TSA watch: A crazy agency finally gets an official diagnosis

You probably already suspected that the idea of a Department of Homeland Security in general, and the Transportation Security Administration, specifically, was a little crazy.

Last week, all doubts were removed.

I mean, nothing says “nuts” like the plans for Janet Napolitano’s new office, which will be in the very same room used by the director of the nation’s first major federally run psychiatric institution. I’m not making this up.

DHS Secretary Napolitano and the rest of the Homeland Security team, including parts of the TSA, will soon move to a renovated castle-like structure opened in 1855 as the Government Hospital for the Insane.

Ironic? Perhaps.

Even crazier, to some, is the idea that we’d be better off without the TSA. Only fringe politicians and pundits have seriously suggested that the country should disband the agency.

But this week, one of the most popular petitions on the White House’s new “We The People” section is advocating just that. It wants to dismantle the TSA.

Nearly 20,000 Americans have signed it so far.

The petition says it’s time for the president to act.

The Transportation Security Administration has been one of the largest, most expensive and most visible blunders of the post-9-11 homeland security reformation.

It has violated countless constitutional rights of average Americans, caused miserable and expensive delays in an already-overburdened air travel system, and allowed multiple known instances of harassment, theft, extortion and sexual abuse by its employees.

The poll urges the president to invest in “saner, more effective” security measures.

The fact that such a petition could be hosted by the White House site says a lot about the nation’s attitude toward the TSA. Who would have ever thought it would come to this?

It’s important to see this in context. The TSA hasn’t exactly endeared itself to the traveling public in recent days.

Big hair alert! We know TSA has a thing for hair, but chasing down a passenger after screening to check her coif is unusual, even by TSA standards. But that’s exactly what happened to a passenger in Atlanta. (Memo to TSA: That’s what the screening areas are for. You don’t want to be the agent running through the terminal, shouting, “The lady with the big hair, stop!”)

Working for the TSA can be murder. News that a TSA agent was caught stealing is so routine, it surprises almost no one. Ditto for drug trafficking or other serious but nonviolent crimes. But murder? A top TSA official in Mississippi is in jail in Gulfport charged the killing of colleague, according to reports. Needless to say, this is not good for the agency’s image.

And speaking of thieves …
Who says crime doesn’t pay? A former lead transportation security officer at Newark Liberty International Airport who faced up to 10 years in prison for stealing up to $30,000 from travelers as they passed through security-screening checkpoints, received three years probation and six months of home confinement for his crimes. A federal judge said Al Raimi had been cooperative in the government investigation, which led to several other arrests. In a related story, some TSA agents who failed to check bags in Honolulu were only suspended or allowed to retire after their negligence was uncovered.

So maybe America can be forgiven for wanting to get rid of the TSA. It hasn’t caught a single terrorist, its agents haven’t been on their best behavior and their crimes often go unpunished.

But will the government finally listen to the voice of its own people? And if it does, what should it do?

(Photo of St. Elizabeths Hospital in Washington by Amber Wiley/Flickr)

  • http://profiles.google.com/leeannewrites LeeAnne Clark

    Humanity proven once again. I sincerely hope that in your lawyerly practice, you do not interact with crime victims. That would be an atrocity.

    Please leave me alone. That is a request. Can you be human? Just in this one instance? Or will you have to proverbially jam your thumb in my vagina one more time, just like the TSA?

    I will not be returning to this thread, so jam away, if it makes you feel good.

  • Daisymae

    Leanne,

    Stop wasting your breath with this fool.  He’s deliberately baiting you.  Don’t dignify him with a response.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sommer.gentry Sommer Gentry

    It’s interesting that you mention the damage that TSA has done to people’s trust in the government.  I must be the poster child for that.  In the last year, I’ve re-examined all of my political opinions and reversed most of them, and it’s entirely because of what the TSA is doing to people.  I used to trust government, but now all I can do is fear a government that would inflict what I consider ritualistic sexual abuse on its citizens.  Thank you for an interesting exchange.

  • Daisymae

    Re: ACLU testimonials

    One woman on the ACLU site said that the agent put her thumb into her vagina…..just like LeeAnne stated in her previous posts.  That’s two separate people unknown to each other who said the same thing happened.  Don’t they call that a corroborating witness, Carver?

    “The pat down was so invasive that the woman doing it stuck her thumb through my jeans into my vagina, significantly more than simple resistance. She cupped each of my breasts, and ran her hand inside the waistband of my jeans…. ”

    I can only imagine how much force was used to get the thumb into the vagina through a pair of jeans.  Must have been excruciating.

  • cjr

    Then perhaps you should take a different tact in your posts. To quote from you just a little further up:
    “My question is do you have a factual basis for this belief?”

    You are outright questioning whether somebody has the right to believe whether TSA abuses occur because they have not experienced them personally.

    How else should somebody interpret your comments then? You haven’t experienced such abuses, nor witnessed them, and you doubt the experiences of others because of that. Thus, you all but accuse others of making their stories up since you didn’t witness them.

    According to you, since I have not experienced abuse at the hands of TSA, apparently I have no reason to despise TSA for what they do to others. Sorry, but that ‘logic’ doesn’t fly in my book. Nor does it fly in the court of public opinion, where TSA has long been found guilty of being incompetent, wasteful, violating our rights, and doing more harm to this country than good.

  • Desertstarone

    You’re right, I should have included the complete thought for those who aren’t familiar with common aphorisms, so here goes: IF THE SHOE FITS, WEAR IT.   

  • Desertstarone

    Hmmm. you must not be familiar with recent statistics indicating the much improved border security as a result of both Bush and Obama’s beefing up the Patrol.  As for Janet, she had an over 70% approval rating when governor of Az. and was one of the best governors the state ever  had although we may never know how she would have compared to two others who went to prison before their terms were up.  Of course you know there are those that find fault with any Democrat even if they told people to vote Republican.

  • Brooklyn

    You used to trust the government? I haven’t felt that way since the beginning of the Vietnam war (and before that I was too young to follow the news)!

  • Brooklyn

    You used to trust the government? I haven’t felt that way since the beginning of the Vietnam war (and before that I was too young to follow the news)!

  • Brooklyn

    You used to trust the government? I haven’t felt that way since the beginning of the Vietnam war (and before that I was too young to follow the news)!

  • Brooklyn

    You used to trust the government? I haven’t felt that way since the beginning of the Vietnam war (and before that I was too young to follow the news)!

  • Brooklyn

    Oh, now I get it! You’re white,  a racist, a lawyer and a born again Christian (or why would you be telling a prospective employer about your religious beliefs?) I would have thought your little cousin’s death might have engendered some compassion for real victims (which you are not), but I guess the impervious carapace of your racial attitudes, religion and profession make that impossible. I do wish you’d and leave LeeAnne alone; maybe you should restrict your social interaction to your co-religionists and members of your political party, which we can now guess.

  • Brooklyn

    Well, there was Prohibition, but that wasn’t ineptness.

  • Brooklyn

    Did I say I hadn’t signed it? But if they want an accurate poll, they should make it anonymous.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sommer.gentry Sommer Gentry

    I wasn’t born until after that war.  In my public schools our history classes always “ran out of time” to cover events more recent than WWII.

  • Lisa Simeone

    I’ve only posted it about a dozen times already, so what’s one more:

    Master Lists of TSA Crimes and Abuses:

    http://www.travelunderground.org/index.php?pages/tsa-abuse-master-lists/#LisaSimeone

  • Lisa Simeone