Straight talk about the truly dismal state of airline baggage, and what it means to you

To get an idea of how badly airlines might treat your luggage in the summer of 2010, consider the latest offer by The Stafford London by Kempinski. It’s called the “Baggage Emergency Response Squad.”

I’m not making this up.

The squad is on call 24 hours a day, so that when weary travelers step off the plane and walk to the baggage claim, only to find their luggage didn’t arrive with them — despite paying a significant checking fee — they have somewhere to turn. Obviously, the airlines aren’t doing the job.

Here’s what you get from the property’s veteran concierge:

1. Immediate First Aid – Upon arrival, guests receive their own “First Aid Kit.” These customized, complimentary packs are stocked with essential personal items and are tailored for both men and women.

2. Hostage Negotiations – While the guest is relaxing in the comfort of their suite, the squad will consult with the airlines on the guest’s behalf to ensure expedited arrival of the detained luggage.

3. Quick Cleanup – To ensure guests have a fresh start the next day, the squad can also provide fast, complimentary laundering of arrival clothes. Immediate shopping on behalf of the guest to replace necessary items such as a suit for the next’s day’s business meeting can also be arranged.

A little dramatic, don’t you think?

Perhaps not.

We could always got to the Transportation Department statistics on lost and misplaced luggage, but a few examples might illustrate the point better. Here’s one:

This is Richard Martin’s story of battling American Airlines unsuccessfully to receive reimbursement for a road bike that was broken beyond repair on a European flight last year.

While waiting to board his plane he saw his bike box torn wide open on the JFK International runway tarmac. He immediately notified attendants on the plane, who contacted the crew on the ground. He was reassured by the American Airlines crew chief that his bike “looked a lot worst than it was” and that his bike was “fully inspected and is in perfect working order.”

As soon as I saw my bike at my final destination, I knew that I had been lied to. I expected to see a few dings in the bike but the frame was cracked through in multiple places and severely destroyed beyond repair. The only way that could have happened is if my bike had been run over.

Oh, by the way, among the major carriers, American performed the worst on the latest DOT report, with more than three lost-lost luggage incidents per 1,000. For the month of April, it “misplaced” 17,889 bags.

Maybe airlines know they won’t be able to safely transport your luggage.

Here’s what happened to Kim Usiak when she dropped off a friend at Miami International Airport on Friday.

They pulled out a new, one-page “declaration of responsibilities” (written in Portuguese) which they were now requiring passengers to sign.

We requested an English version but were told they had none. The basic translation of the document was that TAM was relinquishing all liability for baggage.

We told the ticket counter rep we disagreed and would not sign at which point she contacted a TAM supervisor.

The supervisor arrived and told us that if we did not sign the document she would instruct the ticket counter to remove our luggage from the plane. The supervisor was extremely rude and as I was about to open my iPhone to record the conversation so we could later file a complaint with the airline when I was told that they would contact the airport police and have us arrested if I did not put my phone away.

Usiak checked with a TSA supervisor and the police, both of which said TAM was wrong. But her friend signed the agreement, because she didn’t want to miss her flight.

I’ve asked TAM to comment on the incident and will update this post when it responds.

What does all of this mean to you? When it comes to checked baggage, the less, the better.

Airlines lose luggage. Given a chance, they’ll lose yours this summer.

  • KathyJ

    What is “TAM”? Why Portuguese? I can only surmise she was flying to Brazil. . .

  • cjr

    Christopher, considering the state of the airline industry now, and this story you’re getting regarding TAM, just wait another 4-6 years from now when Brazil will be hosting both the 2014 World Cup and 2016 Summer Olympics. If you’re still in the consumer advocacy business, I expect you’ll be kept plenty busy. :)

  • TimD

    What amazes me is the lack of consumer protection in this regard. Why are there no legal repercussions for airlines that lose your bag. The airlines protect themselves by hiding behind postal fraud laws and refuse to even look at a claim that is sent through any other means such as email.
    I’m currently battling an airline for a bag that they lost on a flight from BOS to JFK. Since I went on to Ethiopia (where I still am) I do not trust the postal service enough to mail the appropriate documents – so after waiting for weeks for a response to my emails I was finally told on an expensive phone call that they won’t do anything until they receive my original signature through the U.S. postal service.

  • CPP

    @KathyJ: or Portugal – they do speak Portuguese there :)

    I wouldn’t want to sign anything I couldn’t read, and it’s pretty ridiculous that an airport in the USA had no English language documents. She probably would have been within her rights to refuse until an English translation was available, but would not have made her flight…the airlines will usually win in situations like this because they can hold that over our heads.

    It’s really awful about the bike – I’ll bet that was a pretty expensive model; hope his vacation wasn’t completely ruined; how was it resolved? Did the airline reimburse him or replace the bike with the same model?

  • David

    KathyJ:

    Portuguese is commonly spoken in Brazil. TAM is the largest airline in Brazil.

  • Carver

    There is some critical information that is missing from this story. The most obvious relates to the 17,889 misplaces luggage in April. 1)How many bagsg do the airlines carry per month? 2)Of the “misplaced bags, what is the resolution? How many are permantly lost vs, how many a returned with a reasonable time, say a couple hours? That will put the 17,889 number in context.

  • SirWired

    You’d have to consult an attorney, but I’m pretty sure that you can’t waive your rights to baggage liability entirely, no matter what they make you sign. An international flight has to conform to the Warsaw Convention (?) for baggage liability. Period. They can print whatever they want in their Contract of Carriage, the ticket, or a signed waiver; they simply cannot lower those limits. I would think a complaint with the FAA might cause them to reconsider this policy.

    This would be a fairly easy issue to litigate in Small Claims, as the laws are pretty straightforward, and collection shouldn’t be too tough against an airline, especially if your jurisdiction offers “till tap.” (The sheriff stands behind the counter and seizes any cash that flows across the counter…)

  • Ed

    Again…If the airline is now charging to transport your baggage along with you to your destination, then your baggage should be subjected to the same regulations and benefits that come from using a separate shipping company. The airlines voluntarily separated the luggage from the ticket price, to benefit them. I think that if they want to get into the package shipping business (which paying for luggage outside of your ticket purports to be) then if they damage the goods of the package that they are entrusted to ship based on your bill of lading, they should reimburse the full replacement price of the item lost or damaged. Simple as that!

  • oregon

    @carver- misplaced still equals lost. When you are the only person left standing at the luggage carousel still waiting for that misplaced bag at that moment it is lost.

  • Drew

    American is the absolute _worst_ for losing bags.
    I came back from Europe back in February, and came into LAX via KLM, then transferred to American Eagle for the flight to San Jose, CA. I got my bag and cleared customs in LA, then dropped the bag off with the transfer baggage folks. I had almost 2 hours before my flight to SJC.

    I got to SJC, and no bag! I talked to the American baggage folks in SJC, and they assured me that it would be on the next flight up, arriving at 7pm. (I live about 100 miles south of SJC!) They assured me that it would arrive on the 7pm flight, and that I would get it that evening. Realize that this is Friday, and Monday is Presidents Day.

    I checked on the status of my bag on the American luggage site around 8pm, expecting to find it in transit to my home. It showed as still in LAX! I called the number, and was told that the bag ‘missed the cutoff for the 6pm flight’…

    Fast forward… around 10:30pm, I get a call from a courier, basically holding my bag hostage! “If we bring it down now, we’ll get there around 3am… otherwise, you won’t get your bag until Tuesday, since Monday’s a holiday!” At this point, I’ve been up since about 4am the day before–European time. I’ve been waiting for my bag, as I’ve got some items to take care of over the weekend, before I leave again.

    Around 3:30am, the courier shows up… and asks me how I’m going to pay for the delivery! I tell him that it was supposed to be billed to the airline, and that I want my bag. I’m very tired and cranky at this point. He says that the airline _did_ pay for the delivery, but how am _I_ going to pay for his time coming down here in the middle of the night? After I threaten to call the cops on him, he throws my bag down and literally burns rubber down my street….

    I contact American, and get a form letter “we’re sorry for your experience, but luggage does sometimes get lost.”… So now extortion goes along with breaking bikes and everything else?

    I go out of my way to avoid flying American (unfortunately, sometimes I have to do so, but…)… and this is just one of the reasons why!

  • http://www.tsalocks.net/ tsa locks

    Fist of all, I enjoyed the video. How can they possibly break the bike that badly?!? It looks like as if they are doing that deliberately…. American Airline has a bad reputation here in Australia too. Quite few customers of ours complained about their destroyed luggage and other belongings.