Can this trip be saved? Left high and dry by my resort

Club Med Sandpiper Bay is an all-inclusive resort near Port St. Lucie, Fla. — the perfect place to escape the cold December weather in Washington without having to spend hours on a plane. At least that’s what Jane Winfrey thought.

Back in April, she made a deposit for the week of Dec. 2 to 10 at hotel. But in late August, she received an apologetic call from Club Med representative. There was a problem with her reservation.

They were very sorry, but the entire Sandpiper has been reserved by a single client for Dec. 7 to 14 and they were therefore canceling the last three nights of our vacation, as well as everyone else’s reservations.

We’ve seen this kind of thing before.

Related: The smarter consumer: When to sue a company — and when to shame it.

The customer service agent outlined Winfrey’s options.

• Shorten their vacation by three nights.

• Visit another Club Med within the US for the same price.

• Cancel their entire vacation and receive a refund.

As compensation, Club Med offered a $100 credit per person, which could not be used toward to cover accommodations. (It could be cashed in for airport transfers or gift-shop purchases.)

Club Med also offered to reimburse Winfrey up to $200 for her airline change fees. But it wouldn’t cover any fare increases that resulted from its cancellation.

That doesn’t sit right with her.

To us, $200 to spend in the Club Med boutique just doesn’t cut it. I would have hoped the Sandpiper Club Med would preempt our complaint with a more gracious and generous offer.

I suggested that she send a brief, polite email to Club Med, letting it know she was disappointed and telling it exactly what it could do to make things right. Incidentally, I agree with her that it’s bad form to cancel a hotel reservation just because you have a better offer.

Club Med didn’t respond to her email in writing, apparently reluctant to have a written record of its offer. Instead, a representative phoned Winfrey again.

Their response was that the policy is firm – no other recompense. I feel it would have been more fair to offer a discount for the room charges on the nights which had to be changed – or to at least allow the credit to go toward room charges.

Also, $100 is somewhat paltry considering the cause of all this is that the whole club is being rented out for a week.

People with their own airline tickets will really be out of pocket. If they cancel their stay they are stuck with the tickets. If they alter their tickets’ dates to fit with the Club’s changes they will be reimbursed only for airline change fees, not any increase in fares. If a family bought airline tickets a few months ago and now must rebook them I would imagine the fares would be several hundred dollars higher.

Club Med shouldn’t have kicked Winfrey out of its resort for three days. If it did, it should have ensured she had alternate and comparable accommodations at no additional cost.

Having received two firm “nos” to her suggestion that it cover all of her costs, I’m not sure my inquiry would change the answer. If it did, then Club Med would be forced to extend the same offer to all of the guests displaced in December, which could cost it a bundle.

I’m not afraid to try, though.

(Photo: htt p2007/Flickr)

  • Eric

    Whew!  That was close.  I’m looking for a place to get away next spring and this one was on my list.  I think I’ll have to scratch this property from my list.  This is a totally bush-league move by the resort.  I hope she gets some sort of satisfaction.  They should offer to change her reservation to another week and completely cover her cost for re-booking flights, including any fare increase.

  • Eric

    Whew!  That was close.  I’m looking for a place to get away next spring and this one was on my list.  I think I’ll have to scratch this property from my list.  This is a totally bush-league move by the resort.  I hope she gets some sort of satisfaction.  They should offer to change her reservation to another week and completely cover her cost for re-booking flights, including any fare increase.

  • Eric

    Whew!  That was close.  I’m looking for a place to get away next spring and this one was on my list.  I think I’ll have to scratch this property from my list.  This is a totally bush-league move by the resort.  I hope she gets some sort of satisfaction.  They should offer to change her reservation to another week and completely cover her cost for re-booking flights, including any fare increase.

  • Eric

    Whew!  That was close.  I’m looking for a place to get away next spring and this one was on my list.  I think I’ll have to scratch this property from my list.  This is a totally bush-league move by the resort.  I hope she gets some sort of satisfaction.  They should offer to change her reservation to another week and completely cover her cost for re-booking flights, including any fare increase.

  • flutiefan

    sorry, have to disagree with your notion that someone looking to make a change to an existing res would not find the same prices as someone starting to look for a fare at the same time. that’s not how our computer systems work… they aren’t based on whether or not you have a flight already booked. the computer doesn’t care. the price is the price (given fare choices, dates, class of service, etc).

  • Euser101

    I will never stay there after this post.

  • Anonymous

    Any updates on this one, Chris? I’m dying to know. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=530479200 Dana Scheider

    If it’s going to do this it should first of all cover all the expenses the traveler incurs because of its reneging on the reservation and secondly not penalize the traveler (i.e. not keep their deposit) if they get a better deal elsewhere.

    Of course a hotel is not going to be completely empty, so if someone wants to book the whole resort then some people will be bumped. But there should be a time cutoff for this–e.g. if you want to book the whole resort you have to do it a year in advance–and people making reservations should be informed of the time cutoff up front (“We don’t guarantee reservations made over a year before the reservation date,” for example). That way they’d know not to book their flights or other plans until the reservation was confirmed.

    This definitely makes me less likely to book with Club Med, not because they canceled, but because they did so with such short notice and are treating her like a second class customer (when she was most likely going to paying MORE for her room pro rata than whoever booked the whole resort, since you often get a discount for that kind of thing).

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=530479200 Dana Scheider

    Pointing to these agreements to justify the resort’s actions doesn’t make sense. The fact that it has a policy like this at all is exploitative and shows an appalling lack of respect for paying customers. Now, for circumstances beyond their control I think they should return the deposit and not be liable for more – those things happen. But for things like this, I’m sorry, but this kind of policy should be illegal.