TSA Watch: Oh, so this is what they mean by “zero tolerance”

Here are two more reasons you should never check valuables in your luggage when you’re flying: Michael Pujol and his wife, Betsy Pujol Salazar.

The couple was arrested last week and charged with grand theft. Investigators say Pujol, a TSA agent at Miami International Airport, stuffed items from passengers’ luggage inside a hidden pocket in his work jacket.

The Pujols were caught after a missing iPad was traced to them through a Craigslist transaction. Pujol Salazar admitted that she and her husband had taken items stolen from luggage and sold them online for the last three years.

Back in 2008, when I started reporting about TSA’s little crime epidemic, the agency strongly denounced the actions of its thieving agents, insisting it had “zero tolerance” for their actions.

The thefts “in no way represent the overwhelming majority of hard working officers in airports around the country,” the agency declared on its blog.

Since then, I’ve wondered: What does TSA mean by “zero tolerance”?

I think actions speak louder than words.

Just a few days ago, a screener at LaGuardia Airport was arrested for allegedly swiping a pricey laptop from a college student at a screening area. TSA employee Edwin Rosario, 27, was charged with grand larceny and possession of stolen property for taking a $1,300 computer a passenger had left behind.

A few weeks before, the TSA was accused of taking money out of a Florida couple’s luggage. No arrests have been made yet, and the agency refuses to release security camera footage that could implicate the thief because of “security” concerns. The agency also told the passengers that its screeners “never steal.”

Last month, another TSA worker in Memphis was arrested and charged with theft. Police say Ricky German, 48, tried to swipe a laptop that had been left at his screening station. Surveillance video showed German carrying away the laptop and throwing away papers with the owner’s name on it. After police arrived and said they would view the surveillance video, German then claimed he “found” the laptop.

This fall, a passenger going through security at Phoenix Airport left the screening area $200 lighter. He thinks one of the agents helped himself to his cash when he was checked. Surveillance video didn’t implicate the TSA, but the passenger, Tyson Tibshraeny, is unconvinced. “Where I have a problem is they wanted to separate me from my wallet,” he says.

A few weeks earlier, a TSA agent lost his job and is faced grand theft charges for allegedly pocketing a $450 pen owned by Rick Case, a prominent South Florida car dealership owner. Investigators say Toussain Puddie, 30, admitted to taking Case’s pen after it was left behind during a checkpoint screening at Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport.

“Finders keepers doesn’t apply when you are a public servant and have the public’s trust,” a Sheriff Department spokesman said.

It’s easy to see how agents like Puddie might think otherwise. After all, Congress allows the TSA to keep the pocket change air travelers leave behind — why not their pens or laptop computers?

I could go on. There are dozens more documented cases of TSA agents being arrested and charged with theft in 2011, but you get the idea. (And never mind the items that TSA confiscates from us legally, like cosmetics, liquids and other, so-called “prohibited items.”

Bear in mind that these are just the agents that are caught. Chances are, there are many other TSA workers who are getting away with their thieving ways. Pay attention to the reported convictions, too. Even the agents who are caught are often given a slap on the wrist. It might be reasonable to assume that now more than ever, the TSA is afflicted by a theft epidemic.

Is this what “zero tolerance” looks like?

Look, I get it. Insisting the TSA doesn’t tolerate theft makes for a catchy TV sound bite. But if you really think about it, it’s nonsense.

Saying the TSA now has “zero tolerance” for thefts — which it proclaimed back in 2008 — implies that before then, it had some tolerance for it. (Actually, that’s a whole lot closer to the truth; if TSA’s policy were truly “zero tolerance” then it would summarily dismiss any agent who takes a pencil from a desk or “borrows” a pair of those latex gloves they use for patting us down — that’s zero tolerance.)

I think “zero tolerance” might just be empty rhetoric designed to make us think our federal screeners will be held to a higher standard. They’re words that are meant to soothe us, to convince us to stop worrying about our property being spirited away by a screener.

They are words we should question.

Why do the very people who are supposed to be protecting us also steal from us with such frequency? They do it because they can. They do it because, despite what their mouthpieces tell us on the evening news, they know they’ll probably get away with it.

We hear “zero tolerance.” But the TSA workforce hears “zero accountability.”

(Photo: Caryn K./Flickr)

  • Anonymous

    Actually, since he said he served in the military, I think he understands risks and risk assessment better than you give him credit for.  Not everyone has to rant and rave to get their point across, you know.

  • Anonymous

    I can’t summon sympathy for anyone stupid enough to leave valuables behind at a TSA checkpoint. And, Chris, they are not so-called “prohibited items”; they ARE “prohibited items,” and anyone stupid enough to put them their carry-on deserves to have them confiscated. Once again, you allow your virulent anti-TSA bias to overshadow a worthwhile message: Don’t put valuables in your checked luggage, and don’t leave them behind at Security.

  • Anonymous

    Agree with the pockets comment.  Many years ago I worked for a department store, and we were required to carry a clear plastic “purse” when at work.  That ensured we never stole from either the company OR the clients.

  • Anonymous

    Pathetic!

  • Anonymous

    BS!

  • Anonymous

    Yeah, but that’s true of any “first offender” for non-violent crime.  Rush Limbaugh got busted for a Class 3 felony for drugs, and got ‘drug diversion’ and probation.  So it’s not the TSA — it’s just in general we don’t want to pay $200,000 to incarcerate somebody for five years for stealing a pen.

  • Anonymous

    So true.  Do you think TSA employees steal more, or are more dishonest than employees in general?  Chris isn’t being reasonable – any organization with 30,000 employees is going to have some people who are dishonest.  To assert that they should have ‘zero’ employees who are dishonest is, well, just plain silly.  Can we deal with the real world instead of the fantasy world?

  • http://profiles.google.com/leeannewrites LeeAnne Clark

    Ah, a real live birther.  I thought you guys all crawled back under the rocks from whence you came after you were publicly humiliated and thoroughly debunked with facts.  Y’know, “facts”?  (Oh…right…you’re a birther, you don’t know what those are…)

    ;-)

  • http://profiles.google.com/leeannewrites LeeAnne Clark

    So what do you suggest we DO with our valuables when we need to transport them?  How SHALL I take my jewelry, my family heirlooms, my antiques that I want to bring with me? I’m not allowed to carry on the ones with sharp edges – apparently the government thinks I would try to take down the plane with it.  I can’t put it in my checked luggage, because the government apparently hires thieves, and it’s MY responsibility to not tempt them. 

    What about when I move?  I don’t want to put my valuables on the moving van so they’ll be out on the highways out of my care for days or weeks, I want to take them with me.  But I can’t carry them on (might get swiped out of my bag at the checkpoint while I’m being groped), can’t check them (because it’s apparently my fault if they get stolen because I tempted the government thieves).

    Yeah, lotsa logic there, Paulette.

  • Anonymous

    Can we deal with a real security organization and not TSA?

  • Anonymous

    I don’t see any ranting any raving from Sommer.

    But I do see plenty of posts like yours that seem to apologize for anything and everything TSA does.

  • Anonymous

    Because invading Iraq made America oh so strong under the last Republican we were foolish enough to allow to become President…

  • Anonymous

    I would suggest that it would be possible to have them shipped to your destination via insured/bonded package delivery.

    If you’re really worried about it, there are ways.  Museums, auctioneers, and antique dealers manage to find ways to transport extremely valuable items across the country. I really doubt it’s via normal check-in. I think some items (together) are so valuable that sometime there are chartered flights to transport them, where one doesn’t have to deal with the TSA when it’s general aviation.

    Remember Toy Story 2, where some toy store owner/dealer is trying to transport some super-valuable toys to Japan, but checks them in, telling the airline employee that “This is worth more than you make in a year”?  I don’t know anyone who would be stupid enough to tip off anyone to the value of the contents of luggage.  For that matter, I can’t fathom how anyone would ever think of checking in Louis Vuitton luggage.  It would say, “I’ve probably got something worth stealing” as well as myself being worried that luggage costing that much could be damaged.

  • http://profiles.google.com/leeannewrites LeeAnne Clark

    Or how about this idea:  our government stops hiring criminals and thieves to rifle through our belongings and take whatever they feel like taking?  Oh wait…that’s just too logical…

  • Anonymous

    Is this “zero tolerance”?? No way… If they had they wouldn’t have pockets in their costumes!!!

  • Anonymous

    I’m with you there, Lee Ann! It used to be that you didn’t place any valuables in your checked luggage….it would probably be stolen. You kept them with you in your carry on.

    But now that TSA separates you from your possessions while they are screening (molesting) you, these thieves can help themselves to anything they want, knowing there are absolutely no consequences if they are caught.

    It’s impossible to travel without some valuables…at the very least your wallet with cash, credit cards, and identification.

    I think pauletteb is way out of line to call people stupid who lose things at the checkpoint. People in uniforms are screaming at you, they separate you from your belongings, they put you in an X-ray machine and you’re worried about radiation and wondering who is looking at your naked body, they sexually molest and assault you, they intimidate and terrorize you, you’re worried if you’ll make your flight and wondering what you will do if you don’t make it, the TSA is rifling through your belongings and stealing whatever they want……and in the midst of ALL this, you’re “STUPID” if something gets left behind? Maybe you should rethink that, pauletteb.

  • Anonymous

    Kind of hard not to leave it behind when it’s in the TSO’s pocket.

  • Anonymous

    Sadly, very true.  My sister works for Kroger, and their monthly reports show losses due to breakage/spoilage, vendor theft, customer theft and employee theft.  One guess what the highest cost comes from!

  • Anonymous

    I meant HE didn’t have to rant or rave to get his message across.  And NO, I certinaly do NOT apologize for the TSA, they are the bain of my existance as a travel agent and frequent traveller.  I was just stating that HE has a right to state his, and it seems on THIS site, only those who bash the TSA are acceptable – this gentlman said he has had no problems, and I believe him (and wish him well in the future)

  • Anonymous

    While they did not deserve their costly items to be stolen by crooks with a paycheck, they should have known better in that you keep valuables and medications WITH you.

  • http://profiles.google.com/leeannewrites LeeAnne Clark

    Unfortunately that doesn’t work either, and here’s why:

    1. The airlines now limit your carry-ons to the point where you may not have room for your valuables, especially if you need to carry things for medical needs (e.g. CPAP).

    2. What if your valuables would be deemed “prohibited” by the TSA?  Anything with a sharp edge is in jeopardy of confiscation.  Jewelry in the shape of weapons has been known to be to be swiped.  Heck, a girls’ WALLET with a leather-embossed shape of a gun on it was taken!

    3. Even if your valuables fit in your carry-on and aren’t confiscated for being prohibited, passengers are often separated from their carry-ons while they are being groped, leaving their valuables unprotected from sticky-fingered TSOs.  There are numerous reports of valuables stolen from carry-ons at the checkpoints – watches, wallets, laptops, cash. 

    Bottom line:  there is NO sure way to protect yourself from theft by thieving TSOs. None.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sommer.gentry Sommer Gentry

    The difference is that while the government doesn’t grab your arms and immobilize you to help the street mugger grab your wallet, the government does force you to leave your bag unlocked when you hand it over to these TSA thieves.  The problem is that the process is set up to victimize travelers.  No savvy traveler lets unlocked bags (or bags to which strangers have the keys) out of his sight.

    Let’s leave aside the fact that the TSA’s expert behavior detection officers have failed to locate the thieves, rapists, and child porn enthusiasts among their employees.  But actually, now that you’ve raised the subject, how exactly is the TSA supposed to detect my intent by reading my mind when they can’t even detect that their own employees have been stealing on the job for years on end?

  • Anonymous

    The TSA agents in Row 8 (or Row 1) stole my prescription codeine cough syrup and zip loc travel items at Logan International on 12/30/11 between 6 and 7 am.  And even though I called the voicemail at Logan several times and left messages, no one ever returned my call or returned my items.

  • Anonymous

    I’ve never had any real run-ins with TSA either.

    But that doesn’t mean I’m going to wait until I do before speaking out against TSA.

  • Anonymous

    Theft of controlled substances, of which prescription medication often applies, tends to carry heavier penalties.

    The fact that your attempts to contact have been ignored should mean that those responsible for responding to said voicemails should be held equally responsible.

  • Anonymous

    Please let us know when the Kroger employees are federalized and tasked with protecting commercial aviation.

  • http://twitter.com/DoctorTampa Doctor Tampa

    This is what happens when McDonalds applicants are rejected…the TSA hires them no problemo!

  • http://www.bestcarry-onluggage.net Jeremiah Johnson

     I, as well as several others that I know have had items stolen from our bags during so called TSA security checks. Unfortunately its not surprising when you have that many different people randomly going through our bags that items turn up missing. Its like they have unabated free ride to go through any bag they want to and no way of proving that they stole an item when it turns up missing. Its a shame that the people who are hired to protect us are stealing us blind.