Guido Akster/Shutterstock

When Dave Mootz checked into the RIU Playacar two years ago, he was greeted by trucks and construction workers where there should have been a quiet beach. The area was undergoing a much-needed beach restoration project — during his much-needed Mexico vacation.

Mootz was unhappy with the view and the incessant noise. So he complained to RIU, and after a lengthy back-and-forth, the hotel agreed to send him a two-night voucher, valid between Aug. 1, 2010 and Aug. 30, 2011. That made him a little more happy, but not by much. He’d asked for a partial refund, arguing that he couldn’t return to Mexico until 2013.

“They said just hold on to the voucher and explain that when making a reservation,” he says.

Unfortunately, he didn’t get RIU’s promise in writing. So you can probably guess what comes next, right? Here’s the response he got from RIU when he tried to make a reservation with his long-expired voucher.

Regretfully we inform you that your voucher is no longer valid. Complimentary stay vouchers are valid for one year only and can be extended only for 6 more months after the regular expiration date.

We deeply apologize for the inconvenience that this may cause you and shall you need further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Mootz wants me to ask RIU to extend the voucher for two reasons. First, because a hotel representative assured him he could use it, and that has to count for something. And second, because he agreed to a lesser compensation — a voucher instead of a refund — and in doing so, believed he was doing the hotel a favor. The least they could do now is return that favor by being a little bit flexible.

“I want to be able to use the voucher and have RIU show me that they actually care if I stay at their properties in the future,” he says.

I’m a little conflicted about this case. RIU wasn’t responsible for the beach restoration; it was a federal project. Had RIU been remodeling its rooms during that time, it would be another issue. It reached a generous compromised with Mootz, giving him a one-year voucher and then extending it for another six months.

Still, Mootz specifically said he couldn’t get back to Mexico until next year, and was told that wouldn’t be a problem. It’s a shame he didn’t get that in writing, because if he did, he’d have a confirmed reservation for his next vacation by now.

I don’t know if I should take up this case.

Should I mediate Dave Mootz's case with RIU?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...