Triple-booked on Travelocity with no refund in sight

Erich Bley bought two tickets from Miami to Aruba on Travelocity. Instead, he got six.

Double-bookings — at least the inadvertent kind — are rare. But triple-bookings? This is the first on I’ve come across.

Turns out it’s three times as difficult to resolve, too.

First, let’s hear from Bley, who describes how it all happened.

After filling out the requested information on the computer screen, I got a reference number that said a written confirmation will follow. A few days later, having not received the promised confirmation, I went back to Travelocity to check the status of my tickets.

There, in bold red letters, it said: “This flight is not available.”

Then Bley received his credit card bill.

We were charged for six tickets!

I called Travelocity immediately and somebody from India told me that we should get a refund from American Airlines for four of the tickets.

I called American Airlines, but they told me it is Travelocity’s fault and I should contact them.

This has been going on for a number of times back and forth between American and Travelocity, and I agreed to pay a $75 per ticket cancellation charge.

Guess what? Now American is not crediting their balance.

I talked to my travel agent about the situation and she suggested to write to you — that you are the only one who could help.

Well, I don’t know about that, but I can certainly try to help.

I contacted Travelocity. Here’s what it had to say:

Chris, the duplicate booking was a technical error we take responsibility for. Normally, we have systems in place that automatically detect this, but it did not work in this case.

We have contacted AA and they have agreed to refund $346 per ticket for a total of $1086. We will refund the $75 cancellation fee for each ticket.

The customer should see this reflected on his credit card statements (he used two different cards) in the next two billing cycles.

Let us know if you need anything else and thanks, as always, for bringing this to our attention.

Case closed? Not exactly.

The money didn’t show up on Bley’s next statement. Or his next one. Five months went by, and still no refund.

I nudged Travelocity, but it seemed to feel this case was closed, too.

Yesterday — almost a year after the triple-booking and many months after getting a promise of a quick refund — the credit showed up.

Bley explains:

When you called me about six months ago and told me the refund from Travelocity would be happening, we were delighted. Thanks for opening the door.

When nothing happened until December my wife started calling. We heard all the excuses possible:

“We do not pay after six months”

“It is American Airlines’ responsibility, call them.”

“We can’t find your records.”

My wife recently called Travelocity. When a representative promised my refund would be processed, we were skeptical. But today we received our refund. Mr Elliott, thank you so much for guiding us into the right direction.

I’m glad Travelocity and American finally resolved this. But why did it have to take so long?

(Photo: atomicshark/Flickr Creative Commons)

  • Josh

    Honestly I never understand why these things get so far. It is pretty clear that he did not purchase six tickets. The screw-up was obviously with Travelocity. The first thing I would have done after not getting an immediate refund from Travelocity would be to contest the charge with my credit card provider. If that had failed I would have contacted the FTC and the DOT. Nothing seems to make a company jump quite like a referral to government agencies that they are involved with. If nothing had come from that I would have sued Travelocity in small claims court (assuming it was appropriate in my local venue). But agreeing to pay any sort of “cancellation” fee and having to wait twelve months while just calling them, forget it.

  • Liz

    Thanks you Chris I never accept the “pass the buck” game that the major online travel agencies like to do. I firmly (but politely) tell them that they are acting as my travel agent and I expect them to fix the issue. It’s worked fairly well so far!

  • chris

    I don’t understand why he didn’t get his credit card company involved. this is an obvious screwup on travelocitys part and I would have disputed the charges the moment they appeared on a statement. usually doing so gets their attention real fast.

  • Arizona Road Warrior

    This is why travelers should deal directly with the airline’s website or use the services of a traditional brick & mortar travel agent.

  • Robert Davis

    Again,
    Why do people bother with these third party sites? Are they that much less expensive? It just adds to the headaches.

  • Ames

    What’s with the math? How do six tickets at $346 each equal $1086? Four tickets, assuming he still really wanted to go and used two, do not add up either!

    “agreed to refund $346 per ticket for a total of $1086. We will refund the $75 cancellation fee for each ticket”

  • Dave

    I would NEVER use Travelocity or its ilk. I’ve been reading the travel blogs far too long, have seen way too much of this ping-pong treatment: Airline: “It’s Travelocity’s fault.” Travelocity: “It’s the airline’s fault.” Besides, Travelocity isn’t usually any cheaper.

  • Mike

    The airlines and travel agencies make big dollars on the float. These delays are just their way to steal our money.

    Congress should address this and other travel abuses. Fat chance.

    Maybe a class action unjust enrichment suit is in order.

  • http://www.angrymarks.com/ Kevin Fields

    @chris Indeed! After six months I would have drawn in the credit card company as well, and also be talking with the legal department. This wasn’t just an error, this is flat out highway robbery! How much in interest payments did Mr. Bley end up paying? Travelocity should also have to pay every bit of that interest over THE LAST YEAR. Outrageous. Then again, maybe Mr. Bleys is at peace with all of this now, and that’s the end of the story.

  • sweepergrl

    I can’t imagine how this is legal. Surely this is some sort of fraud, isn’t it? Especially when he was told to pay $75 for each ticket that he didn’t voluntarily purchase.

    On a side note, how fortunate that Erich had the ability to eat the cost of the 4 extra tickets for a year. Even if he got a dirt cheap fair, that’s still a LOT of money to be out. Can you imagine all the ‘over the limit’ charges he would have to pay if he didn’t have the available credit or if he unknowingly charged something (like his hotel room or rental car) before he caught such a huge mistake. Yikes. It certainly guarantees that I won’t be using Travelocity.

  • Jesse

    There really is no reason to book with a third party site anymore. Rarely do they have better deals than the airline’s site itself – and it can be a major pain in situations like this.

    The only time I use Orbitz is for multi-airline itineraries that are difficult to retrieve otherwise.

  • http://www.claws-and-paws.com/ Douglas Muth

    I’m not sure how Travelocity feels that it can shirk its responsibility by telling the customer to “call American Airlines”. The customer didn’t give the money to American, he gave the money to Travelocity. American Airlines would have no obligation to refund money to someone who technically isn’t a customer.

    Really, Travelocity. You need to train your CSRs better–stop focusing on short term gains (call times) at the expense of long-term issues (your reputation). This sort of short-sighted thinking is why the travel industry gets a bad rap.

  • Sarah Di

    There’s no way I would agree to pay 75 dollars per ticket for a cancellation fee on a ticket that I did not purchase or intend to use. I can’t believe that any travel company would find that to be a sound policy.

  • Chicky

    In general, the only time I use a third-party site is to compare fares among different airlines. I have used hotels.com without incident before, but my itinerary wasn’t complicated. I’ll also use an opaque site to rent a car once in a while, since I really don’t care which company I rent from. Otherwise, I deal directly with the airline/hotel/car rental web site. It’s just easier.
    I’m such a wimp, I’d have probably come screaming to Chris as soon as I saw the triple booking on my credit card. LOL.
    Other than disputing the charges right away, I don’t know that Mr. Bley could have done anything different. This whole buck-passing, tap-dancing, razzle-dazzle is designed to make the traveler tired of dealing with the situation so whoever got the money originally can keep it. It stinks.

  • Thalassa

    Wow, this is a great example of the need for a guy like you, Chris! Good job slicing through that Gordian knot!

  • Kelly

    I still don’t understand why this took so long to process. Why did it take do long?

  • Jerry mandel

    I cannot underestand why anyone would purchase through Travelocity, Qixo, Expedia, etc. They have no better air fares than the airlines and I do bargain with cruise lines to get greatly reduced fares.

  • Josh

    (this is another Josh :-)

    Agree with many here — unless there’s any inkling that I made a mistake (and just hitting submit twice isn’t enough — they can clearly tell that the names are the same and detect the duplicate), I give them *one* chance to process a refund immediately (Home Depot can process a return instantly, as can any merchant), then I start the credit card dispute. The chargeback will go to Travelocity; let them and American fight it out on their own time.

  • LeeAnne

    I have to agree that this should have gone to a credit card dispute. This was a clearcut case of a duplicate charge. This is exactly the type of case that credit card disputes are made for – there is no gray area, no wiggle room for the merchant to claim they are entitled to the money.

    While I can understand why, after so much effort to get it resolved, the OP agreed to pay the $75 change fee, that was a wrong decision. That just serves to perpetuate the problem, and motivates companies like Travelocity to NOT resolve their invalid charges quickly. Heck not only did they get to keep a substantial chunk of money that didn’t belong to them for a very long time, but they were going to make a profit of $300 for THEIR screw-up! And this customer was letting them! Good thing Christopher stepped in and cleaned that up.

    If customers will simply quickly dispute clearcut mistakes with their credit card companies, and then leave it to the companies to sort out, that will provide the motivation to the merchants to resolve these cases quickly. Trust me, the credit card company is NOT going to allow Travelocity to keep THEIR thousands of dollars for months at a time!

    This is not meant by any stretch of the imagination to discount what Christopher did here. It sounds like, by the time the OP contacted him, too much time had already gone by to involve the credit card company. They do have a time limit. At that point, Christopher really WAS their only option.

    So the lesson here is: PAY ATTENTION TO YOUR BILLS! And if you get a fraudulent charge, DISPUTE IT, provide adequate documentation to prove your dispute, and let the companies involved hash it out.

    One final note: to all the people in here saying they’d never use Travelocity – sometimes you DO get a better deal from these online agencies IF you are buying a package – air, room, car. I have seen a number of situations in which purchasing each of those items separately is more expensive than buying as a package from Travelocity or Expedia. So it’s entirely possible that’s what this OP was doing. However, I have to agree that if you’re talking strictly about flights, there is simply no reason to not go directly to the airline. I have never seen a flight at a lower price on one of the online agencies than I could purchase from the airline directly.

  • http://http/aol.com barbie45

    Chris, as usual you did an excellent job in resolving this nightmare. I hope this query is not off topic,but are there travel attorneys available who handle customer travel complaints ? The reason I inquired is that I noticed in a UK travel blog references being made to attorneys or solicitors who deal with problems such as this one. I believe this problem could have been avoided if the OP had booked with American directly.

  • dcta

    I’m confused. Shouldn’t they be receiving a refund of $1384.00?

    Of course Bley’s Travel Agent said to try calling Chris – if Bley booked on Travelocity, there’s nothing his/her Travel Agent can do with that. S/he can’t see the record and does not work for Travelocity. Had Bley booked with his/her Travel Agent, the TA would have been responsible and then could have done something with it. In the meantime – took almost a year with Chris’s help anyway….

  • Jackie

    “We have contacted AA and they have agreed to refund $346 per ticket for a total of $1086. We will refund the $75 cancellation fee for each ticket.”

    Meaning… AA is refunding $346 X 4 tickets – $75 Cancellation per ticket = $1086

    But wait! There’s more…

    Travelocity is refunding the $75 per ticket, so…

    $1086(AA) + $300 ($75×4) = $1384.

    TADA!

    Though, I agree with most of the posters here, I would have gotten my CC company involved from the beginning.

  • Joe Farrell

    thank you for calling the quickie mart [in your best subcontinent accent please] = oh, wait, I am sorry sir, thank you for calling travelocity, oh, wait, this is expedia thank you very much, my name is Chuck, how may I not help you today. . . .

  • David Z

    Are they that much less expensive?

    In some cases, sadly yes. Not to mention one doesn’t really hear this happen often, especially if one maybe does a Google or Bing search.

    If travel providers were to maybe share how many called to complain of issues like this versus how many bought tickets and didn’t have issues, the results might be…interesting to say the least.

  • Karen Kinnane

    This is another reason for dealing directly with airline, hotel and rental car company. Use Kayak or similar search engine which doesn’t get involved with collecting you money, to find a good price. After a brief run around, I’d have sued Travelocity in small claims court, got a judgment, and if they didn’t refund the money within two weeks of the judgment and a certified letter from me to Travelocity with copy of judgment, contacted the state Attorney General for consumer affairs. This office can issue an injunction to prevent Travelocity in your state until your judgment is paid. Normally the small claims victory is enough to get satisfaction, if not a brief letter from the AG’s office will do the trick.

  • http://http/aol.com barbie45

    If you have problems going through the proper channels and our having problems with a credit card dispute or cannot reach Chris consider Small Claims Court. I recently read of a person who was quite succesful . He recieved not only his money back,court costs plus interest, and compensation for the aggravation. Remember judges also have had unpleasant experiences.

  • Sarah Di

    Yes, they can be less expensive, especially if you need to use two different airlines due to a tight schedule or high cost of a particular flight. And most people who book using third party websites never have any problems. Recently, I was forced to book flights for two people through Expedia because Delta’s website was having such technical issues that I couldn’t even get to the page to view available flights. It was the last two seats on a couple of the flights and if I didn’t book them right away, they would have been sol and we would have had to choose entirely new flights. Expedia worked very well for me in that situation.

    To be honest, in this case, couldn’t someone at the airline have done the same thing if they had booked directly with the airline? There are technical glitches everywhere, not just on third party sites.

  • Ernest

    I called Travelocity immediately and somebody from India told me that we should get a refund from American Airlines for four of the tickets.

    Not only will I NOT deal with these 3rd party agencies but I have stopped dealing with any company that uses the India call centers. Most of the time I can not understand their version of the English language but they are no better than monkies reading a script off of their computer screen.

    I understand it is cost effective to use them and it has limited many of the firms that I use but I perfer speaking to a person that I can understand. I speak 3 languages but heavily accented Indian/English is not of of them. I don’t think I am a bigot, just a tired consumer who wishes that people llike Chris were no longer needed.

  • http://http/aol.com barbie45

    Ernest, you are right on target. Trying to deal with a heavily/ accented Indian/ Englih accent is useless.I always ask to be put through to a n American. Lately though quite a few have English as a second language which places you almost back to .where you were before. The only solution is to ask for an American and pray English is his first language. You are not a bigot by any means .Unless you live in the country you really cannot understand all the nuances involved in the language. I can speak French fairly well but would have a fairly difficult time unless I were there for a while in order to learn the slang and nuances.Also Spanish spoken in Latin America is quite different from Castilian Spanish in Spain.

  • Carver

    Its funny

    Living here in Silicon Valley, the heavily accented Indian accent now sounds like regular English to me. Call centers are aren’t problem for me except that the folks there are very script oriented. They have trouble deviating from the script. I wonder why? Poor training perhaps?

  • dmo

    As an airline agent, I had a customer with 9 tickets (same flights etc). He purchased them on the internet (Priceline?one of the dot-coms.) I asked if he had 8 brothers with the same name? And explained what the customer did when purchasing the tkts online (he kept clicking because the process was slow-and each click was a ticket). If it was within 24 hrs I could have refunded 8 tickets, but more than a week had passed. So I checked him in (one tkt), and cancelled the other 8 reservations. Which made those tickets “receipts for cash, although still non-refundable.” Now a problem exists, some agents would charge $75 per ticket to exchange for future travel. But since the reservations were cancelled prior to travel, my position is exchange them for the value against his next purchase, and any balance (if less) for an MCO for future travel. (MCO is a kind of airline check with restrictions-depending on the value.) I attached a note to each electronic tkt with the story). You have to remember one thing, he booked 9 seats and 8 of them no-showed, so there should be some penalty (maybe a 1-time $75 charge). He walked away happy at least.Never heard from him after that day (told him to call me personally if he had any questions.)

  • Bill

    I would like to add that I have had refund issues that have been resolved:
    - I mistakenly clicked on the wrong month while making a booking at Expedia. Once I made the purchase, I realized I had made the trip seven weeks long instead of two. I called Expedia customer service, and they cancelled it. I was not even billed. It was my mistake and they invoked their “cancel within 24 hours” policy. I couldn’t ask for more.

    - I had to cancel two Air Canada tickets to London. I had also bought lounge access. The agent on the phone refunded the lounge access immediately but the refund of the tickets did not show up, even after weeks. I looked on Air Canada’s website and they said to contact them if you do not receive refunds within 10 days – so I did. The phone was busy so I tried email, quoting the ticket numbers.

    I received a response stating that the tickets had already been refunded. I emailed back and explained that those refunds were actually for lounge access and not for the actual tickets. I received a response shortly thereafter confirming the correct amounts of refund – once I had pointed out to her what had gone on.

    I received credit on my credit card statement a few days later.

    There was an issue, but there was obviously a helpfup person who does have common sense on the other end of the line at Air Canada and it got resolved very quickly once I pursued the recommended avenue. It took only a couple of hours really.

    It blows me away how these seemingly simple issues have to go all the way to Chris – but at the same time, I am glad he is there because in some places, there is a lack of common sense and someone who is excellant at these things is needed – and Chris is top notch.

  • http://www.flightsite.co.za Laniece

    I would have totally freaked out if a third party travel agency had taken forever to refund me with my money, and not even to say because it was their fault. I mean how does a professional travel agent make such a huge mistake and then not even bother to make an effort to help you get your money back.I would still go through some travel agencies any day, as some of them are quite handy!