TSA Watch: Did they really sexually assault his mother?

Another day, another TSA screening video.

This one came to us earlier this week from Ryan Miklus, who was flying from Phoenix to Reno with his parents for the Memorial Day weekend. The woman at the start of the clip is his mother, Carol.

Miklus claims she was groped by a TSA agent, and when she asked for a police officer, she was escorted from the screening area and missed her flight. She was screened the next day in Phoenix and traveled without incident.

The TSA has already weighed in on this dust-up with its usual statement.

I spoke with Miklus by phone yesterday to get his side of the story. I was particularly interested in the moments before he began filming.

“They had wanted her to go through the body scanner,” he explains. “She refused. She wanted to have a police officer present during her screening. They pushed through and did the pat-down, anyway.”

During the “enhanced” pat-down, he says his mother was inappropriately touched. Which is when she demanded a police officer.

“That’s when I got my camera out,” he says.

The rest of the video is pretty self-explanatory. There’s the airport worker and Southwest Airlines employee, trying to stop Miklus from filming by citing a law that doesn’t exist. There’s the police officer who in the end refuses to arrest him because he’s violated no law. And there’s plenty of yelling and screaming.

One of the most interesting parts comes at the start when a screener says she’s warned Miklus already. That’s because this isn’t the family’s first run-in with the TSA.

Here’s his encounter with the TSA a few months ago. (Warning: strong language.)

Off-camera in the first video, a TSA employee accuses him of being a paid actor. Miklus denies it.

“I said, “Thanks for trying to dehumanize me,” he says.

But the “paid actor” accusation has gotten some traction online, with many believing both these videos were staged.

I don’t think Miklus and his family are actors, but I’m not entirely unconvinced that they didn’t go to the airport looking for trouble, at least in the first video. They are certainly within their rights to film and to ask questions. We all are.

Interestingly, the TSA now says its photography rules are “under review.” I think that’s a positive development. TSA already films every checkpoint, and I think in the interests of transparency, it should actively encourage every air traveler to record their screening experience on camera.

Hopefully, TSA’s “review” will prompt the agency to remove the provision that they can stop you from filming if you’re interfering with the screening process. I mean, their agents have the necessary training to work around an iPhone that’s powered up — they shouldn’t let that get in the way of a thorough pat-down, right?

As for the latest video, Miklus hopes viewers will remember one thing.

“Envision that as your own mother, your sister, your wife, your daughter,” he says. “How many millions of people don’t say something when they’re touched. Even police officers have to have probable cause when they search you. This shouldn’t be happening in America.”

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    Gulf Activists Harassed By TSA Agents Who Claim Filming Is Illegal
    December 29, 2010 9:40

    http://beforeitsnews.com/story/330/994/Gulf_Activists_Harassed_By_TSA_Agents_Who_Claim_Filming_Is_Illegal.html

  • cjr

    Then never leave your home – which, oddly enough, is the advice that the pro-TSA types give.

    You’re filmed all the time, including at the airport by security cameras.

    And there’s nothing ‘crazyass’ about people wanting to protect their rights.

  • cjr

    Nice logic there, David.

    After all, it’s not like less people flying won’t mean fewer flights by the airlines therefore fewer seats.

    Glad you’ve thought that one through.

  • Vivi

    The son was filming and wasn’t hysterical, his mother was.  The Southwest agent asked *him* if he wanted to fly that day, that was bullying. 

  • cjr

    “and then hijacking the plane.”

    As we’ve had to repeat time and again: there will be no hijackings because there are secured cockpit doors.

    Please find another boogieman.

  • cjr

    I have a better idea: we can put Mike in a padded cell to make sure the rest of us are safe.

  • cjr

    Don’t like people filming you at the airport, don’t fly, right?

  • Anonymous

    Dear Julie,  I am so sorry to hear of your Experience.  I would NEVER allow anyone to touch me  in in a “sexual” way, but the TSA is another story.  I have been through so much of their “security searches” and have been “pulled over” every time I fly.  I do not make a fuss or I am liable to be denied boarding.  If anyone would touch me in a normal situation (except for these TSA people), they’d find themself with a 
    jab in the face or some other retort.  I know “self defense.”  And, I could inflict a great deal of pain.  I am presently in Paris and went to 
    Switzerland for a day.  On the way back I was approached (on the train) by 2 guards.  They asked for my passport and if I was carrying a great deal of EUROS.  No.  Then a female security guard came by and did a full body search on me (I was clothed).  I was the ONLY person on the train to be searched.  I carry an American passport.  I was “scared to death.”  But, made no comment.  I was not guilty of money-carrying.
    My most invasive search by TSA was when a woman guard began squeezing my breasts.  (I wear prostheses because of cancer) and had she not stopped I was ready to pull them out of my bra and hand them to her so she could squeeze them.  Another time I was told to pull down my shirt.  It exposed about an inch of my flat stomach (after going through a machine that blew my t-shirt up a bit.)  I’ve been through it all, and when I say “get over it” I mean sometimes you have to put up with this when you FLY.  The woman in the video seemed quite “staged” with her son having a camera ready.  When I wrote to Elliott — the travel guy  – he said he was not taking this any further and I agreed.  I am really sorry my “flip” manner upset you and I apologize, but I was just talking about me and my dozens of flying experiences that I just have to “get over” when I am going on planes.  Hope this explains a bit.
    I apparently upset TSA because I wear 2 watches, my dress looks like a “trench coat” and I am told to remove my COAT.  My husband goes on through ahead of me because he said I give off “vibes” that make me the one to put through the wringer.  

  • Anonymous

    Dear Lisa,  I wrote a very long response to “Julie” below and hope you will read it.  Sorry it was so long, but I am commenting on MY experiences with TSA because I travel so much.  I’ve recently been searched on a train from Switzerland to Paris and it was invasive, but I was not taking a chance in getting arrested if I did not comply.  Only person on train to be searched because I carry an American passport and they thought I was carrying a lot of Euros.  My name really is Naoma and I hope you will read my comments below.

  • Anonymous

    Dear Lisa and Julie,  I travel an awful lot (much of it alone) and have been mugged 3 times.  Once I needed surgery on my ear, and the other two were just scary and robberies.  In one case the man was captured by 25 men who ran out of a bar and knocked him to the ground.  While he was down I went over and kicked him, etc.  I made sure he was prosecuted and spent 2 years and then a 3rd in jail.  I have a “world class scream” which I urge all women to acquire.  I was 9 blocks away when the World Towers came down and am angered that we have to go through the security thing, but that is the law.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sommer.gentry Sommer Gentry

    Umm, wouldn’t it be nice if the TSA would stop evading our questions about what screening is in place at this time?  You expect people to give these perverts a blanket “yes, I accept” when they won’t even tell us what exactly they are going to do! 

    Can the TSA strip search you?  Can the TSA make you remove implanted medical devices?  Can the TSA remove bandages and press their unsterile hands into fresh surgical wounds?  Can male TSA agents select female passengers based on breast size and take them into the stairwell for bare-breast “searches”?  All of these atrocities and more have been reported by the victims, but TSA won’t promise that it won’t happen again. 

    There can be no consent without knowledge of what we are consenting to.

  • MikeZ

    Naoma, you keep talking about your train ride search. lets not forget that in a different country, you abide by THEIR laws, not ours here. Our laws are supposed to protect us from this type of invasive activity. Those laws are call the Bill of Rights and Amendments to the Constitution.

    I would personally risk terrorist activity rather than continue to give up my freedoms. people came to this conuntry and rebelled against the British because of government. The founding fathers placed strict limits on what the government was allowed to do. Only now we are letting them abuse that power more and more each day and some people actually think it is a great idea. I’m sorry, but countless Americans have died over the centuries to ensure the very freedoms that you now say go ahead and take away, just to “feel” a bit safer. millions of Americans die each year because of lung cancer, car accidents, etc, and we worry so much because a terrorist MIGHT try something on a few hundred people. the govt has you brainwashed into a false sense of security.

  • Anonymous

    Dear MikeZ.  You are absolutely right about our country.  My ride was on a SPEED TRAIN.  My husband is a British subject and has dual 
    citizenship.  He shows his British passport and no problem.  With an American passport I was confronted with 2 guards (the woman who did the search came a bit later)  I was not about to be held in Switzerland. I consented to the search — little choice.  My stories of American TSA searches could fill a book and I have spoken about them.  I am not young, very petite, white blonde hair, 5’2″ and 115 pounds.  Do not look at all threatening and travel the world.  For some reason I am “suspect.” I was 9 blocks away on 9/11 and realize there are people out to hurt us.  I do think TSA goes TOO far and does not search some people who look “suspicious.”  But me,  I get it all.

  • flutiefan

    i’m referring to the Southwest Airlines agent you mentioned in your comment.  that is NOT a “public servant”.

  • flutiefan

    yes, because that’s exactly what i said.

    smh.

  • flutiefan

    boats.

  • flutiefan

    i’m still waiting on that.

  • flutiefan

    the Supreme Court did NOT write the Constitution, nor are those laws IN the Constitution.

  • flutiefan

    YAY!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dawn-Robinson-Shepard/614303610 Dawn Robinson Shepard

    There is no such thing as a constitutional right to travel. I would rather be searched or go through the xray machine than have a terrorist get on board a plane and blow us all up. Really people. Get over yourselves. No one is taking your rights away. If you don’t like being touched go through the scanner. The amount of microwave is less than what comes off of a TV and I’m sure you all spend time in front of that and dont’ think about it. I don’t agree with the TSA 100% but wouldn’t want the job of having to touch all of the gross people that come through.

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    You’re mistaken.  I’ve answered these false assertions with evidence over and over and over and over and over again.  Umpteen times.  Not going to repeat it all again.  Read the thread.

  • Sbeetle

    Uh, considering that the airlines have no say in what the TSA or DOT does, your logic is ineffective. 

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    Bullsh*t.  It’s called an economic boycott.  Money talks in this country. More than politics, more than violence, more than anything.  Money is this country’s god.  If enough people were willing to put their money where their mouths are, things would change.  The airlines wouldn’t stand for being killed through an economic boycott.

  • Sbeetle

    You don’t have a constitutional right to travel. You can purchase a ticket on the free market system of a commercial airline. An airline can refuse service to anyone and kick your butt off the plane if you don’t comply with the rules. 

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    Another person who hasn’t read the thread.  You’re wrong — we do have a Constitutional right to travel.

  • middle-aged-diva

    I wonder if we’ll ever get to the point where we can agree to disagree without all this name-calling and hysteria. It’s possible for reasonable people to disagree.

  • Stronghill

    I have read most of this thread. I can not recall any positive suggestion on how to satisfy all of the travelers all of the time. And provide a credible deterrent.

    When age 60, departing New Zealand, my backpack, as well of that of my 25-year-old daughter, were scanned and probed three times. We too were patted down at least twice. Yet I would return there in a trice.

  • Carver

    flutiefan

    At what would you do if someone disregards your order not to videotape you.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=703291673 Anonymous

    Um, did he really pronounce it as “Jest-appo?” All respect gone for the cameraman at that point. :)

  • Diana

    Can I take a train, car, or bus to Hawaii (and the days of the Lurline – even if affordable – are long gone)?  No, but I wish I could, as I dread going by plane now, especially after my invasive search recently returning from Hawaii.  I am age 73 and in a wheelchair, and for some reason the TSA always picks on me.  Traveling to Hawaii every year is my reason for living.  It’s the only place where I feel rejuvenated and able to do more physically, but I can’t afford to live there.  I am not going to stop going there because of the TSA.  I’m not going to let them beat me down;  so I have to put up with the humiliation and trauma of being intimately touched with an invasive body search.  Is this right?

  • Diana

    Can you name a ship that carries passengers and that travels on a schedule?  The days of ocean steamers that crossed the oceans are long gone.  This isn’t the early decades of the 20th century.  The only ship you can take now is a cruiseship, which probably won’t take you where you want to go and is prohibitively expensive.

  • Diana

    What if they don’t give you the choice?  They tell you to go behind a privacy screen, and then they tell you they’re going to grope you.  At least in my case, I think that if I protest, I’m going to be denied boarding.  I would much rather go through the scanner than be touched in intimate places.

  • vbrink

    I believe you are talking about “consent” in the legal sense.  I’m not sure it applies here because you may “give” or “waive” consent, in the strict legal sense, by purchasing a ticket.  Again, I don’t know, but my sneaking suspicion is that you are waive consent, per federal law.

    Kind of like if you choose to drive on a public highway, you give up to the right ‘not’ to be stopped at a sobriety check point.  The different being driving/flying is a privilege, not a Right. 

    I really don’t have any comment on your list of incidents, but it does seem to me that if ‘you’ choose to fly when you know about the incidents, then you choose to fly when you know they could happen to you. 

  • DAVE CLARK

    Ask how many terrorists TSA has ever caught in their airport screenings, and compare that to how many TSA employees have been arrested/prosecuted for stealing luggage (or its contents) and other criminal acts? 

  • http://dxingworld.info kristin

    TSA is neither “public servant” nor police officers. I beg of you not to confuse these entities with transportation security. Also I ask all of us to act civilly please in these trying times, especially toward those working the airports no matter what their titles are non authority or strangers. I read that the TSA is ordered to do these things. But, on other hand let us embrace our rights as citizens yet please give each other no harm or at least try not to.

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    Ban the Scan, Friday, June 10, 4:30, Union Square, NYC

    As NYC residents who lived through the attacks on 9/11, we are tired of politicians exploiting it for government power grabs and excess.  And we are not alone.  

    Join New York City residents as they speak out against the TSA’s extremism and support the nullification movement afoot in Texas and Utah to criminalize the TSA’s pat-downs and invasive security measures.  (They violate the Fourth Amendment and have an ineffectiveness rate of 70%!)  

    A coalition of Republicans, Democrats, and independents have united to support legislation banning whole image body scanners and invasive pat-downs throughout NYC.

    While there is no need to check the underpants of our grandmothers, mothers, or children there is a need for sound, common-sense security at public portals.  The TSA has failed in this regard and if Senator Schumer has his way, whole image body scanners will make their way into our railways and subways. 

    This event is nonpartisan.

    Friday, June 10, 4:30pm, Union Square Park, NYC
    http://www.meetup.com/ronpaul2012ny/events/18018501/

  • Munchnib

    Some people go out of there way to get attention.  1 problem with TSA is possible, not likely but possible. 2 means you are looking to make a scene.

    TSA probably over rreacted  when confronted with someone who was delilberately trying to provoke.  They need more training in handling disruptive peolple.

    I have been through all kinds of airport pat downs and all types of screening machines.  i have yet to have a problem with it.  Do
    ii think there are better processes avaialble to move people through the screening efficiently?  yes, but this is what we have at the moment so people need to deal with it in a positive way.  Life is too short to make this the reson for your unhappiness. 

    As far as how my mother would react to being “groped”  She would laugh about it or give them 10 minutes to stop.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sommer.gentry Sommer Gentry

    I’m attending this, and all I can do is hope that someone with the power to stop that child molester Pistole and his pornographic picture-loving compatriot Napolitano from their campaign of sexual humiliation will hear our demands.  We want our decency and our rights back. 

    Security theater that wastes money on pointless water-finding missions is one thing.  It might be tolerable for its psychological reassurance value to stupid people.  But sexcurity theater that forces innocent people into unwanted sexual contact with strangers and exposes their naked bodies is another thing altogether, and no one should ever tolerate these sex crimes.  This is an attack on our humanity.  No terrorist ever looked down my pants or laid hands on my labia, but the TSA has done these things to millions of people.  I won’t be victimized by the TSA, which is why I and many of my acquaintance won’t fly.  I quit flying at enormous personal and professional cost, but there is a line between right and wrong, and TSA has crossed it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sommer.gentry Sommer Gentry

    Yeah, life is too short to bother trying to keep strangers from taking naked pictures of your teenage daughter.  I see your point.  Life is too short to worry about who’s putting their hands on your child’s sex organs.  I mean, it’s not worth missing what’s on TV tonight to try to prevent millions of ritualized sexual assaults, right? You know, when a stranger on the street put his hands up my skirt and grabbed me between the legs, I did file a police report but now I see how I should have tried to deal with it in a positive way, and how I should have just laughed about it. Thanks.

  • Geographer

    Yes, unfortunately true that you got searched because you were an American (assuming that is what is meant by “carry an American passport”.   American passport holders are subject to all kinds of questioning when entering or leaving the “Schengen zone” area of the European community.   Oddly this is partly because the US Govt. insists on all airlines and possibly other transportation services, get full details of US Passport holders border crossings (sometimes it may also be in reprisal for the kind of hard nosed treatment even harassment which non-US passport holders get when entering the US – long lines, endless questions, finger prints and photos … as a US passport holder you have no idea just how discouraging, even offensive, this kind of surly treatment is in spite of all the superficial welcoming language that the US customs forms and instructions contain.

    Two weeks ago, my son, traveling on a US passport was questioned at length on arriving at the East Midlands airport in Nottingham, England, on a flight from Bergerac, France.   I was traveling on a British passport, and was astonished at the length of questioning … maybe the US could ease up on its treatment of incoming travelers, and the kind of thing which happened to you between Switzerland and Paris would also ease up?

  • Geographer

    Yes, unfortunately true that you got searched because you were an American (assuming that is what is meant by “carry an American passport”.   American passport holders are subject to all kinds of questioning when entering or leaving the “Schengen zone” area of the European community.   Oddly this is partly because the US Govt. insists on all airlines and possibly other transportation services, get full details of US Passport holders border crossings (sometimes it may also be in reprisal for the kind of hard nosed treatment even harassment which non-US passport holders get when entering the US – long lines, endless questions, finger prints and photos … as a US passport holder you have no idea just how discouraging, even offensive, this kind of surly treatment is in spite of all the superficial welcoming language that the US customs forms and instructions contain.

    Two weeks ago, my son, traveling on a US passport was questioned at length on arriving at the East Midlands airport in Nottingham, England, on a flight from Bergerac, France.   I was traveling on a British passport, and was astonished at the length of questioning … maybe the US could ease up on its treatment of incoming travelers, and the kind of thing which happened to you between Switzerland and Paris would also ease up?

  • Geographer

    See my post above (posted as Geographer).   Yes, I am a British citizen with a UK passport (the term “British Subject” went away some 30 years ago).  And I repeat, as I stated above, that having an American passport may get you in and out of the US much more easily (though not necessarily in a more friendly manner), but elsewhere, either because the US government insists on it, or because it is a kind of reprisal for the unwelcoming treatment incoming non-citizens get when entering the US.   This was certainly true for Brazil some years ago, requiring visas for US visitors to Brazil and charging an amount equal to the kind of fees that the US asks for visitor visas.

    I assume your husband’s other citizenship is American, so he gets the best of both worlds crossing borders into and out of the US and Europe.   Perhaps he could get you British citizenship – that would ease your problems

  • Geographer

    See my post above (posted as Geographer).   Yes, I am a British citizen with a UK passport (the term “British Subject” went away some 30 years ago).  And I repeat, as I stated above, that having an American passport may get you in and out of the US much more easily (though not necessarily in a more friendly manner), but elsewhere, either because the US government insists on it, or because it is a kind of reprisal for the unwelcoming treatment incoming non-citizens get when entering the US.   This was certainly true for Brazil some years ago, requiring visas for US visitors to Brazil and charging an amount equal to the kind of fees that the US asks for visitor visas.

    I assume your husband’s other citizenship is American, so he gets the best of both worlds crossing borders into and out of the US and Europe.   Perhaps he could get you British citizenship – that would ease your problems

  • Anonymous

    Hello,  Geographer:  Sometime my mind resides in the “dark ages.”  Yes,
    my husband has a British passport as well as an American one.  Our daughter also has a British one (dual citizenship).  I could not get one.
    Yes, I remember when I went to Brazil (a number of years ago) and getting a VISA for the first time.My husband became a US citizen many years ago.  He had to study, pass a test and be sworn in by one of the attorneys from the firm where I worked. All legal and official.   Thank you for your comments.  He still has his accent and a great voice. We were at a lecture last night and he asked a question.  There were people in the back row  who came up to us and said:  ”that could only be Roger with his accent and voice.”  I told him he should do “voice over” for commercials, but is too busy right now.

  • Anonymous

    Hello,  Geographer:  Sometime my mind resides in the “dark ages.”  Yes,
    my husband has a British passport as well as an American one.  Our daughter also has a British one (dual citizenship).  I could not get one.
    Yes, I remember when I went to Brazil (a number of years ago) and getting a VISA for the first time.My husband became a US citizen many years ago.  He had to study, pass a test and be sworn in by one of the attorneys from the firm where I worked. All legal and official.   Thank you for your comments.  He still has his accent and a great voice. We were at a lecture last night and he asked a question.  There were people in the back row  who came up to us and said:  ”that could only be Roger with his accent and voice.”  I told him he should do “voice over” for commercials, but is too busy right now.

  • Pauletteb

    The BS is all yours. How is anything TSA does the fault of any airlines, and how would boycotting the airlines have any effect on TSA’s behavior? Despite your post and others by the virulent anti-TSA crowd, most of us experience no problems with TSA. This entire incident was so obviously staged, it makes me want to scream. As David noted, we sane people will benefit from the few seats that might be vacant due to your “economic boycott.”

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    If you don’t understand that moneyed interests run everything in this country, then you don’t understand how economics works.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sommer.gentry Sommer Gentry

    Mistreatment of international travelers cost American businesses $500 billion over the “lost decade” from 2000-2010.  While international travel grew 31% around the world, visits to the U.S. declined 9.3%.  See: https://network.ustravel.org/eWeb/video/lostdecadereport.pdf for the cost estimates of people boycotting the U.S. to avoid the incredibly negative experiences with visas, customs, and TSA.   See: http://nestmann.sovereignsociety.com/2011/06/08/welcome-back-to-the-u-s-a/ for just one person’s explanation of why TSA makes him less likely to fly here. 

    Besides, boycotting is more than just a pressure tactic to make the TSA sexual assaults stop.  It’s a way to keep my body secure from being ogled and fondled against my will.  If buying an airline ticket is just asking for a sexual assault (and that’s what the comment “flying is a choice” means), then I won’t do it and and I don’t understand anyone who would.

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    Via Forbes (yeah, there’s a real radical magazine!), on a story that’s been amply reported but that so many on this site still ignore:

    . . . a TSA spokesperson said that no agent has been fired or even disciplined as a result of the incident. “We regret that the passenger had an unpleasant experience,” the spokesperson said, using the passive voice, as spokespeople do, to make it sound as if the unpleasant experience just happened.
    . . . If I recall correctly, al Qaeda has measured its success partly by its ability to harm the U.S. economy through increased security costs, travel restrictions, and so forth. Seems a little ironic that the agency that’s supposed to protect us from them has threatened to use a similar strategy.

    http://blogs.forbes.com/kevinunderhill/2011/06/08/tsa-settles-with-woman-whose-top-was-pulled-down/

  • http://www.cogitamusblog.com/2010/11/five-words.html Lisa Simeone

    Via Forbes (yeah, there’s a real radical magazine!), on a story that’s been amply reported but that so many on this site still ignore:

    . . . a TSA spokesperson said that no agent has been fired or even disciplined as a result of the incident. “We regret that the passenger had an unpleasant experience,” the spokesperson said, using the passive voice, as spokespeople do, to make it sound as if the unpleasant experience just happened.
    . . . If I recall correctly, al Qaeda has measured its success partly by its ability to harm the U.S. economy through increased security costs, travel restrictions, and so forth. Seems a little ironic that the agency that’s supposed to protect us from them has threatened to use a similar strategy.

    http://blogs.forbes.com/kevinunderhill/2011/06/08/tsa-settles-with-woman-whose-top-was-pulled-down/