Displaying the Detailed Car Rental Information:

    THIRD PARTY PROPERTY DAMAGE – TPPD
    ———————————-
    TPPD IS A SERVICE THAT PROVIDES COVERAGE UP TO USD
    500,000.00 AGAINST PROPERTY DAMAGE.
    TPPD IS INCLUDED IF THE RATE INCLUDES CDW OR THE
    CUSTOMER PURCHASES CDW. TPPD IS NOT INCLUDED AND
    BECOMES MANDATORY TO PURCHASE IF CDW IS OPTIONAL AND
    CUSTOMER DOES NOT PURCHASE IT.
    TPPD REDUCES THE RENTERS RESPONSIBILITY IN THE EVENT OF
    DAMAGE TO THIRD PARTY TO AN AMOUNT RANGING FROM USD515
    TO USD1035.00
    TPPD FEES APPLY TO ALL RATES EXCEPT AEX WHERE THE
    ADDITIONAL FEE WILL RANGE FROM USD 12.00 TO USD 17.00
    EXCLUDING TAX PER DAY AND DEPENDING ON THE VEHICLE
    GROUP.

    Okay, so what is the OP complaining about? Maybe he should read the details further.
    He bought Travel Insurance which had nothing to do with Auto Rental Liability Insurance.

  • TonyA_says

    I went to Expedia and tried to rent a car from Hertz in TLV airport.

    The price had a disclosure.
    * Includes estimated taxes and fees. May not include mandatory insurance charges that are required for certain international rentals. Car charges are billed at time of rental.

    Displaying the Detailed Car Rental Information:

    THIRD PARTY PROPERTY DAMAGE – TPPD
    ———————————-
    TPPD IS A SERVICE THAT PROVIDES COVERAGE UP TO USD
    500,000.00 AGAINST PROPERTY DAMAGE.
    TPPD IS INCLUDED IF THE RATE INCLUDES CDW OR THE
    CUSTOMER PURCHASES CDW. TPPD IS NOT INCLUDED AND
    BECOMES MANDATORY TO PURCHASE IF CDW IS OPTIONAL AND
    CUSTOMER DOES NOT PURCHASE IT.
    TPPD REDUCES THE RENTERS RESPONSIBILITY IN THE EVENT OF
    DAMAGE TO THIRD PARTY TO AN AMOUNT RANGING FROM USD515
    TO USD1035.00
    TPPD FEES APPLY TO ALL RATES EXCEPT AEX WHERE THE
    ADDITIONAL FEE WILL RANGE FROM USD 12.00 TO USD 17.00
    EXCLUDING TAX PER DAY AND DEPENDING ON THE VEHICLE
    GROUP.

    Okay, so what is the OP complaining about? Maybe he should read the details further.
    He bought Travel Insurance which had nothing to do with Auto Rental Liability Insurance.

  • fithsk

    The breathalyser in France is no longer a problem, as it was finally decided that no fines can be given for not having one.

  • fithsk

    The breathalyser in France is no longer a problem, as it was finally decided that no fines can be given for not having one.

  • bodega3

    What the heck is going on. I have posted twice with information from Expedia’s site that they state that some countries will have additional insurance requirements over the purchased coverage, but both are gone.

  • bodega3

    What the heck is going on. I have posted twice with information from Expedia’s site that they state that some countries will have additional insurance requirements over the purchased coverage, but both are gone.

  • Hal

    Disqus seems to be having issues lately. I have had problems getting responses to post the last few days. End up having to post multiple times before they show up. I had it requesting verification I wasn’t a bot but didn’t see it because the popup blocker was hiding it. They have changed the email message format (the new one really sucks) so I’m guessing they are mucking around with it a lot lately.

  • Hal

    Disqus seems to be having issues lately. I have had problems getting responses to post the last few days. End up having to post multiple times before they show up. I had it requesting verification I wasn’t a bot but didn’t see it because the popup blocker was hiding it. They have changed the email message format (the new one really sucks) so I’m guessing they are mucking around with it a lot lately.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1275578005 Noah Rosenthal

    Outrageous. On the other hand, $43/day for a rental car isn’t too bad.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1275578005 Noah Rosenthal

    Outrageous. On the other hand, $43/day for a rental car isn’t too bad.

  • Grant

    Hi Bodega,
    Sorry about that. For some reason, both posts were stuck in the spam filter.

  • Grant

    Hi Bodega,
    Sorry about that. For some reason, both posts were stuck in the spam filter.

  • JenniferFinger

    In this instance, the OP was not in or going to Europe or Ireland. And it’s not unreasonable to expect one’s travel agent (in this case, Expedia) to disclose all information necessary to make an informed decision. If a country like Israel requires extra insurance and/or the travel vendor won’t honor what the agent is selling, the agent has a duty to disclose that to the customer. That didn’t happen here, leaving the OP to believe that the product the agent sold him would be honored over there. And before you bring up “doing your homework,” that’s what many people hire travel agents for-because the agents have the professional contacts and access that makes that their day job. Most travelers don’t have that sophistication. The travel agent had the duty to only sell products that would be actually honored at face value and not leave their customer open to “surprise charges.”

  • JenniferFinger

    In this instance, the OP was not in or going to Europe or Ireland. And it’s not unreasonable to expect one’s travel agent (in this case, Expedia) to disclose all information necessary to make an informed decision. If a country like Israel requires extra insurance and/or the travel vendor won’t honor what the agent is selling, the agent has a duty to disclose that to the customer. That didn’t happen here, leaving the OP to believe that the product the agent sold him would be honored over there. And before you bring up “doing your homework,” that’s what many people hire travel agents for-because the agents have the professional contacts and access that makes that their day job. Most travelers don’t have that sophistication. The travel agent had the duty to only sell products that would be actually honored at face value and not leave their customer open to “surprise charges.”

  • TonyA_says

    When you book a rental car from Expedia, they will offer you some kind of Car Rental Insurance. [Note: this is not the same as the Travel Insurance mentioned in the article.]

    But that “insurance” is for Damage Protection and NOT LIABILITY.

    Unfortunately, in ISRAEL, can rental companies charge for Liability Insurance.

    The rate offered to him by Expedia did not include Hertz’s (Liability Insurance) THIRD PARTY PROPERTY DAMAGE (TPPD). It also did not include CDW. TPPD is mandatory unless a customer purchases CDW from Hertz.

    In my opinion, the OP did not FULLY understand what he was getting into when renting a car in Israel.

  • TonyA_says

    When you book a rental car from Expedia, they will offer you some kind of Car Rental Insurance. [Note: this is not the same as the Travel Insurance mentioned in the article.]

    But that “insurance” is for Damage Protection and NOT LIABILITY.

    Unfortunately, in ISRAEL, can rental companies charge for Liability Insurance.

    The rate offered to him by Expedia did not include Hertz’s (Liability Insurance) THIRD PARTY PROPERTY DAMAGE (TPPD). It also did not include CDW. TPPD is mandatory unless a customer purchases CDW from Hertz.

    In my opinion, the OP did not FULLY understand what he was getting into when renting a car in Israel.

  • TonyA_says

    The $14 is a BASE rate for an Economy 4 Door. The TOTAL rate is $42.

    In addition there are 2 other charges to worry about:

    (1) Airport Pickup/Drop Off Charge $27

    -AND-

    (2) Liability Insurance. If you get CDW ($17/day) then it is covered.
    Otherwise, you will pay $9-12day for TPPD.

    In other words, the true rental cost is about $60++ a day (for a short term).

  • TonyA_says

    The $14 is a BASE rate for an Economy 4 Door. The TOTAL rate is $42.

    In addition there are 2 other charges to worry about:

    (1) Airport Pickup/Drop Off Charge $27

    -AND-

    (2) Liability Insurance. If you get CDW ($17/day) then it is covered.
    Otherwise, you will pay $12/day for TPPD.

    In other words, the true rental cost is about $60++ a day (for a short term).

    *** UPDATE: please read my latest post “I think I figured it out”.
    It has the correct rates and fees.

  • TonyA_says

    I think I got this figured out.

    I went to my GDS and did some car searches for Hertz Israel, TLV airport.

    The BASE daily rate for an economy car (EDMR) is only $14 a day.

    There is NO TAX for a non-Israel resident and passport holder.

    The is an (TLV) airport LOCATION SERVICE CHARGE: PER RENTAL of $28 (one time charge).

    So for one day you will pay $14 + $28 or $42.

    You will pay an additional $14 more per day rental. So 2 days is $56 total.

    Now here is the problem. Unless you buy CDW from Hertz ($17 per day), you will be forced to pay the THIRD PARTY PROPERTY DAMAGE – TPPD fee of $12 per day. In other words, the CDW costs more than the daily rental rate!

    The problem with Expedia’s website for rental cars is that they offer an insurance which covers damage, theft, vandalism, etc. EXCEPT LIABILITY for $11 a day. Unless you are alert (or sophisticated), you will think it will do. But in reality it is quite useless. You are better off spending that $11 and adding $6 to get Hertz’s CDW (for $17 a day).

    So shame on Expedia for selling a pretty useless product (it’s car insurance) when renting a car in Israel.

  • TonyA_says

    I think I got this figured out.

    I went to my GDS and did some car searches for Hertz Israel, TLV airport.

    The BASE daily rate for an economy car (EDMR) is only $14 a day.

    There is NO TAX for a non-Israel resident and passport holder.

    There is an (TLV) airport LOCATION SERVICE CHARGE: PER RENTAL of $28 (one time charge).

    So for one day you will pay $14 + $28 or $42.

    You will pay an additional $14 more per day rental. So 2 days is $56 total.

    Now here is the problem. Unless you buy CDW from Hertz ($17 per day), you will be forced to pay the THIRD PARTY PROPERTY DAMAGE – TPPD fee of $12 per day. In other words, the CDW costs more than the daily rental rate!

    The problem with Expedia’s website for rental cars is that they offer an insurance which covers damage, theft, vandalism, etc. EXCEPT LIABILITY for $11 a day. Also, there is no guarantee Hertz (or other car rental companies) will recognize it. Unless you are alert (or sophisticated), you will think it will do. But in reality it is quite useless. You are better off spending that $11 and adding $6 to get Hertz’s CDW (for $17 a day).

    So shame on Expedia for selling a pretty useless product (it’s car insurance) when renting a car in Israel.

  • bodega3

    Mahalo for fixing it!

  • bodega3

    Mahalo for fixing it!

  • Bill___A

    It is not a bait and switch because it is not both done by the same company. It is just a stupid thing where Expedia does not keep up with where the companies charge mandatory insurance. Why are there always misleading questions on these surveys?
    86% of people vote it is bait and switch. It is wrong, but it is a lack of programming the site completely enough.

  • nkarman

    My employer carries a special rider on their insurance policy to fully cover employees’ rental cars, and specifically instructs us not to purchase insurance when renting cars when traveling on business. “Mandatory insurance” would force us to pay twice!

  • BMG4ME

    If they had done their research they would know that theft protection is mandatory in Israel. I know because it irritated me the first time, but it’s a fact. It’s not bait and switch. It’s there for anyone to see if they go to the web sites of the rental car companies in Israel.

  • Maryann K

    This happened to me in Puerto Rico last year. I booked through a third party site and and the possibility of mandatory insurance was not disclosed at all. I picked up the car at 1AM and tried fighting them on it. It ended up costing me about $100 extra and I decided after the fact that it wasn’t worth my time to fight to get $100 back. When picking battles with travel providers, I always struggle between fighting based on principal or making a decision to drop it because the value of my time doesn’t warrant the amount of time needed to try to recover the amount lost. Mandatory car insurance definitely needs to be disclosed clearly and at the time of the initial reservation!

  • johnmathew

    Many of tourists get into the fake promises of car hire companies. they just mention overview charges and their always hidden charges like insurance charges. I will say always look into complete details and make sure you are viewing the actual prices or rent. http://aussiecarrentals.com.au/hire-prices/mid-size-car-hire/