“It sounds like criminal activity to me”

Getting a ticket name change can be an uphill climb. / Photo by ykanazawa1999 - Flickr
And now, a little story about names, online travel agencies, airlines and the TSA.

Are you still with me?

Good. Because this could affect your next trip if you’re not careful.

Joanne Verdon just flew from Sacramento, Calif., to Philadelphia with her family, and learned “a very painful lesson,” she says.

She booked her tickets on United Airlines through Priceline.

“We never noticed until this past week that our friend’s last name showed up as Verdon — the same as mine and my daughter’s,” she says. “When I realized the error, I immediately called United, accepting that I would probably have to pay a $150 fee to change the reservation.”

The rules are no secret: The name of your ticket must match the name on your ID exactly or you won’t be able to fly. That makes sense, because the government checks the names against its “no-fly” list before departure.

It’s also common knowledge that airlines don’t allow name changes on tickets, sometimes even small ones to correct a misspelling. A big one, like changing a last name, is asking a lot, and is rarely granted.

Verdon continues,

United directed me back to Priceline, saying I needed to work with the travel agency. I called Priceline and was told United would have to authorize the name change, so I waited on hold with Priceline while they waited on hold with United.

Finally, Priceline got back on the line with me and said United would not authorize the name change. Per Priceline, United said all they could do was to put a note on the reservation but that would not guarantee that our friend would be able to board.

So neither Priceline nor United could or would help Verdon’s friend.

But wait! There’s more.

Priceline said our other option was to cancel the passenger’s first ticket and repurchase it. In this scenario, we would lose our payment for the first ticket and pay the current higher price for the new ticket and perhaps not have the same itinerary. This all sounded so bogus.

Finally, a United representative agreed to place a notation in the friend’s reservation.

“I asked how it worked and if we would be able to board the airplane,” says Verdon. “He said it depended on the airport.”

Oh, that’s reassuring.

So they went to the airport to get a better answer. A United representative verified that a notation would work. Even the TSA said it would be fine. But that wasn’t enough. Their return flight was on US Airways, and a US Airways manager told them they’d be denied boarding.

When we got home, my daughter called Priceline again, spoke to three different agents and, when they wouldn’t budge, ended up canceling Jonathan’s first reservation, forfeiting the $392 fare, and paying an additional $755 to rebook him on the same flight with the same seat assignments!

And this is all legal? It sounds like criminal activity to me.

You know what? It does to me, too.

Here’s the problem I have: The TSA wasn’t protecting us from terrorists by turning him away – and it wouldn’t have done so, anyway. Also, US Airways and United weren’t protecting their revenues by denying this passenger a name change or preventing him from boarding. They were just being pigheaded.

Priceline could have done more than parrot the airline’s policies. It should have advocated for their customer, which after all, is what travel agents are supposed to do, right?

There has to be a better way to verify a passenger’s identity. For example, if the passenger’s date of birth and phone number and first name are the same, then it’s a pretty good bet he’s the same person, and no one is trying to transfer the name on the ticket, which would theoretically cost the airline revenue.

  • TonyA_says

    Last July I had a ‘lucky’ experience being on the same Cathay 777 full of (mainland) Chinese kids from HKG to JFK. They did not speak a word in English and had a (lost and found) tag hanging from their necks. They gave all their passports and US forms to their (what look to me) teenage guides. The passport stacks were so high that they kept falling everywhere. When we landed in JFK, no one was allowed to deplane until US Immigration and Customs could make it to the door of the airplane. Then they asked US citizens to get out first. I did. The first thought in my mind – walk fast and get out of there. I wonder how they sorted out who was who in that airplane.

  • Joe_D_Messina

    A one-week boycott of an airline when they knew that business would come back the next week once the boycott shifted to some other airline wouldn’t send any message whatsoever.  This is as useless as the age-old “Let’s boycott the gas stations for a week” idea. 

  • TonyA_says

    From what I read the UA desk/gate agents in SMF would let him through, but the US agents in PHL won’t (on the way back). That verification was beyond just a simple notation.

  • Tawnylittel

    I just booked my flight reservations, before I could actually pay, they asked that I check to make sure all the information is correct, 3 TIMES!! AND it says the NAME HAS TO BE CORRECT. Geez please don’t sit the person next to me that can’t check a simple form to make sure they put their name in correctly. I am really tired of stupid people. Wah wah, I missed my cruise cuz blah blah blah….oops I put the WRONG LAST NAME on my flight reservation and now I need the airline to forgive me…uh no, 

  • http://www.facebook.com/asiansm Dang Ph

    Security psycho is more an American/British (the last recent empires) issues but not really big issue in Canada, Europe or Asia. Lately, in Europe and Canada, I left bottles of water by inadvertence but they all went thru.

  • TonyA_says

    Honestly, I have yet to come across a customer who really reads the rules. I end up having to read the rules for them and hope I guide them properly so they don’t hang me. The TA is always blamed for everything – the punching bag of the airline and the passenger. This can be a crazy job. And one way I have learned to cope with it, is to read Raven’s comments every morning and smile :-)

  • judyserienagy

    “US Airways and United weren’t protecting their revenues by denying this passenger a name change or preventing him from boarding. They were just being pigheaded.”  

    PIGHEADED is absolutely the correct term.  Easy to just reissue the ticket with the correct name. 

    Things are getting completely out of control.  Airlines are treating their customers like criminals.   I still think we should organize a “non-fly” week for every single person in the United States to force the airlines to start giving us some service for our dollars.

  • bodega3

    The OP made a mistake and could have had this corrected within 24 hours of purchase.  What don’t you understand about a restrictive ticket purchase?  There IS a reason why the carriers went to restrictive tickets and as I mentioned in a previous post, you have past ticket purchasers to thank for getting these strict rules put in place.  I own a business, do you?  We have gone to fees because everyone thinks their time and money is worth more than ours and want things done for free.

  • sershev

    If TSA did not have a problem with boarding with a wrong name as long as notation was made it shouldn’t been a problem since airlines are don’t check ID at the boarding gate. They should not even be telling US Air about the name discrepancy. Just print the boarding pass at home or at the kiosk and don’t check bags.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=544363929 Terri Lundberg

    I just recently did something similar this past April. Of course, since in my mind I’m a regular, seasoned, frequent flying, know it all passenger, I couldn’t believe it when I booked my mom’s ticket to visit me in Seattle that I had used my last name and her first name on the ticket.  I didn’t notice it on the confirmation.  I found out when my mother arrived in Seattle and she proceeded to tell me what I had done.  The counter agent was told her we typically charge $100 to do a name change, but we’ll do it for you, just this once.  And, it was done.  This was Alaska Airlines.  

  • Barfeld

    The drugs were in the COCKPIT.

  • emanon256

    So?  Multiple cleaning crews, maintenance crews, catering crews, flight attendants, and even other pilots all have access to the cockpit, and have been in it at multiple airports.  Again, it’s a common carrier, not the pilot’s private personal plane.  If it were a private personal plane, the story would be different.  Should a bus driver go to jail if someone brings drugs on the bus?
     
    By the way, the news stories all say that they found that the cocaine was placed there by a baggage handler who was caught and pled guilty.

  • emanon256

    So?  Multiple cleaning crews, maintenance crews, catering crews, flight attendants, and even other pilots all have access to the cockpit, and have been in it at multiple airports.  Again, it’s a common carrier, not the pilot’s private personal plane.  If it were a private personal plane, the story would be different.  Should a bus driver go to jail if someone brings drugs on the bus?
     
    By the way, the news stories all say that they found that the cocaine was placed there by a baggage handler who was caught and pled guilty.

  • TonyA_says

    I am surprised how many people think the agent is “pocketing” all or some of price difference to change a ticket. Unfortunately they have no clue how much work (and calling) goes into changing a ticket and agents don’t make anything unless they charge their own change fee ABOVE the and SEPARATE from the airline charges.

  • jerryatric

    Disqus generic email templateThen a far more lengthy boycott is needed. Else we keep getting “worked over”

  • jerryatric

    Disqus generic email templateSo to all you Americans, sit & do nothing & watch it get worse. On this trip I flew 3 different airlines & the cheapest was the best service! Priceline as an agent should go to bat for their client period instead of mouthing airline policies! Rented from Alamo & got to save a bundle on a 1 day sale, so no real complaints re car etc., only the guy who saw me leave the car with my GPS in it & took it to his hut hoping, I think, I had forgotten it.

  • Michael__K

    I read basically the same thing.  Sounded to me like the US Airways Manager was also in SMF (not sure if s/he contacted PHL personnel).

    Not sure what you mean by “That verification was beyond just a simple notation.”

    Looks to me like another example that fits the pattern of US Airways being more inflexible and difficult to deal with than its peers.

  • Raven_Altosk

    Resistance is futile. ;)

  • Raven_Altosk

    Tony,
    Didn’t people used to book tickets as “Passenger X” or something? I remember seeing a case here where a woman was using her TA to “hold” FC seats under bogus names and then releasing them at the last minute so she could score an upgrade.

  • TonyA_says

    I meant that if the desk/gate agent said they will board you then that is better than just a notation in a PNR (which they may not care to read).
    The airport agents hold the “key” to the plane. They will decide who will get in.

    I don’t know why USAir was playing hardball if UA was going to make a notation. For as long as USAir can lift the coupon and UA will pay them upon submission, then what’s the fuzz?

  • Raven_Altosk

    Can’t.
    Remember.
    Her.
    Married.
    Name.

    And this person is competent to travel without a caregiver!?!?

  • http://elliott.org Christopher Elliott

    TSA baiting? MOI? ;-) OK, fair point. I was feeling extra snarky when I wrote that.

  • Raven_Altosk

    Or they lie. I was in line behind a group of idiot college girls headed to spring break. One only had her fake ID which did not match her ticket. Her friend told her to tell the agent she was only 17.

    (This was prior to Secure Flight where you had to enter B-date)

    The girl went through security and boarded without incident. I had half a mind to say something, but, eh. I figured they’d lose what few brain cells they had left getting wasted.

  • TonyA_says

    Yes but if they catch you, your Mileage Membership is toast!!!
    Read this interesting story:  http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-0506-golden-ticket-20120506,0,7103119.story

    And for travel agencies – they will be fined heavily and lose their plates (or appointments).

  • emanon256

    I will become one with the snark.

  • TonyA_says

    We do have a lot of old clients since we are very patient :-)
    But this one really made me think twice whether I was still awake.

  • Michael__K

    Same idea, yes.  If they ding you for an honest mistake then (IMO) they ought to pay you when they mess up.

    Or they can recognize that we’re all human and follow the Golden Rule (which doesn’t necessarily mean fixing mistakes for free, just that mistakes are not a bonanza opportunity).

  • MarlaM

    I just don’t understand how she could have mistakenly entered the wrong last name for her friend.  Even though I’ve been with my boyfriend for many years, I can’t imagine any circumstances where I would accidentally enter his last name for mine or visa versa.  But I’m sure it can happen.  I saw in one of the comments that PL requires you to enter each person’s first and last names separately, so as unlikely as it seems, she had to have made the mistake.

  • Michael__K

    what’s the fuzz

    Exactly.  I gather either the revenue from the new ticket or maybe just a company culture of inflexibility.

  • TonyA_says

    That price point for SMF-PHL needs a 21 day advance purchase. So she needed a 24 day no-penalty rule; not a 24 hour one. :-)

    If people know that a one-way Y class non-restrictive fare costs upwards of $1600, then they will understand why a $390 round-trip ticket has ALL THE RESTRICTIONS under the sun.

    Sometimes people forget what they are buying.

  • TonyA_says

    Well that’s the difference between United and USAir. We lived in Sacramento about 20 year ago (2 of 3 sons born there). My wife has a big family there so we still visit. Her nephew is married to a UA FA who does Int’l routes from SFO. Before the LCCs flew there, United was our main choice. We and the rest of the family have never had problems with United. They are a good airline. [Cannot say what happened after the merger.]

    I avoid USAir for well known reasons. But I cannot blame a US Air employee (i.e. desk or gate agent) for telling the OP the truth that the guy will be denied boarding (for improper ID) since that is USAir’s policy. You cannot force an airline to be nice to you. All you can do is give your business to one that IS nice to you.

  • Barfeld

    Well, my point is that the criminal laws don’t apply equally to all persons. You offer various unpersuasive reasons why they shouldn’t, but the fact remains that they don’t.
    When it comes to areas that are not open to the public (such as the cockpit), the fact of being a common carrier is irrelevant.

  • lorcha

    I wouldn’t want to try to go through security with a fake ID. Much easier to fake the boarding pass.

  • bodega3

    This shows how little you know about airline tickets which is a problem due to the internet IMHO.  We don’t have airline Reps as we use to who would handle this for us.  We have to call, usually an agency desk with the carrier and it is their call, not ours.  If they won’t give us a waiver code we can’t do it or it we tried, we, not the passenger would get fined and it is taken out of our account that they have access to through ARC.  The fine can be anywhere from $50 to hundreds of dollars. 

  • bodega3

    It won’t happen.

  • emanon256

    And my point is that an airline is not a person. 

  • bodega3

    Southwest and Alaska are great to work with on this type of thing.

  • TonyA_says

    No Michael, I don’t believe they got good advice.
    Note UA was willing to transport him from SMF-PHL.
    So his only problem was coming back home on the USAir flight (codeshared by UA).

    The proposed solution by Priceline was to BUY a  new ticket for $755. Now that is ridiculous IMO.
    What he should have done is buy a one-way ticket from PHL-SMF from USAir on the same flight but with a different (correct) name. Right now that can be as cheap as $225 plus tax.

  • jerryatric

    Disqus generic email templateNo matter to me! I try to go straight to the company rather than Priceline or other on line travel companies. I tried Priceline for car rental first then went direct. Got the best deal from Alamo & went with them. I guess my biggest problem is watching SERVICE go down the drain everywhere. In some 50 odd years of travel, service seems to have been lost to profit & the client is the big loser. Travel is not the only area as tradesmen in every area have forgotten about it as well.

  • bodega3

    When customers are just numbers service isn’t priority and the airlines are not alone in this as stated.

  • bodega3

    Often going directly to the company doesn’t give you the best deal. How do you know you got the best deal?  You don’t. 

  • Michael__K

    I was wondering about that too.  $755 sounded high but plausible to me for a one-way ticket at the last minute.  Or is it possible that a last minute round trip was about the same as or cheaper than a one way? (I’ve seen that occasionally).

    Anyway, my point was just that the price for “fixing” the mistake was a bit out of proportion with the mistake.  If that price was higher than necessary because of bad advice, then that just makes it even worse.

  • Jeanne_in_NE

    Now c’mon, @sirwired:disqus , Raven is the only one on here on whom the title “Doctor of Snarkology” has been conferred.

  • TonyA_says

    I believe they sold him a new RT ticket. If I were him I do what I said above for $225 plus tax. Then I will check in at PHL as myself (correct name). Then I will also check in as my other self and get an empty seat beside me. That’s a lot cheaper than paying $150 + fare difference when you only have less than 10-7 days to go prior to Outbound departure. The Return is usually easier since that is farther away. So he had an easy problem with a wrong advice.

  • AUSSIEtraveller

    Is this woman a moron ?

    Hey I booked a ticket on a US airline. My name is Osama Bin Laden, but my real name is Obama Hussein (Bin laden) & am a close relative of the US president. Shouldn’t I get FREE travel on Air Force 1 (or 2 I don’t care)

    Why didn’t priceline & United just say to her, you have to buy a new ticket (you idiot) & next time learn to type before making a booking online !!!

    Another scenario …

    I booked a ticket, on XYZ air & my name is John SMith, but then I decided I didn’t want to go.

    So I made up this totally bogus story of how I typed my name wrong when I made the booking & it’s really Shirley Temple (I’m a cross dresser).

    But the airline wouldn’t go for it.

    Help me get my money back, because I deserve it, because I’m an idiot & also cross dressers should get special privileges that normal people don’t. It must be a really slow news day, if you’re even bother to write about how stupid people are & worse, they even admit to it.

    Maybe, this woman shouldn’t be allowed near a computer before she passes a basic IQ test.

  • AUSSIEtraveller

    Many airlines now offer name changes on tickets for a fee, sometimes substantial.

    Easy work for airlines (a lot more profitable than running an airline)

    If it’s too minimal a fee people wouldn’t take any care entering their name.

    Travel agent I dealt with last for ticket to USA, insisted that we email our names as per passport.

    Apparently, many people can’t even spell their names over the phone.

    It seems some Australians are as dumb as some Americans.

  • Raven_Altosk

    Yeah, I’m not advocating it, but I’m just remembering the case. It seemed like a total scam on the part of the TA and PAX.

  • scapel

    This is why I deal directly with the airline and not through a thrid party booking. Errors are easier to correct.  Bad enought the airline always changes the schedule without notifying me. I just keep checking the booking online to pick up changes.

  • bodega3

    A lot people don’t know their own name as it appears on their passport or DL and forget about the spouse calling to make their partner’s reservation.  Oh lordy, it does get interesting!

  • Michael__K

    Sure, *IF* the $225 fare was available for the flight in question.

    I do see your point that there’s a good chance they had 7+ or 10+ days until the return flight, in which case it seems improbable that the return flight alone would cost ~$755.