The Murphys’ vacation in Punta Cana did not go well

Remember Murphy’s Law — anything that can possibly go wrong, does?

Well, meet the Murphys: Kevin and Amber Tait, who booked their 27th wedding anniversary at the Gran Bahia Principe in the Dominican Republic through CheapCaribbean.com.

Their vacation did not go well. Not at all.

When they landed on the island, they were dropped off at the wrong hotel. They waited in the rain for an hour for a ride to their resort. They had reserved an ocean view room, but when they checked in, the property was out of oceanview rooms.

That was the best part of their vacation, it turns out.

Amber Tait writes,

I’m disabled due to a rare neurological problem and diabetes. I went into the hot tub in my room, and woke up the next day with bumps that itched. They turned into open sores and my husband caught them from me.

The toilet in their room didn’t work. The all-you-can eat buffet at the property was covered with flies. The Tait’s room was infested with cockroaches and centipedes.

And then, mercifully, their vacation ended. But not before one final insult: Their ride to the airport didn’t show up.

“A gardner took us to the airport in an old truck,” she recalls.

The experience left the Tait’s with $550 in medical bills and deeply disappointed. “I was in misery,” she says.

The resort wouldn’t answer their emails and CheapCaribbean.com offered her what appeared to be a form apology.

I contacted CheapCaribbean.com to get its side of the story. Here’s what it said:

On June 21, 2010, Mr. Tait contacted our sales department at CheapCaribbean.com to purchase a vacation package he had seen advertised for the Gran Bahia Principe in Punta Cana.

Our agent quoted Mr. Tait for the travel dates of July 21 – 29, 2010, in a “Junior Suite Club Golden” room, with airport transportation (transfers), and our Complimentary Hurricane & Weather Protection. Mr. Tait informed our agent that the trip was for their 25th Wedding Anniversary, so our agent advised him that we would put in a request for an “Ocean View” room, but we could not be assured they would be given it.

Our agent advised the client that the property was rated as a 3 ½ Suns (we use “Sun” ratings) out of 5 possible. The agent covered a list of the resort amenities available, and gave step-by-step instructions on how to view this resort on our website. The agent offered travel insurance, which the client opted to not purchase.

As I am sure you know, most travel experts recommend travel insurance for international travel to protect the client for unexpected issues that may arise prior to or during a vacation. The agent then covered CheapCaribbean.com’s “Terms & Conditions”, which the customer agreed to, after which the customer’s credit card was charged and the clients’ travel documents were emailed to them.

Upon the clients’ return from their vacation, we received a complaint regarding issues they had while at the resort. Customer Service is of the utmost importance to CheapCaribbean.com, and we take every client complaint very seriously. We forwarded the client’s complaint to the Gran Bahia Principe in Punta Cana, for their response. While awaiting a response from the resort, we sent our client an apology and offered them $100 in “Sun Dollars”, which can be used for future travel through CheapCaribbean.com.

The Gran Bahia Principe in Punta Cana informed us that they did not have any record of the client visiting the resort’s medical facility about their ailment while in the destination. Additionally, they have not had any other complaints of this kind of illness at the resort, even though many guests have stayed in that same room both prior and subsequently to Mr. & Mrs. Tait’s visit.

With no other complaints, the lack of a medical record while at the resort, and Mrs. Tait’s other ailments that she listed, the resort does not feel they can be held responsible for this unfortunate illness. We have worked closely with both the resort and their parent company about this issue, on behalf of our client, but there is no actual evidence that the client contracted their illness at this property. Therefore, the hotelier does not feel they should accept the liability or offer additional compensation to the client.

I contacted Mrs. Tait last week to let her know the resort’s position and that there was nothing more that we could do. Mrs. Tait told me that she was not looking for money, but would like another vacation as compensation. Unfortunately we are not able to give away vacations as customer service gestures, especially when we cannot validate the reason for her illness.

Gran Bahia Principe in Punta Cana is a well known and regarded resort. Trip Advisor and Expedia both rate the property at 4 stars, and Yahoo Travel and Hotels.com rate it at 4.5 stars (out of 5 possible). Literally thousands of guests travel to this resort, and the other Bahia properties, annually, yet I was unable to find a history of this type of ailment at their property while doing a search on the internet.

We express our sincere apologies for any difficulties our client may have encountered. Our aim is to always provide the best service possible to our customers.

I’m not sure if there’s anything more that can be said. No one disagrees that the Taits had a very, very bad vacation. But how much of it was the resort’s fault, and how much of it was just bad luck?

(Photo: carLe StyLe/Flickr Creative Commons)

  • Walt Blackadar

    I’m a bit dubious on their claims, even though I usually take the side of the traveler.

    First, she seems to have stretched the truth about the ocean view room. Starting off your complaint with a seemingly misleading statement isn’t going to help. Also, ocean view rooms are nice, but not a necessity. At a resort you’re not generally in the room all that much and the beach is just out the back door of the hotel. Maybe that’s a misunderstanding, so let’s move on.

    The rash may be entirely unrelated to the hotel. For all anyone knows, she could have caught it at home or on the airplane. If it wasn’t important enough to bring to the attention of the medical staff then, I’m not sure why we should care now. Also, I’m not sure why it’s relevant that she’s disabled…why is that comment even in there? Is that to elicit some sort of sympathy?

    As for the rest – if the buffet was covered in flies and there was an “infestation” of centipedes and cockroaches, I think I’d have some photographic evidence. As it is, there’s NO way I’d stay in a room “infested” with bugs and I doubt many other people would either. Most people would vocally complain, demand another room and/or switch hotels entirely. You simply wouldn’t wait until your vacation was over to complain about such things. So I’m quite skeptical of the bug claims because it just doesn’t ring true.

    So as far as I can tell, perhaps the only legitimate complaint is the transportation. That’s not worth a new vacation. Nowhere near that. This email sounds like it’s filled with a laundry list of half-truths (or mistruths) in an effort to get a free vacation. So unless more evidence comes forward to support the OP, I can’t muster any sympathy for her.

  • DChamp

    The resort was right.. if they never went to the medical facility there, and told nobody there of their problems, they’re not liable.
    Now, what about the transfer no-shows?? They completely disregarded that.

  • Raven

    Sounds like people just fishing for freebies. I know if I was made THAT sick by a hotel, I’d speak up on site, see a doctor, and take photos of the mysterious rash.

  • Phil

    You get what you pay for and sometimes you do get an upgrade. I have clients who buy the most inexpenisve package to a resort and expect to have an ocean view or ocean front room when they have paid for a garden view. I always inform them that I will make the request to the hotel, BUT the hotel has the final say in the matter, it is NEVER guaranteed that the request will be honored.

  • Mike Z

    Wow, that has to be one of the best responses from a vendor/travel supplier that I have read here. They covered the real meat and potatoes of the problems (though they did skip the transportation aspect) and addressed each with a lengthy and valid explanation.

    What I find troubling is “Mrs. Tait told me that she was not looking for money, but would like another vacation as compensation” Excuse me!!! That IS looking for money. In fact, probably about $1,000 worth. Stuff isn’t free and it costs someone. The lack of evidence in photos and documented complaints leads me to side with the resort given what was in the story.

  • Kevin

    Walt hit it head on with this one:
    Dropped Off at the Wrong Hotel – Did they even open their eyes when they got out?
    Waited an Hour in the Rain – Could they not go inside and wait where they were dropped off?
    Ocean View Room – How much time are you really spending in your room? If you want to view the ocean, walk down to the beach.
    Disabled – How does that even fit into the story?
    Bumps that Itched and turned into sores – Did you scratch them until they turned into sores? Did you seek Medical Help there?
    Toilet didn’t work – Did you report it to the hotel?
    Flies on the Buffet – Was it outside? Most resorts are pretty open so flies around the buffet are not completely uncommon.
    Room Infested with Bugs – Did you report it to the hotel?
    Ride to the Airport didn’t show up – When were they supposed to pick you up and when did you show up?

    I am actually surprised you took this on Chris. This is clearly a case of someone simply spitting out as many lies as possible to try and get a free vacation. I am actually surprised that CheapCarribean gave them anything. This is one of those customers that you don’t mind running off and never getting repeat business from.

  • Leslie

    I was very surprised to see a situation involving Cheap Caribbean here. I have heard nothing but good things about them and I know several people who work there. They’re a great company who employ great people, and they actually do strive to take care of their customers – a rarity anymore!!

    Unfortunately, unless the Taits have some sort of documentation or made a formal complaint to the hotel’s manager before they left, they really don’t have a case to request another vacation from Cheap Caribbean.

    Also, without Mrs. Tait having a medical visit to a clinic or a doctor, she has no way to prove that the rash she contracted was a result of something in her room or because of her medical condition.

    Somehow I think there may be more to this story than meets the eye…

  • http://www.singleparenttravel.net John Frenaye

    #1 someone that is disabled due to a rare neurological disorder certainly should have had travel insurance. Period.

    #2 transfers TO the hotel. Typically these are contracted vans and will drop off at several hotels. Did they just get off the bus at the wrong hotel? In all honestly, language can still be an issue in the DR if you do not speak Spanish and I can see a local transfer driver not being too well versed in English.

    #3 Flies on the buffet. Gross? Sure. But this is summer in the Carribbean. You can go to ANY resort or ANY private home and you will see flies on any open food. Deal with it or don’t eat at the buffet.

    #4 Infested rooms. Valid complaint if it was valid. Like it was pointed out above, who the hell sleeps there. Now if there were a few bugs passing through, reference #3 above–it is the Caribbean. They probably had lizards too.

    #5 If you develop a medical condition that results in a rash, and grows to open sores that are easily transmitted to other individuals. This is something serious. You need medical attention, not a free vacation!

    #6 Missed transfer on the way back to the airport. Totally valid, and they have $100 to use.

  • Jennifer

    Unless a client actually tries to resolve the issue while in destination, there would be no record for the hotel to use to back up any customer service complaint, medical, room issue, etc. Being very familiar with that resort, I find the issues with the main buffet unsettling. The buffet is indoors there, and while many of the resorts in the DR have outdoor buffets and there are flies and birds and bees that can buzz around them, Bahia in general has excellent standards with regard to food safety and in general by comparison to many other resorts in the area, their food quality is excellent. However, food is VERY subjective in the DR
    If the clients had done any research at all on the resort, they would have learned that the hotel doesn’t actually sell an oceanview room category. Like most of the resorts in the DR, its laid out beach, then pool, then room blocks, then lobby, so oceanview rooms are very very limited (and the resort is huge). Given that the clients never asked for a room change or went to the dr. onsite, the only issue I see is the transfers, where Cheap Caribbean could have refunded the return transfer the client didn’t use (but the client would have probably been insulted when they only got $20 back guessing on the actual cost of the transfer). Think they handled it well. Looks like they did everything they could to advocate for the client.

  • Jeanne in NE

    My mother has diabetes and has problems with bathing, showering, etc., so I have some sympathy for Mrs. Tait. Some people have bad reactions to the chemicals that are used to keep hot tubs clean, or the cleaning chemicals used in those. But, her husband *caught* the rash from her? My first thought was chickenpox, which is not caused by immersion in a hot tub. I’ve never caught a rash from my mother related to her problems with impaired circulation (from the diabetes) and bathing.

    As re the transfers, I think I would have had words with the management when I finally arrived, assuring myself that the transfer back to the airport would occur on time and in proper manner. If the Taits did so, I do think the hotel owes them an apology and/or compensation. I’ve done landscaping work and those trucks aren’t for the delicate of constitution.

    As for bugs in the room – I found one in my kitchen a few minutes ago, and I’m not even in the tropics. Centipedes – okay, they’re sneaky like that. Cockroaches – NO! Those can be addressed.

    I’m going to assume that the Taits are telling the truth, because small things that normally could be overlooked become big when so many of them happen. Why didn’t the other complaints get addressed? If there was no record of the rash being reported to management/medical staff, what about the plugged toilet, missed transfers, bugs in the room?

  • Sarah Di

    Convenient that a free vacation will happen to make things all better. I sympathise with them, but if these were such big issues that it warrants a free vacation, why isn’t there any record of notifying the resort while they were there?

  • ronda

    I would’ve gotten seen by they’re first aider for those sores… they dont sound healthy, and it was obviously contagious if the husband caught them from her.

  • http://www.sanibel-rentals.net Sylvia

    Putting aside my fond feelings for the Dominican Republic and how accommodating staff at the resorts are, I was left with one question.

    You had a really rotten time and you want to go back (for free)?

    Why?????

  • Tom

    The got Cheap Caribbean not Luxury Caribbean.

  • Rose

    My husband and daughter and I all got a nasty rash from a hot tub at a very nice rental house in the Catskills. Parasites and bacteria can live in hot tubs, apparently (google “hot tub rash”). So I can believe that they contracted a skin problem from the hot tub. But if they knew or thought it was from the hot tub, why on earth didn’t they notify the hotel? The whole story is weird to me. They continued on with their vacation, covered in open sores, and didn’t seek treatment until they got home?

    The toilet didn’t work? What does that even mean? They stayed in a room with a non-functional toilet for a week? What bathroom did they use when they needed a toilet? And again, isn’t this something one would notify the hotel about, right away?

  • Brian C

    I tend to agree with most of the commenters here. This seems like the Taits may have exagerated their claims a bit to get a free vacation.

    They obviously didn’t have a stellar time on their vacation and are looking for a scapegoat.

    Without documentation of a complaint while at the resort it appears these grievances weren’t as bad as they make them out to be. While being dropped off at the wrong hotel is partially the driver’s fault, I believe the Taits should take some responsibility for this as well. These resorts have signs and names on the exterior. Can they not read? I’ve had taxis try and dump me at the wrong location, but I didn’t fall for it.

    I believe the $100 in sun cash is more than sufficient compensation for the inconvenience they experienced.

  • Laura

    Well, you get what you pay for.
    If the trip was to celebrate a significant event, why would they have used a 3 star hotel thru Cheap Caribbean? Would you shop at Walmart if you were attending a black tie event? Probably not.
    Resorts rarely look as good online as they do in person. And sure you can find tons of reviews, but are any of these people staking their professional reputation on the outcome of your trip? Probably not.
    Find a travel professional who has personally been to the resort or destination that you’re considering within the last three years, and you’re likely to have a better outcome than what these people did.

  • Carver

    I have a slightly different take. I think that the Taits are telling the truth as far as they see it. I think the real issue is that the Taits are very inexperienced travelers who don’t understand that you complain on the spot, not when you get home.

  • Steve

    @Carver: I agree…what I really don’t understand is why the Taits did not complain more about these issues while on site, particularly since they were on vacation in another country. Any issue you have is going to be more likely to be resolved to your satisfaction while you’re on the premises, and it also gives you the chance to get the problem fixed and enjoy the rest of your vacation.

  • Datanerd

    This story just screamed out to me “TAKE PICTURES”. I have actually been in a hotel room once where we had several nests of spiders hatch and had hundreds of little ones climbing all over the blinds. I can empathize. With pictures, you can show the desk clerk easier what is wrong in the room, and what you want made right, right then. And if they don’t, you can upload them to the internet when you get home to send to the travel agent and Chris Elliott (and TripAdvisor).

  • Ed

    the vacationers did not have any substantiating proof of their issues…they didn’t contact the travel company when their ride dropped them off at the wrong hotel…they didn’t contact the hotel about the rashes, or the bugs, they didn’t contact the travel company when their ride back to the airport didn’t arrive…These people are either the most naive travelers ever or they are trying to scam the travel company.